Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

! ,0 *G1 / 0,-,: *?1 : ,, : 1 ., <1 + : H 1 / 0 1 S-,; +K6 ?1-/,+7:,0 ?1-/,+ 1 1/ < T(1

0,0, 1 /,0 6 1 " =6 ?1 , " : H 51 1 , " ,0?1 -,:; 6 KL 1/ 0,0,51/, *6, 101-?1-<!1/ 0,0!K16 5-0 +7; ,-7?10> = 1-, ,51-!L ,-> 12 >1/ 0,0,5?1K 6 2-,51 6 * +7 ,-(1 7/ 0 6+ 0,1 /,62 0 1 4( (17 < ,11 I(((: , ,6 +71 <,= 1 !-0+ 0 71 1 + 1 > 1 K 6 2-1 , <>1 1/ H />?1 , 1 + 1 ,51/ 0,0,51-!-1+ H1 1, " : ; H 5?1 1, L-0 , 1/ 0,0, 1-,: 191-< 7-*1 1= + 71!-; ,0+ *1 1S + T1-, +K6 *1 G1!",6 ,1/ 01 1-0, ,6?1 G1 !",6 ,1/ 0,0>G1 = <,0?1 ,1-+ 1M ,1 1 !6 10,/+,L ,101 ; +7 ,<1/ 0,0,<1/, *6 ?1 ,1! ,0 71/ 0,0,51 !+7 ! >1016 ; ,<1 , L-0 1 -1 , = 71 1 6 +7 > 1 <, 0>1 1 -<+ ; *?1 1 ,?12 ,1-71 1-<,<16 + J%(1

,-+ 6,0 +7 , 1/ < 16 * +7 ,-,",1/,6G,6 1/ 0 ; +,1 1 00 6 K1 01 -+,0 71 -,H +7 ,;"!< >G1 ! 1 ", 1 I= : 7J?1 1 /+,6, 0, ,<!1 / < K?1 1 1 , ,+," 2-,<1 ! ,0 ?1 1 101 + : 1, L-0 101H +,<?1 G1 + 1 >G1 ",1-. 191-,; H +7 *1 = : 7?1 /,+ 2-*1 = : 71 1 (/(1 71 /,<,L7K1 ", 1 I= : 7J1 !6-*1 0> : 71 M " K?1 0 ,-7?1 H + / 0+ , 1

.! H , ,0 1 -,H +7 >G1 -! P ,0?1 -!H , +7 >G1 -! ! 1 1 (/(?101, " 2-,<1 6-0 16 < 2-,",1 1-2 ; -,",?1< +7 ,;/ 2-,",1 16!G,0 ,",1<,< ,016 * +7 ,; -(1 ,H--! +7 ,-71= : 1 ! 10 < *1 1 + :!1/, ,; -5?1-,01 1H ,-51!2-,01 ,",1 + 1 ,",10 6 16 * +7; ,-?1 , G,6 <,-1!2 >0 71 H , +7 > 1 1 H , +7 > 1

., <>1/,0 6 *1 1/,-!/ ?10,, L 1/-G,+," 2-!K1-,-0+*K; L!K1+K ,",10 6 12 +,0 2-,516 * +7 ,-(11

F 6 0 *16,+= , 16-!--, ,-1 1 : , ,-10,; / ,-?14( (1C +7 ,1 1 ( (1 ,. <,01-0 K 1 1,-, ,<1 ; ", +7 ,<1-!-?1 !2 ,51 ,0 : 1 1M0-2-,<1/, H + 1 /, * *1 3&3 656 1 -*?#1 /,-,+7 !1 -!L-0!KL G1 I2->G1 +," 2-G1 -H 5J16+*1/,: *10-",1< ,",, : *1/ 0,; 0>G1 *0+ 51 6,-,2 ,?1 01 ," 0 !K1 / !1 /,< <,1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(113DA C67(12 :(-,2(17(1#E#(1

#1( )C67 ' &7" 6BAD6F7' '(1 , ,;< ,6,+," 2-, 1: 2 1 , H /H 1I/ 0,; 0,51= : J1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$%$(1Q1'(1

-H 6 +7 ,",1-! P 1 , G,6 <,10 +K2 1M</ 2 ; -,",1 -! P 1 /,: *(1 3 :0 0 *1 . ,< ,+," 2-!K1 6 ; H K101--+ 6,0 1/ 0 ?1C(D(1 > 1-G,6 1 :1 ,",?12 ,1-, *1 / 0 1 -,6 = 1 < +,1 / < ,01 1 / 0,0>G1 , >2 0?1 , , > 10> = K 1/ 0,1 1= : >51/, >0?1 -G K?1 /,6; 6 KL!K-*1 H , +7 ,<!1 , P*-K(1 7+ 6! 1 /, * 7?1 /,1 1 < K?12 ,1/ 0,191M ,1/ 0,0 *1= : 7Y1 , < 0 *1 1-!; H , +7 *1 - +7 ,-71 , L-0 1 , -/ 2 0-*1 /,-,* ><1 , ,0+ <1 0-G1 M+ < ,01 / 0,0,51 -. >Y1 -< 1 / 0,0 *1 = : 71<,= 1 > 71,/ 6 + 1 1/ ,- -0,1,/> 1-! P; 0 ,",1 0: <,6 5-0 *?1 , !-+,0+ ,",1 -<>-+,<1 1 ! +7; ><1 < 2-<1-,6 = <1/ 0,0>G1 , <1 1H ,-5(1 ,; M ,<!?1! 0 =6 1 0 , ?1/ 0,1 1<,= 1 > 71+, + :,0 ,101: ; , G?1 , < G?1/ 0,, ,8 *G1 1 (6(?1 ,1/ 6-1I 1/ ,H--1 /, ,=6 *1-<>-+,0?1, :!KL G1 6-0,1-,H +7 ,1: 2 <>G1 1+ 2 ,-,1: 2 <>G1, ,016 * +7 ,-12 +,0 J%(1

,1 < K1 (1 0 1 1 (1 ,0 ?1 -,H +7 ,;/ 0,0 *1 = : 71/ 6-0+* 1-, ,51I-,0, !/ ,-71< ,",, : >G10 6,01 1

., <1 ,-! 0 ,51 -,0<-,51 6 * +7 ,-1 +K6 51 01 -. 1 / 0 ?1 / 0+ ,51 1, -/ 2 1!-+,0 51 1-6-01-!L-0,; 0 *?1 + : H 1 6 0 6! +7 >G1 1 , L-0 >G1 /, ,; -5?1 -,01 1 H ,-5J#(1 7/ 0 6+ 0,1 !*1 M !1 /,: ; H K1: 1!:,-71,G0 1*0+ 51/ 0,0,51-. >?14( (1C +7 ,1, < ; 2 10-7< 10 = !K16 +7191 0 , >1-0,6* 1/ 0,0!K1= : 71 ?1-,; , 0-0 ,?1 / 0,0!K1 6 * +7 ,-7?1 1 1 , < 0 ,51 ; / H 1S01,H ,2 ,<1-<>-+ T?1 1-!"! ,1/,: 0 ><1*0+ *<(1 C =6!1 <?1 / 0,0 *1 = : 71 -1 , G,6 <,-7K1 0 +K2 1 01 - *1 1/,-!/ ?1-, > *?1 >1 1 (6(?1,H 0 <> 1/,+,= +7 ,1-1 ,2 1: *1,. H +7 ,",?1",-!6-0 ,1-H , ,0 ,",1 / 0 ?1 1 1, H +7 > 1 2 + 191/ , 0,/ 0 > 16 * *1R(1U ; , ,6 +71/ ,0,:"+ 8 1,/ 6 + > 1/ 0,0> 1 6 +>?1!-; 0+ 0 1 1 + 1 > 1K 6 2-1 , <>1 1/ H />?1,/ 6 ; +* 1 , 1 + 1 ,51/ 0,0,51-!-1+ H1 1, " : H 5Y1<--,0, 1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%15-CA5 7( !1 ,< ,+," 2-*1< ,6,+," *11,/> 1--+ 6,0 *1/ 0 (1B ;! "?1#$$&(17(1%#&(1

#1 7<(11 4 3F7 ' &7 56F7 ' (1 F L *1 , *1 / 0 (1 8 *1 M H +,/ 6 *(1 ( ,0", ,6?1%EE&(17(#%(1

R1( )C67 '1 0,0 *1= : 71331F L-0 > 1 ! 1 1-,0 < ,-7(1%EEE(1Q1F(17(FF(1

1

!

= 1/ 0,-,: 191-<-*1 1= + 1!-,0+ *1 1-, +K6 ; *1-0, G1/ 01 1-0, ,6?1 ,1-+ 1 G10-2 , 160 = 1 1 !6 1 0,/+,L ,101 +7 ,<1/ 0,0,<1/, *6 1S-,+7 ,1M ,10,:<,=; ,T?1 ,1/ 0,0 *16 5-0 +7 ,-71016 ,<1, L-0 1-10>; = 71 1 6 +7 > 1<, 0>1 1-<+ *?1 1 2 ,1/ *<,1/ , ; 0,/,+,= , 1,. H +7 ><1+,:! " <191. 2-51/ 0,0,51/,; *6, ?1/,62-1 :: , >5101-0, G1 5 G1/ ,*0+ *G(1

I 1 < G1 , H /H 1 / 0,0,51 = : ?1 91 :0 0 K 1 M !1 6 K1 4( (1C +7 ,1 1 ( (1 ,. <,0?191-<1/ ,H--1/,: *1/ 0 1/ , ; 1 ,</+->51G ?1/,:0,+ 1,G0 710-71-/ 1/ 0, ; 2 +7 >G1 1/ , :0,6 >G?1-2-G1 16 < 2-G?1 , < 0 >G1 1 , < 0 >G?1/,+,= +7 >G1 1, H +7 >G?1, " :,0 >G1 1 , " :,0 >G?1 < +7 >G1 1 6!G,0 >G1 / 0,0>G1 *0+ 5?1

,P 6 71 G101 6 >51 ,</+-?1/, : 71 G1 1-!<<!1/ 0,0,51 = : J%(1 <1 -<><1 / 0,0 *1 = : 71 -,0-*1 " ,0 ><1

,P ,<1, L 51 , 1/ 0 ?1I/ 0,0,51<- -<,5J?1, >0 K; L 51 ,0> 1", :, >1 1"+! >1--+ 6,0 *1/ 0 (1

: 0 *1 -<, 1, L 16 + 12 +,0 2-,516 * +7 ,-1 1 ,-! 0 !K?1-,: 6 +7 !K191 16-! 0 !K?1M ,/ 5; !K?1<>16,+= >1-/ ,-* 71M !1 +--. H K1 1 1/ 0,; 0!K1 6 * +7 ,-7?1 / 0,0!K1 = : 7(1 F 1 0 +K2 101 - *1I-,0,; !/ ,-71/ 0,0>G1 ,01 1 >G1 ., <1/ ,*0+ *1/ 0 1S01 ,<1 2-+ 1 " 0 >GT?1G :!KL G1-/ H . !1 1! ,0 71-!L ;

-0!KL 51K 6 2-,516 5-0 +7 ,-?1, ,8 1-! P ,01 1 / 0!1 1 -/ 71!6,0+ 0, *1 G1-,0J#(1A * +7 ,-, 1 /, < 1/ 0 1 1= : 1/,:0,+* 10> : 710-1., <>1 10 6>1 / ,*0+ 51 1 + : H 1/ 0 ?10-1< ,",, : 1/ 0,0>G1-! ; !+7 ! 1S<,+,6 = ,5?1M 2-G?1", ,6-,51 1-+7-,5?1M+ ,51 1 < +7 ,51 1 (6(T?1O 1 ", *1,G0 >0 16 < !1 1-; +!1 / 0,0>G1 -! ! ?1 0,-/ , :0,6-0,1 / 0,0>G1 , ,8 51 1-! ,0?1 /, :>0 1 +7 >51 ! ,0 71 / 0,0,51 !+7 ! >1 1 / 0,-,: *1, L-0 101H +,<?1-,H +7 >G1" !//1 1, 6 +7 >G1 " =6 1 -1 /-!L 51 <1 < ,51 " + :< 1 1 : , ,/,-+!8 *(1

0,0 *1 = : 7?1 !6!2 1 , P <+ <,51 2-7K1 6!G,0 ,51 = : 1 ,6 ?1->0 1,-, ,-1 ",1< +7 ,-(1F 1, ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1( )C67 ' &7" 6BAD6F7' '(12 :(1-,2(17(&(11

#1( )C67 ' 70,0 *1= : 7(17(FF(1

! 1 1 L +7 , ?1 ,/, + 0, 1 :!2 1 < ,=-0 1 ! >G1 6 + 51 1. ,01/,0-6 0 ,-?1"+! > 1 6 H 1 , , ,51 /,6-:>0 K ?1/,2 <!1/,*0+*-*1 ,51/ 0,/, *6, ?12 <1,. H ; +7 ,16 + ! <>5Y1/,2 <!1M " *1 1 0 ,-71+K6 51 / 0; + >1016-! 0 , 1 !-+,Y1/,2 <!1 0 >51/, H +1, L-; 0 1-2 0-*1 1/ ,6,+ 1., < +7 >G?1/, ,51 + />G?1/ ; " 6(1 1M ,<1/! 1<>1/ , <101/, < 1 +7 ,51/ 0,0,51 - -<>1, L-0 12 :1 :+ 2 > 1 2-0 1-! P ,01/ 0 11 60,; ,01 1/ , ! , ,0?1/, / 08 G1 1/,6-!6 <>G?1-H,01 1, 0 2 ; ,0?16 /! ,01 1 : + 51 1 (/(1

,62 <?1-1/,<,L7K1/, * *1/ 0,0,51= : 1<>1<,= <1 1 ,+7 ,1 --+ 6,0 71 0,-/ , :0,6-0,1 , < 0 ,",1 /, *6 ?1 6 * +7 ,-71 / 0,,G +7 >G1 1 / 0,/ < +7 >G1 ; -! ,01 01 6-0 1 , P 0 >G1 1 6 0 6! +7 ,;+ 2 ,->G1 2 +?1 , 0 2 KL G1 ,0 *<1 ,. H +7 ,;0+-,",1 M +, 1 I6,+= ,",J?1 ,1 1-,-0 71*-, 1/ 6-0+ 1,1/ 2 G1 1!-; +,0 *G1 " 0 >G1/ 0,0>G1/ ,*0+ 5191/ 0, !8 5?1:+,; !/, + 5?1 -/ 0 *1 1/ , :0,+ (1 0,0 *1= : 71/,:0,+* 1--< 0 71 0-1 / 0,0> 1 . ,< >1 01 6 ,<1 ,</+-1 91 -1

., < +7 ,51 1-,6 = +7 ,51-, , ?101 G10,: ,0 ?1 :0 ; 1 1 -2 : ,0 ?1 01 < ,",, : 1 1 / , 0, 2 1 -<>-+,0?1 / 6 0 <>G1/ 0!101/,0-6 0 ,<1-!L-0,0 1+K6 5(11

0,0 *1 6 * +7 ,-71 / 6/,+ " 1 + 2 ,-7?1 6 5-0!K; L!K1 1,-,0 1,-,: *1S, >2 ,510< * <,-?1!<>8+ ,-?1 ! =6 ,-T1 ,0 51 / 0,0>G1 / 6/-51 1 , P 0; ,51 , G,6 <,-?1 ,1-71 1,-,0 1/ 0,-,: *(11

1

25 35 " 165&35 "1 1 1;1

%(11 2 <1 1 -,-, 1< ,6,+," 2-, 1: 2 16 *; +7 ,-,",1/,6G,6 101 :!2 1, L-0 V1

#(18 ,0,1-,6 = 1 1.! H 1/ 0,0,516 * +7; ,-V1

R(1D:1 G1,/ H 51-,-, 1/ 0,0 *16 * +7 ,-7V1 @(18 1,/ 6 +*-*101 -,0 < ,51+ ! 1/,;

* 11I/ 0,0 *1= : 7JV1

)(18 1 1 -0*: >1 < =6!1 -, ,51 1 / 0,0 *1 = : 71 1 / 0,0 *1 !+7 ! V1

1

!

1

1

1

23 DED' B53B354D3A BB233

D D-3 B4BCB' 3

1

1

0,-,: 1 91 , G,6 <>51 <,< 1 " :-?1 .! H , ; ,0 *1 1 :0 *1/ 0 1 1- -<>1/ 0,0>G1, ,8 51 1/ ; 0,0,51 6 * +7 ,-(1 0,-,: 1 -+!= 1 -,2 ,<1 / 0,0,51 0 ,-1 10 ! <1 "!+* , ,<1K 6 2-1: 2 <,",1/,0 ; 6 *(1F ,1/-!-0! 101/ ,H--G1/ 0, 0, 2-0 ?1/ < *1 1-, +K6 *1/ 0 1 1-0*:!KL 1:0 ,1< =6!1 , < 0 ><10>; = <10,+ 1: , ,6 +*1 1 +7 >< 1, L-0 >< 1, ,8 ; *< (1 , :0,6-0,1/ 0,-,: *1 1 "!+*H *16 * +7 ,-1/ ; 0,0>< 1 , < < 19101/ H / ?1-1 ,2 1: *10,-/ , :0,6-0 10-51 - -<>1 , L-0 >G1 1 / 0,0>G1 , ,8 5?1 91 ,6 1 1 , 1 = 1 / ,H--(1 ,62 <19101/ 0,-,: 1 G,6* 1, = 1 1 ,+7; ,1/,-!/ 1+K6 5101-. 1/ 0 ?1< G :<>1/ 0,0,51 "!+*H ?1 -!L-0!KL 1/ 0,, ,8 *?1 ,1 1 1, L-0 > 1, ,8 *?1 , , > 1 !=6 K-*101/ 0,0,51 "!+*H (1

1/ 0,-,: 1-++ :!-*1 1: /+*-*1,H 1-,; H +7 >< 1 -! P < 1 : 2 <,-?1 /,+ : ,-1 1 / <+ <,-1 6+*1 G1 1 6 ,",1 : , ,6 +7-0 1 0,, L ?1 1 1 , 6 +7 >G1 ",1 M+ < ,0(1 O 1 ,H 1 -,:6-*1 -,, ,8 <1 -,01 1 H + 5?1 , , >G1+K6 16,-" K 1-0, 516 * +7 ,-7K?1-1 < 10,:; <,= ,-*< 1 1 ,0 *< ?1 2 ,1 / 6-0+ >1 01 /,: 0 ,<1 / 0 (1D< ,1:6-716+*1/ 0,-,: *1-+ 6>0-*?1<,= ,1-; : 7?1I/ 0,0 *1 1< J1912 :1, ,8 1/ 0 1 1: , ?1 -/ 71 , 0 <,-1 1-! ,0,-1 : *1: 1 !8 1/ ; 0,0>G1 , <?1!-+,0 *1 10,:<,= ,-1-,H +7 ,51-0, ,6>?1/ 6,-; 0+* <,516 5-0!KL <1: , ,6 +7-0,<1 1 (6(1 1M ,51,H 1 / +,<+*-*1, L-0 >51-,51",-!6-0 ?1 ( (101 510-"6 1 /-!-0! 1-0 1/ 0,0,",1-!-1,6 G1+K6 51-16 !" ; < ?1 G1 :+ 2 , 1<-,101/ 0,0,51-6 16 ,",1, L-0 (11

1