Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

-,51-+ ?1/ ,6 1-!L-0!KL ",1, L-0 J%(1 ,6, , 1 0 6 ; 16,+= ,1, -/ 2 0 71 -/- -,-71 1/ , 1, L G1-,0?1-+K2 1 ;+ ,1 , + H ?1 / 0+ > 1/ , 01 < 78-0 (1 7+ 6,0 +7 ,?1 -< 1 -! H *1 0> !=6 1 +K ,",1 !2-1, L-0 ,",16,",0, 1: L L 71/,+,= 1 ,+ 1 6 >G1 1-,H +7 ,1!*:0 <>G?1/,-,+7 !1 ,1 1:-G,0 1, 1 /,/ 6 *101M !1" !//!(1 1/ 6< 1= 16,",0, 10G,6* 11/ H /1 /,+ 2-,51 -0, ,6>1 1 0-0 1 01 -/ 6 + 1 ,-,0 >G1 / 01 1, *: ,-51S =6>51 < 1/ 0,1 1-0, ,6!?1-,0<-; <!K1 -,1 -0, ,6,51 6 !" GT?1 1 / H /1 ,+78 ",1 + " 1 6+*1 ,+78-0 12+ ,01, L-0 191IZM , ,< 2-, 1 1-,H +7 , 1 0-0,1-/ 0 6+ 0>1 ,+7 ,1 ,"6 ?1 ,"6 1-! 1, L!K1/,+7:!1 1 ,</-!K 1/, 1 ,+ 1 : L L ><12+ <1, L-; 0 J#(1 ,1-7?16,/!-<,1 1+K , 1 0-0,?1 ,1+ 871 , ?1 ,; , , 1<-< +7 ,1: L L 1/,: H 1-,H +7 >G1 !-56 ,0(1A,; -+,0 ,11 I7,H +7 > 1 1 M , ,< 2-1 0-0 1 6,+= >1 > 71 , " :,0 >1 <1, :,<?12 ,1, 1,6 ,0 < ,11

T10 6! 1 1 ,+78 510>",6 1 < 1/ !-/ 08 G?101-,; , 0-0 1 -1 / H /,<1 -/ 0 6+ 0>G1 - = 51 1 T1 6 + K 1 , > >< 16+*10-G16,+= ,-1 1/,+,= *101!-+,0 *G12-,",1 0-0 10,:<,= ,-5JR(11

8 16 ,51 , H /H 1 :,-,0 +7 ,1! :>0 K 1 1 1!*:0 <> 1<-116+*13,+: 1-<,1-, ,51 :!< KL 5-*10>-!/ 1 ! 0-+7 *1/ 0 = ,-710-G1+ +7 ,;6 <, 2-<1 H ,-*<1 6 0 6! +7 >G1 -0, ,6?1 H , +7 ,-1 1 (/(1 <1 -<><1 " , !K-*1 / 6-0+ *1 ,1 / , >G1 + " G1 01 >G1 !+7 ! >G1 ,-G?1 1 0,0 1 -,0 < >G1 : / 6 >G1 6 <, 5?1 1 1 0 ! 1 G(1 A=(1 3,+:1 1 : < 2 1 .! 6 < ; +7 ,",1/ , 0, 2 *1-0, G1/,-, 5191-<+ 1-+K2 71 !K;+ ,1 / 6: 6 ,-71 0:"+*6,01 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-71 -G,6 1 :10/,+ 1,/ 6 + ,51/,: H (1

,+ 1, ,-,0 >< 1/ 6-0+*K-*10,:: *1 1-/ 0 6; + 0,-71 C 5 + 1 2,+: 1 91 / 6-0 +*1 & 3 3 5 51 /,6G,6 ?1-G,6*L ",1 :160!G1"+ 0 >G1 :-,011 :-1F-,0 >G1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 7<(11 323 9C 7 '1 7,0 < >51 6-!-1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-11 A=, 1 3,+:1 + 1 C 5 +1 2,+: V1331F L-0 > 1 ! 1 1-,0 < ,-7(1#$$%(1Q1#(17(&$(1

#1323 9C 7 '12 :(1-,2(17(&%(1 R1B6 77,:12 :(1-,2(17(1#F'(1

1

7. 1 1 :-1 6,< ,0 *?1 /,6 :!< 0 KL ",?1 2 ,1 -/ ; 0 6+ 0,-710-"6 1*0+*-*1,H ,51-/,-, 1-/ 6 + *1S6-;!H T1-,H +7 >G1S< +7 >G1 16!G,0 >GT1 + "(1 1/ 0,<1 -+!2 1/ 6/,+ "-*?12 ,1IZ-,H +7 > 1 + " 1S + ",-,-,* ?1 :,/-,-7?16,+= ,-7?1, :,0 ?1/ :0 1 1 (6(T1 :6 +*; K-*1 1 I-. >J?1 !/ 0+* <> 1 :+ 2 >< 1 6- ! 0 >< 1 / H / < Y1M 1/ H />1,/ 6 +*K 1/ <+ <, 1 0-0,1 01 =6,51-. (1F 1-0,6*-*1 18-1 ,+ 1 :0-><1., ; < <1-/ 6 + +7 ,51-/ 0 6+ 0,-11%T1 =6,<!191,6 ,1 1 ,1 = 1SM" + , 1 0-0,TY1#T1 =6,<!191/,1/, ,-*<Y1RT1 ; =6,<!1 91 /,1 :-+!" <Y1 @T1 =6,<!1 91 /,1 "!Y1 )T1 =6,<!1 91 /,1 / ,.--, +7 ,51/ ",6 ,-Y1FT1 =6,<!191 ,?12 ,1/,+,= ,1/,1 : , !J%(1 / < ?1 01 < 6 H-,<1 , -+!= 0 1 !=6 K-*1 / 0!K1,2 671 ,+7 > ?1 ,"6 1 1/ 6,-0+ 1 , >1: 0 ; -1, 1/ ,.--, +7 >G1 2-0Y1-!67 1 16 /! >1 6 +*K-*1 <<! ,<?1 1!2-1 , 0>G16 5-0 5191+7", < 1 1 (6(1 ; :-1= 1 6,< ,0 *1: +K2-*101 6,/!-<,-1/ ,-1 / H / 1-/ 6 + *1S 1-,, 0-0!KL ",1 0-0 T1 :1,6; ,51-. >1016 !"!K(1 /,+ 1+," 2 ,?1/ ,6,+= *1M !1 6 K?10 6 71 ," 2 ,-71 + 1 6 = 1 0,:<,= ,-71 / ,-1 / H /,01-/ 6 + *?1 G 1 -,H +7 >G1 + "1 :1 ,6 ,",1 , L-0 1 S !+7 ! >?1H 0 + : H T1016 !", (11

W > 1 ,-,0 >G1 <,6 + 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-1 --< 0 1 4(C(1F G,0191%T1-+,0 *1<,6 +7Y1#T16,",0, *1<,6 +7Y1RT1 ! ; 0- -*1<,6 +7Y1@T1! +- -*1<,6 +7(11

15651<,6 + ?1-<,51/ ,-,51 1-<,516 0 5?1-/ 0 6; + 0,-71!-0+ 0-*1-+,5101., < ?10>",6 ,51 ,<!?1 ,1M ,51 -+,51, + 6 (1 ,6, *1<,6 +71G 16+*1M-<- -G1 1 , + >G1 6 ,+," 5?16+*1<-:< ?1/,+ " KL ",?12 ,1",-; /,6-0!KL 51 +--1 0*:>0 1 , L-0!1 -0, 1 / 6-0+ *1 ,1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-1 : 1 -+K2 <?1 :!<-*?1 ,<<!-2-,51 , L-0 ,51 ., < H (1 65 5653 1 <,6 +71 S4-, +7?1 -,;

.->?1A(15, ?1 (1E, -?1D(18 1 16 (T191 ?1/ 1 , , ,51-,-,*; 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-1!-0+ 0-*1/! <1 +7 ,",1 + ?1-, ?1 " /, 2-,",1I6,",0,*815 61<,6 +71SA=, 6=1 C! T1-,-,* 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-1!-0+ 0 1 ! 0 ><1-/,;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1B6 77,:12 :(1-,2(17(&)(1

-, ,<1 + 1 ! 0 ><1-,"+ 8 <1< =6!10-< 1-! P < 101 , L-0 (1F 1 , 1 1! ,0 1, >6 ,",1-,: *?1 1 ,+ ?1 1 1 1, + 6 1/, H +,<1, L : 2 <,-(1F 31<,6 +71SD < *1 <T1 ,-! ! 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-71/,; -6-0,<1 I-2 1 1 +7 !+*H J1 !6,0+ 0, 51 /,1 8 + ?1 / 0,6*L 51 1 0>",6 58 <!1 +-!1,6 ,0 < ,16+*10-G1 2+ ,01, L-0 (1 1-<,<16 + 1M 1<,6 +71/,6< * 1-/ 0 6+ ; 0,-71 M..0 ,-7K?1 , , *1 0 ,-1 M+ < >1 H , +7 ,",1 0> , ?1 ,1 1 8 1 / , + <!11 1 -,0<-71 <-< : H K1 0>",61 ,6 ,",1 6 0 6 1 1 <-< : H K1 0>",61 0-G1 6 0 6,0?1 ( (1, L-0%(11

!6 ,1: < 710 ! KK?1"+! , !K1-0*:7?1 :6 +7; ,-7?10: < !K1, !-+,0+ ,-710-G1H ,->G1 1! 0-+7; >G1/ : ,01/ 0 ?10> = KL G1-,H +7 !K1 16!G,0 !K1/ ; ,6!1 2 +,0 (1 6-0+*-*1 < ,6,+," 2-1 /+,6, 0, ><1 + :1 6-0 1H ,->G1/ : ,01/ 0 12 :1-/,+7:,; 0 1 ", 1 I /,- -7J(1 A +,1 1 01 ., < +7 ,51 , 2 ,-?1 /,< KL 51,170* ,51 , H ?1<,"! 1 > 71 16 !" 1 ,+ 2-; 0 > 1 0 >(1 8 ", *1 /,- -1 !6 2 ,1 0> = 1 6 K?1 -1 ,6 ,51 -, , >?1 :6 +7 ,-1 -,-0+*KL G1H +, ?1 -16 !",5191 G1 -+ * ,-(1 A 5-0 +7 ,?1 -,6 = 1 / 6-0+ 51 ,1 -0, ,6 ?1 0-0 1 + 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-1 1<,= 1 > 71, ,=6-0+ ; ,?1 =6, 1 :1M G1/, * 51-/ H . 2 ,(1 1 ,1= 10 <*1+ " ,1!0 ; 6 7?1 2 ,?1 / < ?1 / , :0,+?1 !L <+ 1 65!5 "1 7," 2 1 / 0,-/,-, ,-1 + 16-/,-, ,-T1 : = ,1, :>0-*1 ; !8 <1 0-0 1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-Y101-0,K1,2 67?1-/ 0 6; + 0,-71S/ 6,-0+ 1,6 <1+ H <1/ 0 + " 51/,1, ,8 K1 1 6 !" <1+ H <T10-"6 1/,/ 1 0-0,1 1-0, ,6!(11

> = *1., < +7 , 13 6 65?1/ 0,1*0+*-*1., <,51, ; ,8 51 : 0-<>G?1 0 , ,< >G1 6 0 6,0?101-0, <1/,0 6 1 /,62 *KL G-*10-, L 51 , < ?1 <1-<><1/ 0 L 1-0, ,6!1 :10,:<,= ,-1016 5-0 +7 ,-7(170, ,6 1 :1 0-0 1, , ; 2 0-*1",-/,6-0,<1/ 0 + " ,0 ,",1< 78-0 ?1 0-; 0,1 :1-0, ,6>10 6 1 1! 0 +,0 (1D101 ,<?1 1016 !",<1-+!2 1 -0, ,6 1 1 ,0 *1-2 : (11

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%16 3.6F7 (17/ 0 6+ 0,-71 1 :->51/ H /1!-,5-0 1, L-0 11/! 71 1,2 ; 0 6 ,-1331 ,/ ,->1. +,-,. (1#$%$(1Q1E(17(1F@9FF(1

1

"

0,0 *1 &3 6 651 0> = 1 0-0,1 6,-= *1 + 2 ,",1 + " 1 -1 < 1 = 1 / *: *< 1 6 !" G1 +K6 5(1 3 0 *1 < 1 -0, ,6>1 ! 1 -, :< ,-1 SM 0 0 + ,-T1 0,10: ; <,, ,8 *G1< =6!1 6 0 6 < 1 1-! P < 1/ 0 (14 +,; " 2 ,?1/ 0,0, 1 0-0,?1 1 + 1 2 ?1 ,1-0*: ,1-1/ , :0,; +,<1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-7K(1 0,0, 1 0-0,191M ,10-"6 1 0 ; -0,1-0, ,6 >G1+K6 5?1 0 *1< 1-0, ,6>1 6 0 6,0(1

H /1 0-0 1<,= ,1--< 0 7?1-1,6 ,51-, , >?1 1 *0 !K1/ 6/,->+ !16,-= *1-/ 0 6+ 0,-?1 1-16 !",51 91 1/ /*-0 ?1 , , , ?10,:<,= ,?1/ 6-*1, G,6 71 1/! 1 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-(1 BL 1 <,= ,1 0> : 7-*1 -+ 6!KL <1 , :,<11 0-0,1,2 0 6 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-?1 ,16 + ,1 10-* , 1 0 ; -0,1 ,: 2 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-7?1 ?1 1 / 0 +7 ,1 , < 2 +1 E " +7?1 M , ,< 2-, ?1/,+ 2-, 1 1/ 0,0, 1 0-0,101 , , >G1 -! H *G1<,= 101", :6,1 ,+78 51-/ 1-/,-, -0,0 716,-; = K1-/ 0 6+ 0,-?12 <1 0-0,101 ",1 :+ 2 >G1., < G(1 X , ,1 :0-,1 : < 2 1 ,6, 2 +7 1 . H!:-,",1 , ; -0 :< 1 (16 1C-?1, L , 1/ , 01 6 ,+,",01 H!:; -,51 0,+KH 11I >1= + 1 0-0 1< =6!1+K67< 1/, ,<!?1 2 ,10>1,8 ,2 ,1-2 1 G1,6 ,0>< Z10>1 ,+ ! 1,1/ ; 0 G1 2 +,0 ?1 / 8 1 , L 2 +,0 2-1 ,-!H Y1 *-,?1 2 ,?1 /,10 8 <!1< K?1 :+ 2 *1< =6!1+K67< 1 Y1/! <1!<,: +K; 2 *10>1/ 8+ 1 1, 0+ 2 ,<!1/, * K1,12 +,0 1 10-1/ ! ,; 2 0 1 1M ,51. H J%(1 1 0 ,/ 5-,51 ,-0 0 ,51<>-+ 1 6 *1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-1-0*:>0-*1-1,-, ,5?1G,+- -,5?1 , H /H 51-0,; ,6>?1 , , *1/ 6+ = 1 1, 6 +7 ><1 6 0 6 <?1 1, L ,-*<1 +K6 51S",-!6-0!?1, L <?1-,-+,0 *<1 1 (/(T?1/ 6-0+**1-, ,51 - -<!1/ 0 + " 5(1 ,1-7?1-0, ,6 1 1<,= 1 > 710-, L 5?1 1 " H>1: 0-* 1, 1 2-01-,H +7 >G1-! P ,0?1 6 0 6! +7 *1 -0, ,6 1<,= 10>-!/ 71-,2 ,<1 G (1A,+= 1 > 71!-; ,0+ 1 G *1-0, ,6>?1 1 ,2 191 G *1/ 0 + " 5?1/ , ; 0,-,*L *1 M" + ,51 -0, ,6 (1 1 M ,<1 /,6G,6 1 /-!-0! 1 ; H , +7 , 1 ,-,0 1 6+*1 6 ..H H 1 / 0?1 / 6,-0+ *1 / 0,0>G1+7", 1 1/ 0 + " 5(1

(7(1- -* H?1/,6 :!< 0 *1/,61-!L ,-7K1/ 0 1/ H /1

., < +7 ,",1 0-0 ?1 <1 1< ?1, < 2 +?12 ,1I/-!L *1/ 0!1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1(39 71 E3(13--!=6 1,1 H (1C(?1%EE'(17(1%EF(1

0-, L *1 0 *1< 191M ,1 < ,1 0 *1< 1-0, ,6>1 1-/ 0 6; + 0,-?1 1-0, ,6 1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-71 0,:<,= >10 1 1 :1 0-; 0 1 S, L 51 0 ,51 < >TJ(%1 7/ 0 6+ 0,-71 91 6,-,2 ,1 < , 1 1 < ,",< , 1 /, * ?1 <,= ,1 ",0, 71 ,1 -0, , : 1 <, +7 ,5?1 /,+ 2-,5?1-,H +7 ,5?1M , ,< 2-,51 1 (/(1-/ 0 6+ 0,-(1 ,1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-71/ 0 1S ,+7 ,1/ 0,1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,?1/,1 (7(1-; -* HT#1<,= ,1/, * 71 ,+7 ,1-G,6*1 :1 6-0 ?10: <,/ /+ ; *1-0, ,6>?1 0-0 1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-(11

F , L *?1-,"+-<-*1-1/ 6+,= <1,10>6 + 160!G1-; / ,01/ 0 ?1 , , > 1<,= ,1, P 6 7101,/ 6 + 1-!L ,-1 / 0 (1 ,1-71-!L-0 > 1/ : 1/ 0 1 , G,6 <,16 ..; H ,0 71/,1, ,8 K1 1-,6 = K1 1., < 1/ 0 (1

1D ?1&3 6516" & 1 15!8 6 515! 56 1 1

6"3 +9 1 3 !56 1 &3 6 65 15!9 1 3 1 65!5 "1 13 6 6 B16"3 161 15$. ",B1 $53 5 5&3 ",1 15!9 5!-",1 53 17&3 6 41&56 1 1 5 1 5. ",1 !8 56B15! & % ",1

5 1& ! % 5 17 5 3 6 5T16(11 : <,-0*:7160!G1-, , 1/ 0 1G, ,8,10 6 1G, *1 >1 :1 ,;

",?12 ,1-,2 ,<10-, L ,-1 1 -,-1/ 0 1*0+*-*1 / < 1 0 ,51 < >1 1 0 ><1 6 0 6 <(1 4 +," 2 ,1 , < 0 ,-71/ 0 10 ,-101, L-0 > 1, ,8 *1M+ < >1 0-0 ?1 / 0,1 / 1 /,<,L 1 , L G1 / 0 +1 + :! 1 /, ; ,-71, L-0 101! 0 =6 1 , < 0 >G1 2 +(1

,*-<?12 ,1,/ 6 + 1/ 0 12 :1-0, ,6!1 1/ , 0,; 2 1 / : K1 ",1 0,+ 0,",1 G ?1 ( (1 / 0,1 6-,0 ,1 < ,1 -0, ,6 ,51 0,+ 1 -! P ,01 , L-0 >G1 , ,8 51 1 < 1-<>-+1 ,+7 ,1 <?1"6 1!1 6-,01 , <>1-!L-0! 10> , 1 0 ,01/,0 6 *(1 0,0> 1/ 6/-*1 6-,0 >1 < ,1 0,+ ?1 1 1 ,+7 ,1 ++ !?1 ,16+*1 + : H 1/ 0 1 6,-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 3 939 5#7' 70,1 1 , G,6 < *1., < 1 0-0 ?1-0, ,6>1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-1331 7,H ,+," 2-1--+ 6,0 *(1#$$%(1Q1%$(17(1@(1

#1I7/ 0 6+ 0,1 ,?12 ,10> = 1/ 0,?1-,, 0-0! 1/ 0!1 1-+ 6! 1/ 0!(1A 5-0,; 0 71/,1-/ 0 6+ 0,-191: 2 16 5-0,0 71/ 0,< ,?1-,, 0-0 ,10-, L <1 1 0 ><1 ,0 *<1/ 0 J1S 3 939 5#7'1 +,-,. *1/ 0 (1C(?1#$$$(17(1RRT(1 ,1 ; , G,6 <,1!2 >0 7?12 ,1/,: 0 , 1/ 0,1 1/,"+,L 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-7191-/ 0 6+ ; 0, 1 8 1-/, 1,1/ 0 1<,= 1 > 716,-" ! ,101 :!+7 16,-!6 >G1/ ",0,; ,0?1/ < *?1< 6 H 1 1,-,0 10 + ,6!8 *?1/ ,L *?1<!6 ,- (11

1

$