Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

!-*1",-!6-0,<(1 < 1< ,6,01! =6 *10,0-1 1-< 10,/ ,-1,1/ < 1/ !=6 *101 :!< >G1/ ; 6 + G(1 ,1E(1[ !?1/ !6 +7 > 1-H 1/ 0 1 !K-*1 1 /, ,<!?12 ,1 :1 G10,, L 1 1 >+,1 >1<, 0,01 1/,-+!8 KY1 , 1 != >1 1" 1 ,",?12 ,1->1 G?1 ,16, ,0,+7 ,1 -, +K6 1/ 0,0> 1!-,0+ *?1 1 !6! 1/->101= 0!1 <?1 ,1 1G,2 1-, +K6 71 , <>1 :1/ !=6 *(1 :1- -<>1 / !=6 *1 /,-+!8 1 / 0,0><1 , < <1 >+,1 >1 -0*: ,1 -1-,<1 > 71, < ! ><%(1

1 !=6 1/,6 0+* 1-,H +7 > 1/,-!/ ?1, -/ ; 2 0 1 : , ,-7?1 ,G * 1 / 0,/, *6, ?1 0>-!/ 1 -6-0,<1 -,H +7 ,",1 !/ 0+ *?1 /,-,+7 !1 , -/ 2 0 1 /,62 1 6 5-0 51+K6 51",-!6-0 ,510,+ ?1-+!= L 51S01 6 + T1, L ; -0!(1D1-",6 *?1 101, ,: <,51-, 2-,51/-/ 0 1/ !; =6 1 !6 1 , G,6 <,16+*1,G >1/ 0,/, *6 ?1-, -0 ,; -?1/ 01 1-,01" =6 1 1, " : H 5?1-,:6 *1 , < +7; >G1 !-+,0 51 6+*1 6 * +7 ,-1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 1 0+-1 <-,",1-<,!/ 0+ *(1 0,1 , 6 + <,1, 1-+>?1 ,1-71-/,; -, ,-1 / 0,0>< 1 < ,6 < 1 / ,6,+ 0 71 -,/ , 0+ 1 G1 + 1 >G1+ H?16, 0 7-*1/ 0,0>< 1 , < < 1/,62 *1 G10,; + 16 5-0!KL <1K 6 2-<1!-,0+ *<(1--+7 , 1/ 0,1 91 1/ 0,(1 ,1, ,-,0 , 1/ < 1-+>1 1-+ 1916 + ,1 1,6 ,1 1 ,1= (1-+ 1910 / 0,0, 1*0+ ?1-,-,*L 101/,; 6 0+ ?1 /,/ 1 -0, ,6 ,51 0,+ 1 +K >< 1 -6-0 < ?1 01 ,<1 2-+ 1 5 1=-, < ?1! = KL < 1 1,-, +*KL < 12 +,0 ; 2-, 16,-,-0,(1

1 !=6 1 <1 ,+ 1 1<,= 1 > 71-0 6 ,1 1-+ K?1 /,-,+7 !1 + :!-*101< ,",, : >G1., < G11/ 6!/ =6 ?1 /-2 ?1K 6 2-*1, 0-0 ,-7?1/ 0,0,--,0+ 1 1 / ,H--! +7 *1, -/ 2 (1

C >1 / !=6 *1 :+ 2 K-*1 01 : 0-<,-1 , 1 -/,-, 1 0,:6 5-0 *1S/,1, P !10,:6 5-0 *?1G !1/ 0,0,",10 , ; = *101-. !1/ 0?1-0, ,61 1-,01/ !=6 <,",1+ H T1 1 :!+7 1S/ 0,0>G1/,-+ 6-0 5T1 G1/ < *(1 ?1/,1G ; !1/ 0,0,",10 , = *1, 1/ 6-0+*K 1-, ,51/ 0,0> 1,";

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 ,6 , 1-<(1 3 939 5#7'(1 +,-,. *1/ 0 Z17(1FRF9FR'(1

1

2 *?1, < *1 1, 0 > 16 5-0 *%(1 + ",/ * > 1 /,-+ 6-0 *1 , 1 / < *1 < 1 / !=6 *1 0>-!/ K 1 010 6 1 / 0,0,",1! , 1S+ 8 1-/ H +7 ,",1/ 0 T1+ ,1/ 2 *1 0 6 1S<, +7 ,",?1< +7 ,",?1. : 2-,",T(1

5 . 5 51 S ,"6 1 !/, +*-*1 < 1 I ; -!H , ,-7JT1/ 0 1,: 2 ?12 ,1, ,1/ 6-0+* 1 1/ ,-,1 6 ?1/ H />?1!-,0 1 1 (6(?1-0,5-0 > 1/ 0,-,: K?1 1 0>-!/ 1 1 - -< 1 , P 0 ,0 >G1 K 6 2-G1 , <?1 + :! <>G1/ 1/,<,L 1",-!6-0 (1 1M ,<1 2-0 1/ 0,1-; ,0-*1 , ,-+7 ,1 -<,-,* +7 ><1 1 ,+7 ,1 , 1 , 6 +7 >G1 + H?1 ,1 1, 1, L-0 101H +,<?1-,:6 1-<!10,:<,= ,-71: , ; ,-(1 ,61: , ,-7K1/, <-*1 ,51 = <1I, L-0 ,51 = : ?1 ,"6 10-1+ H ?10 +K2 *1 1",-!6-0 > 1, " >?1 ! ,; 0,6-0!K-*1/ 1,/ 6 + 1/ 0,< ,-1 + 1 / 0,< ,; -1/,0 6 *1+ 871,6 <1 <1916 5-0!KL < 1K 6 2 ; -< 1 , < < ?1 0> = >< 1 01 : , 1 1 6 !" G1 ,. H +7 >G1 K 6 2-G1 -,2 GJ#(1 A 5-0 +7 ,-71 / 0 1 0,:<,= 1 0 1 : , ,-?1 , 1 ->0-*1 01 : , ,-1 1 2 :1 : , ; ,-7?10>-!/ KL 51 1 6-0,1/,: 0 ,51., <>1 1H ,-; ,",1-,6 = *(1

4 ! + : !*1 / , + < !1 / 6+,= ,",1 !-?1 01 < G1 6 ,",1-1<>1-,: +7 ,10 6 <1 :",0, 1,1/ 0 1/ < +7; ,1 1",-!6-0 ,;, " :,0 ,<!1, L-0!1 101-0*: 1-1/ , + ; < < ?1/ = 0 <>< 1-,0 < ><1 ,--5-<1, L-0,<?1 , 6 ; + <><1, 1 ",1 6 0 ",1/ ,8+,",(1 ,1 < ,1/,1M <1/ 2 <?1 1 >1 1 >+10 = 1 :",0, 1,1- -< ,-1/ 0 ?1-,0 8-0,0 1 K 6 2-,51 G ?10>-, ,516 . 0 ,-1 , <1/ 0 ?1"+ 0 ><1 ,- -*10,/ ,-1910,1 <*12 ",1-!L-0!K 1 1 :0 0 K-*1M 1 16 !" 1 -, , >?1-0,5-0 1 1., <>10> = *1/ 0 V11

5K > 1/,/> 1-,-! ,0 71 H , +-2-!K1 ,-; ! H K1/ 0 ?1 -0*:>0 *1 1 ,+7 ,1-1 "!+*H 51, L-0 >G1, ; ,8 5?1/ < <1-,0?1,-0 <1, L ",1 + " ?1 !; 6! 101 , 2 ,<1 ," 1-,-,* +7 >?1 < 1 >1!0 *< 101-,;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%10,0> 1," 2 *?1/ < ?1/,6/-1,10> :6 Y1+ 8 1-/ H +7 ,",1/ 0 191 !+ ,0 1 : 8 *1 1G 1 1 ,8 1, != *Y1, < 1910,:+,= 1-/ ; H +7 ,51, *: ,-1/,1*0 16+*1 "-H 101F AY1, 0 > 16 5-0 *191/ < 1

. : 2-,51-+>?1-/ H +7 >G1-6-0?1/ < 1,"-+7 ,",1, != *(11

#17<(113C933F71 , *1/ 0 (1C(?1%EE@(17(1EF(1

H +7 ,51 H ,-1 / 0 1 , 1 1 -,/ ,0,=6 +-7(1 0,?1 !6!2 1- -, 2-<1 2 +,<1 2 +,0 2-,51 6!G,0 ,-?1 0> = 1 ,-, ><1, :,<1/ : 1+ 2 ,51-0, ,6>12 +,0 1 1 ",1- -; 0 >G1 / 01 1 < . : 2-,51 6 ,-(1 71 M ,51 ,2 1 : *1 <,= ,1 /,66 = 71 / .,-1 O( (18!: H,0 1 S "!< 1 < T1 01 ,H 1A + H 1 : 0-<,-17X41S%''F1"(T1,1-<,,2 0 6 ,; -1: /+ >G101 51-11I2 ,10-1+K6 1-,:6 >1 0 >< ?12 ,1 , 1 6 + >17,:6 + <1,/ 6 + >< 1 , P <+ <>< 1/ 0 < ?1 -6 1 , , >G1 < K-*1/ 0 1 1= : 7?1-0, ,6!1 1 1-<+ 1 1 -2-7KY12 ,1/ 0 +7-0 1/ :0 >1, -/ 2 0 71M 1/ 0 1 1,-!; L-0+*K 1-0,K10+-71-1-,"+-*1 G?1 <1, 1!/ 0+*K ?1 12 ,1-; + 1., < 1/ 0 +7-0 1-,0-*1" +7 ,516+*1H + 1-<,",1-0,; ",1 -!L-0,0 *?1 ,61 < 1 / 0,1 :< 71 + 1 , < 71 ?1 !2 6 71 ,0, 1/ 0 +7-0,?1,-,0 , 1 1M G1/ H / G?1 1!-; ,0 710+-7101 ,51., < ?1 *?1/,1 ",1< K?1+!28 1, -/ ; 2 1 ",1 :,/-,-71 1 + ",6-0 J%(1

D< ,1H ,-> 1/ : 1/ 0 10> = K 1,-, , 1<-,1 1 ,+71 / 0 1 1 0 2 ,",?1 ! 0-+7 ,",?1 - -, 2-,",1 2 + 101= : 1, L-0 1 1 !+7 ! >(1 , *1., <!1: , ?1 H ,-12 +,0 2-,",1-!L-0,0 *1 <1-<><1/ 6 K 1,/ ; 6 + !K1H ,-71: , !(1C>1 :6 +* <1/,: H K?1-,"+-,1 ,; , ,51-, -0 , 1-/ H . 2-, 1-,6 = 1/ 0 ?101, + 2 1, 1 6 !" G1-,H +7 >G1 "!+* , ,0?10> = 1 6-0,1-0, ,6>?1 0-0 1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-(11

;13 6 65113 6 5&3 6?1: +K2 KL-*101-, :< ; 10-G1 6 0 6,01,6 ,51-,H +7 ,51 /,- -7K?1,6 ,51 1 ,51= 1 0 ,51 < ,5(1 3 0 ,/ 0 1 1 0-0,1 91 ", 1 0: <,-0*; : > ?1 ,1 1 ,=6-0 > (1F6 12 +,0 1 1<,= 1 > 71 0 1 6 !",<!?1 ( (1 =6>51, + 6 1 /,0 , <>< 1,-, ,-*< 1 ; ++ ! +7 ,",?1. : 2-,",?1 0, 2-,",1 :0 *?1., < ! ; -*1 16 5-0! 101 :+ 2 >G1-,H ,; !+7 ! >G1!-+,0 *G(12 0 * 71 :+ 2 >G1+K6 51/,1,6 ,<!1 -6 !1 0,:<,= ,?1 1/ 2 ; -*1 /,/> 1 -6 + 71 M ,1 SI! 0 +,0 JT1 91 0 6 1 1 6 " 6 H 1 , L-0 1 1 !+7 ! >(18 1! 6 +7 ,1/, : + 10-< *1-,; *?10-1/,/> 1-,:6 71, L-0,1. 2-,",1 0-0 1: ,;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11753#6F75 '(?1 "!< 1 < 1S ,0 T(18 :-1-,0 < ,",1/ 0,-,: *1331 0,0 6 (1%EE@(1Q1R(17(1)(1

1

"

,< ,1/ 0,6* 1 1,6 <1 1 <1= 1 " 0 ><1 :!+7 <(1O ,1 91 0-0+-1 ",-!6-0 ,51 K , ?1 , :>0 KL 5-*1 ,+ 1 I 0 ,5J?1!-0+ 0 KL 51-6 1 0-0 1 1 , ,+ !KL 51 ",1 -, +K6 Y1 / *1 1 -,H +7 , 1 =6 0 2-0,1 -+ *?1 I< *KL ",J1 -0, 1/ 0 1 1 -0, ,6>1 1" ,0 !K1I/ 5 !JY1 /, *1 6 < 1 :0 *?1 :-,51 1 6 " 6 H *(1 A+*1 ! 0 +,0 1 G >1 < +,2 *1 "+ < H *1 < < +7 ,1 6,:0,+ ,",1 1 <-< +7 ,-71: / L ,",?1/ 2 <1/,61: / 1/,/ 6 10-?12 ,1 / 0>8 1 ! ,0 71 : ! *6 ,-?1 /,-6-0 ,-?1 *0+*-*1 /,6; + ,1 ,0 ,-<1 1/ 6,0><(1 H /1I: / L ,10-?12 ,1 1 : 8 ,J1: /!-1016 5-0 1< G :<>1 ,-0 H 1 1 , <,; = *1, L-0 ,",1 :0 *(1D< ,101 ,<1, L-0 1 H ; +7 ><1-,0-*10>-:>0 191I H 0 1 :! < J?1<-; -,0,51 91 -,H +7 ,;/-G,+," 2-*1 !-,0 1 1 /--0 ,-71 1 , ., < :<(1

12 0 =6 1 0-0 1 1 0 ,/ 0 *1 -6 1 0 >G?1 ( (1 0-0 1K 6 2-,",1910 = 58 *12 ?1-,6 = 1/ ; 0 (18 1/,62 0 +1 (1W 2 ?1I-*1/ 06 1-,-, 101/ ; : 1: 10-< 1 0 ,",12 +,0 2-,",16,-,-0 1 1-0, ,6>?101 G1 >1!-+,0 *G12 +,0 1 1 G,6 +-*?1 1 , 1 >1/,+,= 1 1: < +(1O ,1 10> =-*101 0-0 1/ 0?1 1K 6 2-,51 0,:<,= ,-1 6 5-0,0 7?1 , , *1 /-0 0-*1 + H!1 1 ,; 0,<!(1 ,1 1 1 -0, ,6 , 1/,+7:,0 1M < 1/ 0 < 10 6 1 1 0 ,<!1/ , K1= : >G1 + "?1 ,1/ : 1M ,",1 ; 0-0 ?10> KL ",1 :1-<,",1,-,0 ,",1 2 + ?1-,-0+* ?101 -0,K1 ,2 67?1 / < , 1 ,0 1 / 06>J%(1 : *1 I/ 06 J1 91 01 /,*0+ 1 , L-0 1 0, 2-1 H 0 >G1 1 / 6/ <2 0>G1+K6 5?1 , , > ?101 < G1!-,0+ >G1: ,; ,<1 0 >G10,:<,= ,-5?1 -<,-,* +7 ,1S-0, ,6 ,T1,/ 6 +*; K 1H + 1 1-6-0 1-0, 516 * +7 ,-?1 1/ , 0, 2 L 1: ,; !?1 -0, 51 M " 5?1 -0, < 1 + < 1 1 -/,-, ,-*< ?1 / 0 ; L KL < 1M 10,:<,= ,-1016 5-0 +7 ,-7(13 :!<-*?1/ 1 M ,<1 +7 ,1 / , > 1 S-! P 0 > T1 / 0 1 !6! 1 0; >< (1I4 6 2-, 1S., < +7 , T1 0-0,1-! P ,01/ 0 ?191 : < 2 15(D(17/ 6, ,0?191-,-, 1 101 ,<?12 ,1, 1, + 6 K 1 ,6 ,0>< 1/,1 -0, <!1 , ,<!1 -,6 = K1/ 0 < 1 1, *;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1A23 A57(12 :(1-,2(17(1EE(1

: ,-*< ?1 10,10: < ,-1 G1/ 01 1, *: ,-5?1,/ 6 + >G1 ,6 ,51 1 ,51= 1 0 ,, *: +7 ,5%1 , <,51/ 0 (1DG1K 6 2-, 1 0-0,1/ ,*0+*-*1 < ,10,10: < ,-1/ 01 1, *: ,-5?1 : 6 >G1 , < < J(1 , < +7 ,-71/ 0,0,",1 0-0 1 1 0 ; -0,1. 2-G1-! P 0 >G1/ 01-,:6 K 1,/ 6 + >51/, *; 6, 1 0-01 1 0-0?1-,"+-,0 >G1/,1 6 ,<!1,-,0 K1 1 , L 51 , < (1 3 :+ 2 1 01 / , >G1 / 0 G1 *0+*-*1 : , ,; < ><1 :!+7 ,<1 6 5-0 *1 / H / 1 / 0,0,",1 S., < +7 ,",T1 0-0 ?1 0 ,51/ 0,-/,-, ,-1 6 0 6,0(11

<1 , :,<?1 01 K 6 2-,<1 -<>-+ 1 0-0,1 ,: 2 1 0-0,1 01 / 0,;?1 6 ;1 1 6 + ,-/,-, ,-?1 0-0,1 / 61 -!6,<1 1: , ,<?1 0-0,101-G,6 >G1/ 0,0>G10,:<,= ,-*G?1 : 0-<,1, 1/,+ ?1->?1/ ,.--1 1 (6(1U , ,6 +7 , 1/ ; : 1K 6 2-,",1 0-0 1+K6 51 1, + 6 + 51 :> + ; <>G1/ 01 1-0, ,61-,-0+* 1-!L ,-, 1,/ 6 + 1-,0 < ; ,",1" =6-,",1, L-0 1 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 (1

F-,0 7-*1 1M ,<191: 2 1!/!-71 :10 6!1,2 71-7; : , 1 , -,* +7-0,(1 A,-,2 ,1 6 0 ,1 0>60 ! 1 " /, : 1 ,1 6- + : !KL 51 ,+ 1 0-0 1 01 -/ 6 + 1 6,G,6,01-+ *1 1/ 2 >1/-!/ ,-(1 ,1 , ,<!1: < 2 K19(D(1 E +-,",11 IE+ 0 ><1 01 " :-1 6 0 ,-?1 0 +K2 *1 / ; -!/ ,-7?1 *0+*-*1 1 -<1 /,1 - 1 ! ,0 71 !6,0+ 0, *1 0 ; +7 >G?1-,H +7 >G1 1 6 +7 >G1/, ,-5?1 1-/ 71 :+ ; 2 5?1I : >0 J1010,:<,= ,-*G1 G1!6,0+ 0, *16+*1 :+ 2 >G1 -,H +7 >G1" !//(1U 0-7?1 !6,0+ 0, ,-7?1/, < 1 -; <,510,:<,= ,-1= 71+!28 1/ G,6* 1+ 87101-0 J#(11 ,; +,= 01M !1 6 K101,-,0!1-0, 51" /, :>?17(E(1F+7 ,01-1/ < ; <1< < 2-G1 1-" 2-G1< ,6,01! 6 +7 ,1/,; : +?1 2 ,1 ,/ 6 + , 1 0-0,1 01 -/ 6 + 1 6,G,6,01 <,= 1 , :>0 71 + ",/ * , 1 0,:6 5-0 1 1 M , ,< 2-, 1 :0 1, L-0 (1 1 ,1= 10 <*160 = 1-,H +7 ,51- -<>1 1 ,2 1<-< +7 ,",1 : >0 1< =6!1 6 >< 1 1 ," >< 191 ; ,+ 1,/-,<!1-,-,* K1, L-0 1912 0 ,1-,.,5(1F ; -K6 10>0,61 0 , 11IZ1, 2 * > 1/,/> 1 0,+KH , ,0?1/ ; 0,0 6,01 16 !" G16 * + 5?1-<*L G-*1 1!-,0+ K1 0-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%18A AE656F78 !1 , *1",-!6-0 1 1/ 0 (1C(?1%EEE(17(1%%%(1

#1A A59CA 7* !18 < ,+," *(18!-1+ H 5(17 (?1#$$#(17(1%F$(1

1

$