Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

1A !" < 1-+,0 < ?1 =6>51-! P 1/ 0 ?1-G,6*1 :1-0, ",1 -,H +7 ,",1/,+,= *?1: 6 1<-8 10,-/ * *1/ 0 1 1/ ; 0 L 1 ",1 01 ,-0, > 1 , <>1 -, -0 ,51 6 * +7 ,-(1 F 1 M ,",1 <-8 1 / *<!K1 : 0-* 1 G 1 1 "+! 1 ,-<>-+ ; *?1-/,-, >1: /+ *101*:> 1/ H /,01 1 , <1/ 0 ?1 1 ; = 1 / 0 L *1 G1 01 -! ! > 1 M+ < >1 6 0 6! +7 ,; + 2 ,-,",1 :0 *(11

F>2 ,1/ 0,-,: 1,/ 6 +*K 1 1-,0, !/ ,-710:"+*6,0?1 6 5?1H ,->G1, H 51 1 6 +,0?10> = KL G1, ,8 1 1 / 0!1 1: , !?1-!6!?1 , < 0 ,<!1/, *6 !10,, L ?1/ 2 <1, ,1 1 ,+7 ,1, = 1/ 0,0!K16 5-0 +7 ,-7?1 ,1 1 ,-! ! 1= ; + <, 1/ 0,0, 1-,-,* ?1 0 ,1S/ *<,1 + 1 ,-0 ,T1-,:6 1 1 + :! 1/ 0,(1U6, ,0, 1/ 0,-,: 1, L-0 ?1!0 = 1" =; 6 1 1/ 0!1 1: , !1*0+*K-*1 , G,6 <><1!-+,0 <1-!L-0,0 ; *1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 ?1M..0 ,",1.! H , ,0 *1/,+ ; ,;/ 0,0,51 1 6 !" G1 -. 1, L-0 (13 :0 , 1/ 0,-,: 1 1 / 0,0 *1 0 ,-71" =6 191+!28 *1/ ,. + 1/ 0, !8 ; 5?1/ , 0,6 5-0 *1/-!/ ,-(1

7+ 6! 1!2 >0 7?12 ,1 1., < ,0 1 1 :0 1/ 0,; -,: *1 1., <>1, L-0 ,",1-,: *1, :>0 K 10,:6 5; -0 16 !" 1., <>?1, ,10: <,6 5-0! 1-1/,+ 2-<1-,: ; <?1<, +7K?1 + " 5?1-!--0,<?1. +,-,. 51 1 ! ,5(17,; H , !+7 ! > 1 . , >1 6 5-0!K 1 1 2 +,0 1 1 ,+7 ,1 S 1 1 -,+7 ,T1 2 :1 ",1 -,: ?1 ., < !*1 0 ! 1 ,-,: 0 <>51 < ?1 ,1 01 ,+78 51 -/ 1 2 :1 ,-,: 0 <, 1 0+ * ?1 -,:; 6 KL 1/-G,+," K1+ 2 ,-1 1-<!1+ 2 ,-7101H +,<(11

F, L *1 0>8-: , ?1 <>1 <,= <1 0>6 + 71 -+ 6!KL 1

.! H 1/ 0,-,: *<1 &5-6 +191 ., < !KL!K1 - -; <!1M</ 2-G1 1 , 2-G1: 51,1/ 0 1 1 - -< 1 , <16 * +7 ,-1 1/,0 6 *?1/ 01 1-0, ,612 +,0 (1O 1: ; *10,: K 101 :!+7 1 1/ 2-,",1!2-*101/ 0,0,51 6 * +7 ,-?1 1,-0, *1 : ,, : >G1K 6 2-G1-,01S, 1 ,-!+7 H 51K-,0101-6-0 G1<--,0,51 ., < H 16,1: ; ,<-0 1 -1 ,6-< 1 1 8,-!H 5T(1 + ",6 *1 M ,51 .! H 1 -+ 6>0 K-*1/ 6-0+ *1,1 ,<?1 1 "!+ !K-*1, L-0 ; > 1 , ,8 *?1 2 ,1 : / L-*1 1 2 ,1 : 8-*1 : , ,6 ; + <11 < 1/ 0 < 1 1, *: ,-*< 1, + 6 1-! P 1/ 0,, ;

1

!

,8 511 1 2 +,0 1 <,= 1 !2-0,0 71 01 + : H 1 -0, ",1 / 0,0,",1 1/,+ 2-,",1-!-1 1 (/(1

,1: 71/,+,= +7 , 1/ 0,1 6,-,2 ,16+*1, + 6 *1 / 0,-,: <?1, ,1 1-0,6-*1 1: , ,-,: K?16,+= ,1 G,; 6 7-*1 01 H +7 ,<1 6-0 1 -1 6 !" < 1 -,H +7 >< 1 , < < ?1 6 *< 1 1H ,-*< 191 0-0 >< ?1/,+ 2-< ?1M-2 ; -< 1 1 (6(?1 , , > 1 0 ,10,:6 5-0!K 1 1 ., < ,0 1 1 + : H K1 , <1/ 0 (1F-, ,1: 2 < 1 ,+71<, + 1-1 1 ; ", *< 1-,0-?1+K 0 ?1-,-6 *1 1 (/(191 10>-8 < 1 ; ! < 12 +,0 2-,516!8 (1

0. 5% 1 .! H *1 / 0,-,: *1 0> = 1 M<,H , +7; , 1, ,8 1S/,: 0 , ?1 " 0 , 1 + 1 5 +7 , T16 5-; 0!KL G1 6 0 6,01 1/ 0!1 1: , ,6 +7-0!1S01H +,<1 + 1, ; 6 +7 ><1M+ < <T101: 0-<,-1, 1-,0/ 6 *1 + 1/ , 0, ; 2 *1 G1H + 51 1-,01 ,0 *<1 + 10,:<,= ,-*<?1-,6 ; = L <-*101: , ,6 +7-0 (13 :!<-*?1,H 1 ,+ 1 1: 2 *1 / 0 1-+ 6>0-*101: 0-<,-1, 1"+! >1 1/,+ , >1K 6 ; 2-G1 : 5?1 , 1 / , ,",1 = : ,",1 ,/> ?1 ,?1 /,= ; +!5?101", :6,1 ,+78 51< ?1, 1, ,8 *1 1/ 0!1 1. 51 : 0-* 1 2-0,?1, P <1 10,- ,0 ,-71K 6 2-G1: 5(1 W +,0 101/ ,H--1-0, 51= : 6 * +7 ,-10-"6 10> >0 1 / 2-!K1,H !1 1 ,+7 ,1,. H +7 >G1/ 0,0>G1/ H ; /,0?1 , <?1 1-! ,0?1 ,1 1/,0 6 *1/ 6-0 + 51/ 0,,G; +7 >G1 1-!6 >G1, " ,0?1, != KL G1 1-<,",1- *(1 1 :!+7 1 !1 ",1 0,: 1 &3 656 1 561 91 ++ !; +7 ,;M<,H , +7 ,;0,+ 0 *1/ 6-/,+,= ,-71,/ 6 + ><1 , :,<10,-/ < 71 1,H 0 71/ 0,0> 1*0+ *1 16 5-0,; 0 7101-,, 0-0 1-1/,+!2 ,51 ., < H 51 1,H ,5(1 0,; 0> 1 !-,0 1 :0 0 K-*1 01 / 0,0> 1 , H ?1 ., < !K; L 1 / ," <<!1 6 * +7 ,-1 6 0 6 1 01 K 6 2-1 : 2 <>G1 -! H *G1 91 0> , 1 H + 51 1 -6-01 G1 6,-= *(1 <1 -<><1 / 0,-,: ?10,/+,L *101= : 71 , < 0 > 1/ 6/-*?10>; /,+ * 13 6 +1.! H K?1/ ,*0+*-*1010 6 1/ 0,< ,; ",1 + 1 / , 0,/ 0 ,",1 /,0 6 *(1 8 ,< 1 ,",?1 "!+* 0 *1

.! H *1: +K2-*101 ,<?12 ,1/ 0,-,: 1*0+*-*1-,2 ; ,<1/,: 0 ,",1/ 0 ?1/ 1 ",1 /,-6-0 ,<1!2-1-,:6 ; K-*1/ 0,0> 1 , <>(1

1-,6 = 1-,H +7 ,;. +,-,.-,",1+ : 1/ 0,-,: ; *1 0G,6 1 --+ 6,0 1 1 ",1 " :-?1 / 0 2 >G1 ., <?1 ; -!L G1, / 2 , 1< .,+," 2-,",1<>8+ *?1 1 1 ",10,-/ , :; 0,6-0 1 1-, -0 ,51,-,0 (18, : H 510 , ,",1 / 0; + *1 *0+*-*1 :!2 1 , L G1 <,< ,01 1 :+ 2 51 0,-/ , :; 0,6-0 1/ 0,-,: *1 1/ , :0,6-0 1: *1,1/ 0 (18 ,< 1 ,; ",?1 / 0,-,: 1 G :!-*1 /,1 ",1 -! P <; ,-+*<?1 2 ,1/ 6/,+ " 1,/ 6 + 1 2-0 ,",1-0, , : *101! ,0; 1 1-,6 = 1 G1/ 0,0,51/-G,+," 1 1/ 0,0,51 6 ,+," ?1 K 6 2-G1 : 5(1 2-1 H +-,, : ,1 < ,",, : 1 -! P ,01 / 0,-,: *1 -0-1 1 -+ 6!KL <1 ,-,0 ><1 / <11 6 0 6! +7 ,<!?1 ,++ 0 ,<!1 1<--,0,<!(11

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

1 1 , >6 ,<1 / 0,-,: 1 0> =-*1 -,H +7 ,; /-G,+," 2-51 -+ 6?1 &3 656 1 51 -,H +7 ,51 " !//>?1 ,6 ?1 ,51 + 1 ,51H 0 + : H (17 = <?1< +7 ,-71

1

!"

/ 0,0,",1 " + :< ?1 1G, ,8,1: ,< *1 <?1-,6 = 101- 1 1!-,0 ?1 1,/ 6 + 1/ 0 101 2-0 1 /,+ ,H ,51 16 = 1!L ,51., <>1 "!+ ,0 *1-,H +7 ,51= : ?1, ; H 1"!<-2-,",1-,6 = *1/ 0,0,51 , <>?1/, < 1 ",-!6-0 ,510+-1 1 +7 ,51-+>1 1 (/(1 , * 1 51 -",6 *1 / ,2 ,1 0,8+,1 01 -+1 -,H +7 ,; "!< ,",1: *100 6!1 ",1M0-2-,51/+,6, 0, ,-101

,P*-1 H ,-,;-<>-+,0,51 ,</, >1 -,H +7 ,",1 6 5; -0 *Y1, ,1, ,: 2 1-<>-+,-!L 1 ,-! H 12 +,0 2-,",1 -,: *Y1 2 191- -<!1 :,0>G?1.! 6 < +7 >G1H ,-5?1 ,/ 6 +*KL G1, ,8 12 +,0 1S" !//>?1 ,6 ?1, L-0 T1 1 < !101 6-0 1/,: *?1/ = 0 *1 16 5-0 *(18, 2 ,?1 ,+71 -, ,1<>1! 0 =6 <?12 ,1+K ,512 +,0 191! + 1 1 /,0 ,; <?1 ,?1 -+ 6,0 +7 ,?1 , 1 , + 6 1 1 -, -0 ,51 < +7 ,; -7K?1 ,10-; 1 ,+ 1M..0 ,1M ,1/, * 16+*1G ;-1 / 2 >G12 1< ,;, L ,-51+K6 5?1 G1 1M ,->1 S ,6>T1 1H 0 + : H (1F 1-+ 6>0 K-*1 1/ , *= 16+ ; +7 ,",1 -, 2-,",1 0 < ?1 , + 0 K 1 -!67 !1 ,6 1 01 ",1 ! +7 >518,-<,191-G,1915,",-1S/,1E(1E 2 0!T?10> = K-*101

,>2 *G?1 6 H *G?1 0 G(1C +7 ,-710>-!/ 1 16!G,0; ,;/-G,+," 2-51 0 1 !+7 ! >1 ,6 1 SH 0 + : H T?1 ,-0 !KL 510,-/ , :0,6-0,1 1 :,0>G1H ,-5(1C,= ,1 ",0, 71, 6 +7 ,1, 1,-, ,-*G1G!6,=-0 ,",1 0, 2-0 ?1 -0, , : 1K<, ?1 :+ 2 *G101 + " 1!1 G1 + 1 >G1 ,6,01 1 (6(?1 ,1 -?1 01 / 0!K1 ,2 67?1 -! 1 /, * 1 &3 65651 < +7 ,-1 91 6!G,0 ,;/ 0,0>G1 ,-?1 0,-/ , :0,6*L G?1 2 :1-< !1/, ,+ 5?1,/ 6 + , 1, ,8 1 1/ 0!1 1: ,; !?1-/ H . 2-1 / H 1-0, ,6>?1 0-0 1 1-/ 0 6; + 0,-(18 1 ,++ 0 ,;+ 2 ,-, 1, :,0 ?1/ 0,0 *1< ;

+7 ,-71 0 +K2 1 01 - *?1 / =6 1 0-",?1 "+! > 1 --,: ; +7 > 1 -, />?1, :H>1 1 0 ,< :<>1/ 0,0,",1S0 / ; 0,0,",?1 / 0,0,",T1 /,0 6 *?1 01 ,<1 2-+ 1 H , +7 > 1 < G :<>1 /, < *1 / 0 (1 C +7 ,-71 0 +K2 1 01 - *1 1 ,+7 ,1 1 1 -,+7 ,1 /,: 0 +7 !K1 -. !?1 -,+7 ,1 G K1 H ,-5?1 G />1 ,++ 0 ,",1 --,: +7 ,",?1-, />1 /,0 6 *?1 /,1 M ,51 / 2 1 6+*1 1 1 G 1 .+-0; ,-7(1 0,0 *1< +7 ,-710> = 1"+! >51! ,0 71/ ;

0,-,: *?1 6-0,1 1 H +,-,-71 / 0,0>G1 / 6-0+ 5?1 / 0>2 ?1G 1 1-/,-, >1/ 0,0,",1<>8+ *(1 1K 6 2 ; -,<1 --,: +7 ,<1 /+ 0-*1/ 0,0 *1 ., < H *?1: / ; 2 + 0-*1/ , >51K 6 2-51,/> ?1-,: 0 K 1/ 0,; 0> 12!0-0 1 1, H (1 !6!2 1, " 2 ,512-7K1< +7 ,; -1 ,6 1SH 0 + : H T?1/ 0,0 *1< +7 ,-71-101- 1/ ; /+ 1 : ,, : >G1 !+7 ! ,;-, 2-G1-<0,+,0?1, ; :,0?16!G,0 ,;-<>-+,0>G1 0 ,0(19 ,1 1 +7 . ,1, 10>; =-*101 ,6 ,<1.,+7 +, ?1/,-+,0 H G1 1/,",0, G?1/,0-; 6 0 >G1 / 0>2 G?1 2!0-0 G1 1 /,-!/ G?1 , < G1 H 1 1 : 2 <> 1-, > *(1 0,0,51< + ?1/,1D( (1C + ,0,5?1*0; +*-*1-+,0><1/,+ <1 ,<<! H 101-. 1/ 0 1101 <1-+ ; 6>0 K-*1 / 0+*KL 1+ 1-<>-+,, :,0 *?1<, 0 H , ; > 10 , >(17,6 = 1 1-<>-+1/ 0,0,51 , <>16 + ,1 10-; "6 1 G,6* 1, + 1-! P ,01/ 0 ?1-+ 1 1 G,6*-*1016 !",<1 -<>-+,0,<1 /,+ ?1 -+ 1 : !6 ,?1 /,1 <1 + 1 ><1 / 2 <?1 -,:6 1 6 ,51 -<>-+,0,51 < H>1 / H 1 . ,< ,01 / 0%(1

1F-,: , 1 /, < 1 : , ,6 + <?1 / 0,/ < + <1 K 6 2-,51< +7 ,-1 ,6 16 + 1 1-,6 = 1/ 0,0>G1 ,0?1 1K 6 2-16 5-0 *1, ,-,0 >< 1 1/, * >< 16+*1 " =6 (1 1M ,<1 -+!2 1M " *1/ 0,0,51< +7 ,-1/ 6 1 = :-/,-, ,-71 1 /,: 0 ,<!1 / 0!?1 1 -!H , +7 ,51 - -< 1 / 0 (1 0,0,51 I +-J?1 -G , : H *1 -,0?1 / *: 51 + 2 ,-?1 , L-0 1 1 ",-!6-0 1 6,-"-*1 / 1 : 1 1!2 1, ,+," 2-G1 1-,+," 2-G1,-, ,-51 / 0,0,",16!G 1 ,6 (17!L ,-71 1-,6 = 1/ 0,0,",1< ; + 10> =-*101-+ 1/ 0,0,",1<>8+ *?101/ 0,0>G1 ; 6 H *G?101-/ H . 1 =6,51 H , +7 ,51/ 0,0,51- -<>(11

7/ H . 1/ 0,-,: *1 1 ",1/ 0 2 ,<1! ,0 1: +K2 ;-*1 101 -G 5 ,<1 1 --,: +7 ,<1 ., < ,0 1+," ,51 -!L-0!KL G1 0,+ 0>G1 1 , < 0 ,;,., <+ >G1 , ,8 51 ",1 -,6 = *?1 1 1 01 ,<?1 2 ,1 : 2 *?1 -<0,+ 1 1 -<>-+1 M G1 , ,8 51 1 / ,-,1 .-!K-*1 01 -,: 1 6 0 6,0?1 : /+*K-*1 01 G1 ,/> ?1 ,1 1 /-G,+," 2-1 / = 0 K-*(1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1( A56F 7! 7, + < 1/, < *101/ 0 11 !+7 ! > 1 ,6>1/ 0,-,: *13313 < ;-H >51 + :1, 2!=6 >G1., <1-!L-0,0 *(1B ! "?1%EE'(17(1EF(1

1

"$