Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

-,0 8-0,0 1 E =6-,",1 ,6-1 3 J?1 / 6!-< ; 0 KL 51 : , !18, H /H 1 10-1 :< 5101E =6 ; -51 ,6-1-1!2 ,<1,/> 1 ",1/ < *1-!6 < (18, H /H *?1 : , *1 7,0 ,<1 /,1 ,6 . H 1 1 -,0 8-0,0 K1 " =6-,",1: , ,6 +7-0 1 1D--+ 6,0 +7-<1H ,<12 ; -,",1/ 0 1/ 1 : 6 13 ?1/,+!2 + 18 , , 1, -!=6 ?1 >+ 1,6, 101, * 1#$$E1"(?1 1 / 71=! +1I4-1 ,</ ; J1 1-0, <1-5 1, >+1, -!=6 1, 6 +7 >G1 :< 51 1 6,/,+ 51 -,1 -, , >1 &3 +9 ,1 +3 56B1 , L *1 ",1 ," 1 01 ., < 1 / 6+,= 51 , / 0 71 01 !/,<* ! > 1 7,0 1 1 g (1 <1, :,<?1 , G,6 <,1",0, 71 1,1/ ,.--, + :; < ?1 1,16 <, :< 1: , , 0, 2-,",1/ ,H--?1 !KL < ?1 6+*1/,0>8 *1 2-0 1: , ,6 +7-0 ?1/ 0+ 2 *1 1-<!; + ,0 *1 8 , ,",1 !" 1 1 M-/ >G1 -,, L-0?1 1 -! ! 1 " =6-,",1, L-0 ?17CD(17-< 1: , , 0, 2-0 16,+= 1 > 71, > ,516+*16 +7 58 ",1 :0 *1 1 0, 2-,",1-<,, ; ,0+ *?1 -,6 = 71 /,< <,1 / *<>G1 S, 1 : , ,6 +*1 1 / 0,; / < +*<T?1 L 1 1, > 1 ., < H , > 1-0*: 191, 10-G1 -! P ,01 / 0,/ < +7 >G?1 / 0,,G +7 >G1 1 / 0,; , *: +7 >G1/ ,H--,0(11

,-,+7 !101K 6 2-,51 , < ?101 , 2 ,<1-2 ?10> = ; K-*1 1 : /+*K-*1 ,/ 6 + > 1 /,+ 2-1 6 ?1 , , > 1 6,+= >1 0,-/ < 7-*1 1 , L , *: +7 > 1 6+*1 0-G1 2+ ,01 , L-0 ?1 : 0-<,1, 1 G1-! P 0 ,",1, ,8 *1 1/ 6/ ; -K1 , <>?1/,-,+7 !1,-, , 1: 2 1 < 16 <, 2-, 1

., < ,0 1 : , ,6 +7 ,51 S/ 6-0 +7 ,5T1 0+-?1 K ; 6 2-1 ,., <+*KL 51 ->1 ,+78-0 1 -+ *?1 ,-,0; >G1-,H +7 >G1" !//1 1, L ,-5(14 6 2-*1 , < 1<,= 1 1 6,+= 1 > 71/ 6-0+ 1 1-:1,/ 6 + 51/ 0,0,51H + 1 1 -,, 0-0!KL G1 / 0,0>G1 -6-01 1 + : H ?1 -+!= L G1 + "!1, L-0 1 12 +,0 (1A 5-0 ,-71+K ,",1: , 1 / *; <!K1 : 0-1 , 1 :-,0 ,-1 01 ",1 + : H 1 ,-,0 >G1 -,H +7 >G1 " !//?1 < +7 ,; G 2-,51 1 , " : H , ,51 , -/ 2 ,-1 ",1 -/,+ *(1 U , ,6 +7?1 ! :>0 1 4( (1E ,8 0?1/ < *1!",+,0 ,;/ 0,0!K1 , <!?16,+= 1-., ; <!+ ,0 7101 51 1/ : ?1 , , > 1 >16 0 + 10,:<,= ,-71 / 0,/ < +K1 1 ,+7 ,1 / 0 +7 ,1 ,+ ,0 71 M !1 , <!?1 01

,2 ,<1 -,, 0-0 1 -1 1 : , ,6 +7 ><1 0> = <1 S0,+ 51 : , ,6 +*T?1 ,1 16,-,0 ,1!-0+ 0 71/! <1/ ,H--! +7; ,",16, :>0 *1/ : 1/-!/+ *?1/ 6!-<, > 1M ,51 , <,5%(1

O !1= 1/ , + <!1 8 1 1/ 6+,= *1 (A(1 0 +,0><1 1 4(4(14",0><1 /,-+ 6,0 +7 ,-71 M /,01 :6 *1 : , ?1 01 ,+78 51-/ 16 + KL *1 H 1 1K 6 2-,51 G 1: ,; , 0, 2-,",1/ ,H--(1 1 ,1= 10 <*1, 1, L K 10 < 1 1-,:6 1-G,6 ,51 , 2-,51,-,0>1 , H /H 1 !6!L ",1 : , 1 91 - -<>1 -,<1 1 / H /,0?1 0> = KL G1 < ,0,:; : 2-1 1/,+ 2-10:"+*6>1 ,+78-0 1, L-0 Y1., ; < ,0 1 :,0,",1 <--0 1 , 2-G1 : 5?1 ,/ 6 +*K; L G1, P <1 1-! ! !1 !6!L ",1: , ?1" H>1 1"+! !1/ ; 0,0,",1 "!+ ,0 *Y1 ,-! ,0 1 ., <>1 1 -,6 = *1 / , 1: , ?1/ 6-0+ ,",101 :+ 2 >G1-,0>G10 ; G?1 , ! !KL G1 , H /H *G(1 1M ,<1M / 1"+ 0 , 191 6 ; 0 , 1 : <>-+!1 1 K 6 2-1 " <, , 1 ., <!+ ,0 1 , ; >G1/ 0,0>G1 , <Y1 , H?1+ " < H *1: , ?1 ( (1/ 6 ; 1 ",1/ , !1/,-6-0,<1,/ 6 + ,51K 6 2-,51/ ,H ; 6! >1, *: +7 ,51K 6 2-,51-+>(1-1M ,191/,-+ 6,0 +7; ,-71/ G,6 1, 1: , ,6 +7 ,51 H 0>1 1, -!=6 K1: ; , ,/ , ?1/ * K1: , 1 1 ",1,/! + ,0 K#(1

71. +,-,.-,;/ 0,0,51 ,2 1: *1"+ 0 , 101-,6 = 1 0>8 !/,<* ! ,51 , H /H 1 91 -<+ 1 , -/ 2 71 / 0,0,51 G 1: , ?1 ( (1 ",1-,, 0-0 1, L 51+," 1-,H +7 ,",1 :0 *1 1 :,0>G1H ,-51 !+7 ! >?1/ H / <1 1/ : <1 / 0 1S"!< :<?1-/ 0 6+ 0,-7?1 0-0,?1 , < 0 ,-7?1- -; < ,-71 1 (6(T?1< =6! ,6 ,<!1/ 0!1 18,-!H ?1/ ,H 6!; 1+ " < H 1: , (11

1-,0 < ,51, 2-0 ,51. +,-,.-,;/ 0,0,51+ ; ! 1!-+ 0-*10 < 1 10,/ ,-!?1/,-0+ ,<!1 L 1 1: 1 2 +,0 2-,51H 0 + : H 191,1-0*: 1 1 6-0 1K 6 2-G1: ; , ,01 1: , ,01, P 0 ,51 +7 ,-1S8,-<,-?1/ ,6>?1, ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11633F7 '1 , *1 1/ 1 < + : H 11 <-H H 1, 2!=6 *1!",; +,0 ,;/ 0,0,51 , <>1 331 3 <-H >51 + :1 , 2!=6 >G1 ., <1 -!L-0,0 *(1 B ! "?1%EE'(17(1%R$(1

#17<(113 3F 6F7' , &7/%6F71 , + <>1 , 1 1/ 1: , , 0, 2-,",1/ ,; H--1013,--5-,51 6 H 13313,--5-51K 6 2-51=! +(1%EER(1Q1#(1

1

L-0 T(1W-><1-+!2 <1:6-71*0+*-*1/ , + < 1-,, ,8 *1 : , 1 1 , L !2 ,51 ", 1 1 K 6 2-,",1 : , (1 (7(1X +K 1-G,6 1 :1 , ,-1 G1/ , 0,/,-0+ *?1 -2 *?12 ,1/, < 1, L !2 ,",1: , 1 1 "!+* , 1,/ ; 6 + ,",1 / ,H--?1 ,-! !KL ",1 , G,6 <!K?1 !-,52 ; 0!K?1 -!L-0 !K1 1/,0 , *KL!K-*1 -0*:7?1/,:0,+* 1 1/ 0,; 0!K1 , <!1-2 71-/ H . 2-,51 : ,0 6 ,-7K1, L !2 ,",1 : , (1

1 -0 1 0>8 :+,= ,",1 <,= ,1 ,-,0 7?1 2 ,1 01 >; 8 <1 ,--5-,<1 , L-0 1 /,;/ = <!1 -!L-0 ><1 6 . ; ,<1: , ,6 +7 ,516 * +7 ,-1,- -*1-+ *1, H *1: ,; ,6 +*1 1"+! > 1: , ,< ,-1 "!+ ! <>G1: , ,<1, ; ,8 5(1 ,+ 2-1, 1<,= 1, P*-* 7-*1/,; : ,<!?101: 0 ; -<,-1, 1 , >G1-+!2 01S01 , 2 ,<1 ," ?10 6 <,?1-<+ ; <1!6 = 710+-7T11= + <1!-, 71/ G,61 1 > ,2 ><1, ; ,8 *<1 :1 !2 1 <, ,/,+ :< 1 / , :0,6 + 5?1 -+ ,-7K1 + 1-/,<,L ,-7K101-/,+ 1: , ,0?1 : <1! ,0 <1/ 0,-,:; *1 1/ 0,0,51 !+7 ! >?1: <-0,0 <1 :;: 1 ! = 1/ 0,0>G1-! ,0?16+*100 6 *1 , , >G1 1-,: + 1!-+,0 *191-! 1 6,0 +7 ,",1!/ 0+ *1S-TY12-,1K 6 2-191,-!-0 ; <1/ 6< ,",1 1-,6 = +7 ,",1 :" 2 *1< =6!1/ ,-><1 1 ,-!H , ><1: , < ?1: , ,<1 1! :,<?1: , ,<1 16 !" < 1 S ,< 1! : T1/,6: , >< 1 < (1

1

25 35 " 165&35 "1 1 1)1

%(1W ,1 , 1/,: 0 H *1/ 0 V1 #(18 1-0*: >1K 6 2-1: , >1 1: , ,< ;

,-1, L-0 ,",1 :0 *V1 R(1F/ 6 + 1,-,0 > 1/ H />1: , , 0, 2 ;

-0 (1

@(1 W <1 , -/ 2 0-*1 1 6 5-0 ,-71 : , ,6 ; +7-0V1

1

3 23 D F3 5F 5C& DE &23

3 D F3,B' &3

1 0,101-,H +7 ,51 +7 ,-191 1-,-,* ?1 1-2 *1

- -< 1, <?1,?1/ =6 10-",?16 * +7 ,-71/,1 -/,+7:,0 K1 K 6 2-,",1 -!< *16+*18 *1-,H +7 ,1: 2 <>G1 : 6 2Y1 6 !" < 1 -+,0 < ?1 / 0,1 +7:*1 -0-1 ,+7 ,1 1 K 6 2 ; -,516,"< ?1,. H +7 ,<!1: , ,6 +7-0!(1F + 0 *-71, 1 /, < *1, L-0 ,51= : 1 1-,0, !/ ,51/ 6< ,516 *; +7 ,-1 -< G1 +K6 5?1 <>1 6,+= >1 1 / 0,1 --< 0 71 1 ,-, ,",1 ,6 16 * +7 ,-7?12 ,1/,:0,+* 1I-G0 7J1-<>-+1/ 0 ?1 -,-,*L 5101 ",16 < ?1016 5-0 ?1 + : H ?1/ 2-,<1 "!+ ,0 1, L-0 >G1, ,8 5(1 0,0 *16 * +7 ,-71 /,1-0, <!1-,6 = K1I-G0 >0 J10-1,-,0 > 12 >1! 0 ; -!< 12 +,0 2-,",1< ?10>-!/ *1 1 10,-/ , :0,6-0,1 , < ; 0 ,",1 /, *6 ?1 / 0,/ < +7 >G1 1 / 0,,G +7 >G1-! ,01, L-0 ?1 1 1/ ,H--1 : 8 *1-,H +7 >G1/ ,; 0, 2 5?1 1 1-/,-, 1 1-6-0 1-,"+-,0 *1-,0?16,-; = *1 ,</ ,<--,0?1 1 1/ ,H--1-<, :< *12 +,0 101 G,6 1,-0, *1 , <1 1H ,-51/ 0 ?1 ?1 , H?1 1/ , ; = 1-,H +7 ,51 +7 ,-(1

0,0 *1 6 * +7 ,-7?1 -/ H . 1 1 -,6 = *?1 0: <,; -0*: 1 -1 6 !" < 1 0 6 < 1 2 +,0 2-,51 6 * +7 ,-1 1 (/(1 0-1 01 ,+78 51 < 1 / 0+ 1 0 < 1 , 2-0 >G1 / 0,0 6,0(1 , G,6 <,-71 1 :!2 *1/,62 0 +-7101 , G1 ( (18!6; *0H 0 ?1 A(4(1 8 <,0 ?1 (C(17> >G?1 (D(1 !"-,",?1 A( (1 7 ;

. !++ ?1D(B1(U <,5-,",1 16 (1 ?1/,1< K14(7(1->/ ?1-",6 *1/,61 + : H 51

/ 0 1/ 2-10,10-G1-+!2 *G?1/ *<,1 + 1 ,-0 ,?1/, < ;-*16 * +7 ,-712 +,0 ?16 5-0 *?1/,0 6 2-1 >1+K6 51 91 I/ ,H--1 ,-!L-0+ *1 / 0,0>G1 / 6/-5?1 6 * +7 ,-7?1 -,"+-*1 -1 0> = ,51 01: , 10,+ 5ZJ(%1 ,1-71 + : H *1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%13 39-8CA571 , , > 1-/ >1--+ 6,0 *1 ,-!H , ,",1/ 0,-,: *1331 E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$$)(1Q1%(17(E#(1

1

1 1

/ 0 10>-!/ 1 1., < 1/ 2-,516 * +7 ,-1/,1,-!L ; -0+ K1 / 01 1 0>/,+ K1 , *: ,-5?1 / 0,1 , 1 I= : 7J?10,/+,L *-7101-,: +7 ,;0,+ 0>G1/,-!/ G1S6 5-0 ; *GT1-! P ,01/ 0 ?1 1 6 0 6! +7 >G?1 1 1 ,++ " +7 >G(1 1 2-0 1 ,</, ?1 -,2 1 / 0,0,51 !+7 ! >1 1 / 0,0,51 - -<>1--< 0 1/ 0,0!K16 * +7 ,-7101< ,",, : 1 1 0 6,0?1 -6-01 1 -! P ,01 4( (1 7 < ,%(1 0,1 1 ,-, >5?1 -+,= >5?1 0 ! 1 6 ..H ,0 >51 0 61 6 * +7 ,-1 -; -+ 6!-*101 !6 G1D( (1C + ,0,51,1 !2 >G?1< ,6,+," 2-1 0>0 >G1 ,-,0 *G1 6,+",-,2 ,51 / 0,0,51 /,+ 1 ",-!; 6-0 ?1 H + ,51 1 0 : H K1K 6 2-G1 ., <1: L >1 !+7 ! >(1 < **16 * +7 ,-!K1/ 6 "<!101 < G1/ 0,; 0,51-. >?1E(D(1D , ,0 1 1 ( (15*8 ,10>6 +*K 1-,+7 ,1 -! ! 1/ 0,0,516 * +7 ,-?101 < G1 , , >G1/ ,-< 0 ;-*1-*1/-/ 0 1. +,-,.-,;/ 0,0>G1--+ 6,0 511 %T1/ ,H--! +7 !K?1,/->0 KL!K10: <,-0*:71-! P ?1, P ?1 H + ?1 :!+7 1 1 /,-+ 6-0 51 / 0,0,51 6 * +7 ,-Y1 #T10 6,; 0!K191 !6?1, L 1 1 " 11RT10 < !K1S0160!G1., < GT191 !; +7 ,51 1 !<!+* 0 ,5(1 1< 1 -/ 0 6+ 01 :",0, 1,160!G1

., < G1/ 0,0,516 * +7 ,-11 , 2-,5191/ 0, 0, 2-,51 S: , ,6 +7 ,5T16 * +7 ,-1",-!6-0 ?1 !2 ,516 * +7 ,; -1--+ 6,0 +7-G1/ 0,0>G1-! ,01 1!2 =6 5?1,. ; H +7 >G1, " ,01 ,+ ,0 *1/ 0 191 1/,0-6 0 ,5?1," 2 ; ,51K 6 2-< 1: , <#(1 ,1/,0,6!10: <,-0*: 1/ 0 1 1 "; >1<,= ,1: < 7?12 ,1, 1 ,6-0 >1 1" 2-?1 1 ! +7; ,1 91/,1 (1[ 5: " ?1",++ 6-,<!1--+ 6,0 +K1 " >1 1-; ,2 1 !+7 ! >11IZ<>1: < 2 <?12 ,1/ 2-,<!1, / 0+ ; K1/ 0 ?1 2 1",0, *?1-!6,/ , :0,6-0!?1 ,0>1 >1 1 >+ 1 6 +7 > 1,-,0>1/ 0 191010>-, ,51-/ 1/-!L1G 1-,; -*: *J?1/,1-516 7101 :+ 2 >G1., < G1/ 0,0,51= : 1-0,; :* 1 " ,0> 1 1-,-*: +7 > 1 2-0R(1 1M ,<1 ,-1-,; 0-*1*-,?1/,2 <!1 1/,/!+* >1 1M 1 + 0 :, 1-H ; ,0 1-!6 >G1:-6 519101-+!1 : 2 +7 ,1/-!L 51 <1 ;

%EEF(17(1#&&;#E&(1

#17<(11!C655AC6F 7 ! &78 335C67'1F-,0>1. +,-,. 1/ 0 (1C(?1#$$%(17(#%F;#%E(1 R1 ,6 , 1-<(1193 7A5% 7A1j_`_1kbelmf(1 1 1: 0 8 ",16 *(1C(?1%EE#(17(ER;E@(1