Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

1 1

-0%(1 A ?1 0 *61 + 1 0,:<,= ,1 -+7-0 ,1 , < 71 !/, + ; 101 5 +7 ,; +--. H , ,<1-<>-+ 1 < 1I/ 0,J1/,1 , ,8 K1 1 +K ><1 ,"6 ;+ ,1 -!L-0,0 08 <1 + 1 ><1 -!; L-0!KL <1- -< <1: , ,6 +7-0 (1D:<-*1+ 1/ 1M ,<1 8 1, ,8 1 1I !+ 2 ,<!1/ 0!J1 1 /,6!1/ 0 1 1 ; ,0,",V1-<1+ 1<>1, ,-7-*1 1 = <!17 0 ,518, 1 1/, *6 !?1 !8 KL <!1M+ < > 1/ 0 12 +,0 ?1 <1-; <><1 -/ 0 6+ 0,<!V1 7 <,H ,-71 / 0 ?1 6 = 1 *0+**-71 / ,; 6! ,<1 6,-,2 ,1 /,:6 ",1 /, ,=6 *1 -, 1 2 +,0 2-0 ?1! 1 /, < *1 ",1 0 +K2 ,-1 01 - -, 2-?1 ( (?1 0,: KL 101 :!+7 1 ,/,-,H ," : 1 1 :0 0 KL-*1 0<-1 -1 2 +,0 2-0,<1 2 + 1 2 +,0 2-,51 6!G,0 ,-?1 , + ; 6 KL 1 :+ 2 ,51 < ,51 I*0+ ,-J101-, ?10> = KL 1 "!<-2-1 6 +>1 1 H ,-(1 ,: 0 , 1 / 0,1 0-"6 1 / 6! 1 1 , L , *: +7 ,-7?1 ,1 -< 1 , L , *: +7 ,-71 6,+= 1 > 71H ,-,1, ,-,0 ,5(1

,1 , ,8 K1 = 1 ,1 0-<1 /,6 <1 / 0 1 H +-,, : ,1 / < * 71/, * 1I / 0,J?1, ,-,0 , 1 L 1E " + <(1 < H; 51. +,-,.1/ 6+ " +1 :+ 2 71-,+7 ,10 6,01 / 0 11%T1 &3 3 5 1 &3 651S + 191/ ,-,6!8 *1 / 06 T?1G ; :!KL 1/,/> 1 -/, *L G1,1/ 0 1 -, , 1 -2 71 ,0><1 -, -0 > ?1 ," 2 > 1 / 6-0+ *11 #41 5!1 91 /,/> 1 :-0 71-2 71/ 0,<1 ,?12 ,1 <1 1*0+*-*Y1RT1&3 &1 916 5-0 *?1/,1, ,8 K1 1 , , ><1-,0 8 KL 51 G1 1 !=6 ;-*101 ,<;+ ,1, ,-,0 1M G16 5-0 51 1/ 0,< >G(1 D--+ 6,0 1 / 0 1 01 -0*: 1 -1 / , 0,/,+,= ><1 <!1 /, * <1 / 0 ?1 /,1 < K1 (8(17 < "!++ ?1 6 1 0,:<,= ,-71 ,+ 1 "+! , ,1 1, P < ,1/, < 716 5-0 1/ 0 1 10-1< <, .,:>?1 , , > 1 , ,1 / / 0 1 01 : >G1 -! H *G?1 ,H 0 71 1 /-06, , <!?1/-06,: , ?1/-!/ >51-",0, 1 ,?12 ,1/, ,51 < 1 ,. H +7 ,;0+->51 G ?1 / 6! 1 1 + " +7 !K1 + " ; < ,-7#(11

,:0 L *-71 1 , < 0 ,-1/ 0 ?1, < <?12 ,1/ 0,191 1 ,+7 ,1 ,?12 ,1, " 2 ,10> 1 :1= : 6 * +7 ,-1, L-; 0 ?1 / 0,1 / ,*0+*-*1 1 ,+7 ,1 01 ., < G1 -!H , +7 ,51

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11 , *1/ 0 1 1",-!6-0 (1C(?1%EE)(17(1#%(1

#1 ,6 , 1-<(11DA% A57'1 0,1 1 / 0,1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$$#(1Q1R(1

, < 0 ,-?1 ,1 1 01 , < 0 >G1 / 0,0>G1 !-,0+ *G?1 / 0,0>G1 / H / G?1 / 0,0,51 /,+ 1 01 :+ 2 >G1 ,-+*G1 : , ,6 +7-0 (1 7+ 6! 1 / * 71 0,1 0 < 1 1 < ?1 2 ,1

., < +7 *1 ,/ 6 + ,-71 91 1 -!L ,-, 1 2-0,1 / 0 ?1 1 + 871 -/,-, 10> = *1 ",1 , < 0 ,-?1 ( (1M ,1 2-0,10,1 < ,",<1: 0-1, 1- -<>1-,2 ,01/ 0 1 101-+!2 1 : 0 ; 8 ,-1 ., < +7 ,51 ,/ 6 + ,-1 <,= 1 > 71 / ,6,+ ,1 / 1 /,<,L 1 +," 1 / 0 1 + 1 : , ?1 ," 2 +7 ,",1 + 1-8 +7 ,",1 ,+ ,0 *(1

?1 / < ?1!1-,0 8 ,+ ",101-<7 1, *: ,-51 / 0,0,",1-0,5-0 1 > 71 1<,= ?1 ( (1/, !6 71 1 G1-/,+ K1 ",1 0,:<,= ,?1/,M ,<!1/, * 1I-< 5 ,;/ 0,0,51-!-1-,; 0 8 ,+ ",J1, + 2-*1, 1, L / * ,",101 < G1/ 0 1 <?12 ,1:6-71-,2 K-*1/ 0 101-,",<1/, < 1M ,",1-+,0 1 -1, *: ,-*< 1<, +7 ,",1G (1

8 1!: , , < 0 ,",1/,6G,6 1 1/ 0!1 1,: 2 1!< ; + *1 , P 0 ,51 ,+ 1 , < 0 ,-1 / 0 (1 0,0 *1 , < ?1 !6!2 1, , L ,51<,6 +7K1, L-0 >G1, ,8 51 1/,0 6 ; *1+K6 5?1/,:0,+* 1-! , 6 ,0 71 1 ,, 6 ,0 712 +,0 ; 2-!K16 * +7 ,-7?1 8 71-/, >1 1 , .+ >?1/ 6!/ =6 71 -,H +7 > 16 0 H ?10,--0+ 0 71-/ 0 6+ 0,-7(1 1 , ; < 0 ,",1/,6G,6 1 1<,= 1 > 71 -,0 8-0,0 *1: , ,6 ; +7-0 ?1 : , 1 / 0 +1 : , ,6 +7 ,51 G ?1 !2 1 1 - -< : H 1 , < 0 >G1 ,0?1 01 -,0 < >G1 !-+,0 *G1 91 -,:6 *1 ., < H , ,;/,-,0>G1 - -<1 1 6 !" G1 /-/ ; 0 >G1 / 0+ 51/ 0,0,51-+!= >(1 , < 0 >51/,6G,610>; -!/ 1 ,-,0,51 / 0,0,",1 0,-/ *1 1 / 0,0,51 / ,/ " 6>?1 ( (1I/ 0,10,, L J10-"6 1-!L-0! 101 , ,;-, 2-,51

., < 1 ,/ 6 + ,51 / 0,0,51 - -<>(1 , H?1 ,+7 ,1 01 M ,<1 -+!2 16,-"-*1: , ,-7?10 G,0-0,1/ 0 ?1-G,6*L 1 :1 ",1,. H +7 ,",1!-,0+ *1 1 6 ,, : *1/, < *(1

A+*1 /, < *1 -/,-, 1 -!L-0,0 *1 / 0 1 , G,6 <,1 /,< 71,1 ",1., < +7 ,51,/ 6 + ,-(1 0,10-"6 1-!L-; 0! ?1 !6!2 10,/+,L ><101,/ 6 + !K1-! +7 !K1., <!Y1 : , 1 / 6-1 / 61 < 1 1 ,/ 6 + *1 : ,0 *1 - -< (1 A 5-0 ,-71/ 0 1 0,:<,= 10 1 ,2 ,-1, ,: 2 *101 ; -1 , <>1, -,* +7-0?10>:>0 KL G1/ 0,0> 1/,-+ 6-0 *?1,/;

1

6 + *1M G1/,-+ 6-0 51 1 2-0?1/-!L G1-! P <1/ ; 0,, ,8 5(11

D?1 <1 1< ?1 1 >1 1 >+ 10 = >16+*1/ 0, 0, 2-,51 1 / 0,/ < +7 ,51/ 1: 6 2 1., < +7 ,51,/ 6 + ,-1 1 6 ,, : ,",1/, < *1-1/ 0,0,51 , <>?12 <!1-+!= ?1 / < ?1 / ,H 6! >1 " << 2-,",1 S*:> ,0,",T?1 +," 2-,",1 + 1-< 2-,",1 ,+ ,0 *1: , ?1, 16 + ,1 1-2 />0 K 1 < ,",< ,-1/ 0 1 1 ",10 +K2 ,-101= : 71, L-0 1 1 !+7; ! >101H +,<(171. +,-,.-,;/ 0,0,51 ,2 1: *1-,H , !+7 ! ; *1/ ,6 1/ 0 1 ! 10 < *1 1G !?1 2-0!?1 1 ,+7; ,1 1/ 0,0,<!?1 ,1 1 1-,H +7 ,<!1-!-!1 ,+ ,0 +*?101H +,<191 1 -<,<!18 , ,<!1 ,-!1-,H +7 ,",1 > *1/ 0%(1

D-!H , + : H *1 / 0 1 6,-"-*1 1 -,+7 ,1 ",1 :; +,= <1 01 , < 0 >G1 G1 + 1 !-0, <1 / 6/-51 , ; L-0 ><1 -,: <?1 -,+7 ,1 -,:6 <1 - -<1 / 0,,G ; +7 >G1, " ,01 1/ ,H--! +7 >G1/ 0 +1 G16 * +7 ,-(1 ; 0,1 !6 ,,-!L-0 <,1 :1 ",-!6-0 ,",1 // ?1 / 0; + ,",1 1/ < 1/ 0,0>G1 , <?1 8 1-/, ,0?1/ !=; 6 1 1-/,+ K1 1 -, +K6 K1/ 0 ?1 : 1/ 0, !; 8 + 5(13 "!+*H *16 * +7 ,-1+K6 51 -1 , G,6 <,-7K1/ ;

,10+->5?1/ !6 +7 >51G ?1/,-,+7 !101-,H ; +7 ,<10: <,6 5-0 1-+ 0 K-*1 :+ 2 > ?1/, ,51/ , 0,; /,+,= > 1->?10> KL 1 :1 :+ 2 ,",1 1 0 ,",1/,; +,= *1 +K6 51 01 - -< 1 , L-0 >G1 , ,8 5(1 ,M ,<!1 : 8 1 -,H +7 >G1 / , 0, 2 5?1 0> , 1 ,/ 6 + >G1 H ; + 51 1-6-016 5-0 *1,/ K-*1 10,+ 0, 1 8 ?1 1!" ,:!1 / < *1-+>(1 +->51-/,-, 1 "!+*H 10> 1 :1-<,51 / ,6>1 , L-0 >G1 , ,8 5?1 -+ 6>0 KL G-*1 :1 -,; 2 ,",1< ,",, : *1 1-2 / <,51-+,= ,-1 6 0 6! +7; >G1/,-!/ ,0?10: <,6 5-0 5191 G1 / ,-,1/ 0-1 1 6 ,51 H , +7 ,51 0> , ,51 <,6 + (1 +-7?1 -<*L *-*1 > 71

. , ,<1 !/, *6,2 *1 6 * +7 ,-1 +K6 5?1 6,+= ?1 -G,6*1 :1

,P 0 >G1, ,8 51 1, -,* +7-0?1/,66 = 0 71 1! /;

+* 71 ,6 1 :1 G?1 +, ,0 71 1 : / L 71 6 !" (1 3 :!<-*?1 / 1M ,<1<>16,+= >1/,< 71,1 G1-+ G1-<,, " : H 1 1-; <, "!+*H ?1 , , > 1 -!L-0!K 1 01 , L-0 1 /,< <,1 -!;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11( A56F 7! 7+,-,. *1/ 0, 0, 2-0 (1B ! "?1%EEF(17(1)&;&F(1

H , +7 ,1, " :,0 ,510+-?191-0*: > 1-1-,H +7 ,51/ ; ,6,51-<,",12 +,0 1 1/ 0 2 >G1., <1 ",1= : 6 * +7 ,-(1 ,1 ,-!-0 1 + 1 / + 21 0+-1 0 6! 1 1: !8 K1- -<>1 , < 0 ,51 "!+*H ?10,:-K1 / 6-:! <,-1 !6!L ; ",?16,< ,0 K10,+ 1-+7 ,",?1-= K1: L L ,-12 ; +,0 (1

3 :!<-*?1 0,-/ * 1 -,H +7 ,51 - +7 ,-1 1 + " 1 16,+= ,10-1 1! 0 =6 K1,1 :!-+,0 ,51/,: 0 ,-1+K; ,51!/, *6,2 ,-(12/, *6,2 ,-71<,= 16,-" 7-*160!<*1 / *<,1/ , 0,/,+,= >< 1-/,-, < 191 12 :1" <, : H K?1 -,"+-,0 ?1 ,</ ,<--1< =6!1 :+ 2 >< 1-< 1 16 5; -0 *< ?1 1 1/,-6-0,<1 /--?1" ! ,",1/,6 0+ *1,6 G1-,0101/,+7:!16 !" G(1

C>101H +,<1-,+ 6 >1-1/,: H 51 (D(1F0-/* 11I : ; 0 *10 = ,-71-,,-*1/ 0 101!-+,0 *G16 <, 2-,",1",; -!6-0 1-1.! H *< 1S< ,6 < T1-<!+ ,0 *?1/,,L *1 1 ," 2 *1 1 6,/!-<,-71 I < + : H J1 , 0-0 ,; -101: , ,6 +7-0 ?1/ 1 1 !2 ,; , 2-G1,/ 6 ; + *G?1 <1 1< ?1, < <?12 ,1 ,0> 1 , H /H 1/ 0 ?1K ; 6 2-,51, 0-0 ,-1 16,+= >1I-< 7J101 2-0 1/ ; , ,51G-!1/ 0 12 :1 ", K1",-!6-0 ,; ",1/ !=6 *J(%1 0,0 *1 , < 10 1-H ?10 10,:<,= ,-1 / !=6 *1/ 0 L-*101 + ", 1/,= + (1

,1 , ,=6-0+ 1 / 0 1 -1 -+ <1 0 ,1 /, ,<!?1 2 ,1-+ 191 10,, L 1/ !=6 ?1 10,, L 1-1!L 1 = : 1 1-, -0 ,-?1 ,1+ 871 , 1/ !=6 1 1-1 !L ?1 , , , 1 !8 1, L / : > 1/ 0 1 1-0, ,6>12 ; +,0 1 1" =6 (1 0,1/ !6 +7 ,1/, ,<!?12 ,1-!L-; 0!K 1/ 0 + ?1 , , > 1 , G,6 <,1-, +K6 7(1 : 1 1< ; 1",-!6-0 ,",1/ !=6 *?1 : 2 < *1/,1/ ",0, !1-!; 6 ?1 1-0 1/ 61-, ,51H + 1/ 2 *1. : 2-G1-6 51 + 1! = *12 +,0 2-,",16,-,-0 (1 1M ,<1-+ 6! 1, < ; 7?12 ,1 : 1 : = ,1-,6 = 101- 1<,< 1 >?1: ; +K2 KL 5-*1 01 / 6!-<, >G1 2",+,0 ><1 ,6-,<1 3 1 + ; 8 1 + 1," 2 1/ 01 1-0, ,610 ,0 ,",1+ H 1S2(%1-(1@R1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 6F938 57 1 !1 E,-!6-0 , 1 / !=6 1 1 / 0,0 *1 ", *1 331 3,--5-51 K 6 2-51=! +(1#$$&(1Q1%(17(1%&(1

1

2813 T(1F-,0 >< 1H +*< 1 : *1*0+*K-*110,--,0+ 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-?1 -/ 0+ 1 ,-!=6 ,",?1 / ,. + 1 -,0 ; 8 *1 ,0>G1/-!/+ 5(1

1A, ,0,+7 , 1 -/,+ 1 6 0 6 < 1 / 0 +1 /,0 6 *1 + ",6 *1-<,/ !=6 K1 1 ,=6-0 ,10 8 <!10,:6 5; -0 K1 ",-!6-0 (1 g + 1 6 <, 2-,",1 , L-0 1 / 6/,+ ; " K 1/,-/ !K1: < !10 8 ",1 "!+ ,0 *1/,0 6 *1+K; 6 51-<, "!+ ,0 <?10 ! <1 , ,+ <1-<,51+ 2 ,-1 -0, G16 5-0 5?1,-,: <1-,H +7 ,",1: 2 *1 G1H + 51 1/,; -+ 6-0 5(1 , 2-,51 +7 0,51 +--2-,<!1 / 6; -0+ K1 ,1 < ,6 G1 ",-!6-0 ,;/ 0,0,",1 "!+ ,0 *11 ! =6 *1 1 / !=6 *1 91 -",6 *1 *0+*-*1 ,H 1 / 0 1 1

., <>1 0,:6 5-0 *1 2 :1 / 0,0, 1 -<!+ ,0 ?1 /,,L ?1 ," 2 (1 014( (1C +7 ,?1, L *10 < 1 1 ,?12 ,1: ; 6 2 1 / 0 1 -,-, 1 1 ,+7 ,1 01 -6 = 0 1 / 0, !8 51 1 : 1 0 ,0 >G1 + H?1 ,1 1 01 -<!+ ,0 1 / 0,< ,",1 /,0 6 *1 101/,,L 1+ H?16 5-0!KL G101-G1, L-; 0 (1 F-, ,-71 /,,L +7 >G1 -H 5?1 /,62 0 1 , ?1 01 , -/ 2 1 G1-,H +7 >G1H + 51S + "T?1 6 16,-= *1 , ,; >G1 <,6 +71 / 0,< ,",1 /,0 6 *1 /,66 = 0-*1 K 6 2 ; -< 1-6-0 < ?1,-, ,1 G1H + 5?16,-= 1 , , >G1 >; < 1-/,-, < 1 0,:<,= ,(1 0,0, 1/,,L 1--< 0-*1 1., < 1 1< 1K 6 2-,",1,6, *16, ,0,+7 ,",1:-+!; = ,",1/,0 6 *?101 :!+7 12 ",16+*1-! P 10,: " =6 ; *1 -!/ K 1 + ",/ * > 1 /,-+ 6-0 *1 91 / < ?1 /,2 > 1 :0 *?1 , 6 1 1 < 6 + 1 1 (/(1 : 1 /,,L +7 >G1 -; H 5?1-2 14( (1C +7 ,?1I !6 1,: 2 716 +7 58 160 = 1 !2 ,51<>-+ 1 1K 6 2-,51/ 1/,1/! 1-8 *1/,; : 0 >G1 2 +101/ 0 ?1!0 + 2 *1h-<!+ !KL ",10-i1 ",1 -6-0?1 ,+ 1 : ,-, , ",1 -/,+7:,0 *1 !/ 0+ 2-G1 < ,6,010,:6 5-0 *ZJ%1

1 ,M ,<!1 , G,6 <,10>6 +* 7160,5-0 !K1/ ,6!1/ ; 0,0,",1 / !=6 *11 - -0 !K1 1 -! -6 ,0 !K(1 2 6 1/ !6 +7 ,-71, !-+,0+ 1H ,-><1-,6 = <1 / 0 ?1! 3561-+ 1 1< +7 *1: L 1/ 0 1" ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11( )C67 '14 6 2-1/,,L *1 1 : ,0 6 ,-71-,H +7 >G1-H 51331 F L-0 > 1 ! 1 1-,0 < ,-7(1%EE&(1Q1@(17(1'F9'&(1