Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

<, *1 : >0 >11 0 1 6 <, 1 1 !-+,0 51 6+*1 + : ; H 1/ 0 1,6 110+-7?10 1/ 0 16 <, *1/ 0 L-*1 0,10-6,:0,+ ,-7?101 ," 2 >51: , ,<1/ , :0,+10+-?1 ,+/>?101-+ 1/ ,-,",1 ,+78-0 1 61< 78-0,<Y1-2 ; : K 1 -,H +7 *1 : L L ,-71+ 2 ,-1 1/ 0,1,-KL G-*101 < 78-0 1 +K6 5?1 " !//?1 /,+ 2-G1 / 51 1 . H 51, ; -0 71 -0,K1 /,: H K?1 6 <, 2-51 / + < :<?1 0,:; <,= ,-71 , -!=6 *1 1 0> , 1 +7 0 >G1 8 5?1 6 5; >51 1 /,+ 2-51 /+K + :<(1 D< ,1 01 !-+,0 *G1 1 ," ; 2 ,",1/ 0,<10-0+-*1: ,=6 K-*1/,+ 2-1., <>10,; =6 :< 1 1 !+7 1 + 2 ,-?1 / 0+ 1 : , 1 0> ,=6-*1 01 ; = <1+ 2 ,510+-?1016-/, KY1

;12 , 1 :6 + 1, L-0 ,51S01 ,<12-+ 1/ 5 ,5T?1 ",-!6-0 ,; 6<-0 ,51 1 / , :0,6-0 ,;G,:*5-; 0 ,516 * +7 ,-(1F-!-0 1-!H , +7 ,",1 1.! H ,; +7 ,",1 :" 2 *1 /! + 2 ,;0+->G1 /,+ ,<,2 51 < =6!1 ",-!6-0 >< 1 , " < 1 / /*-0! 1 ,/ 0 ,-?1 H ,; +7 ,-1 1M..0 ,-1 + : H 10-G1.! H 51",-!6-; 0 ?1-0 6 +7-0! 1, 1 ",16-/, 2 ,-Y1

;1 -0, ,6 1 6 * +7 ,-1 6 0 6,01 1 G1 , P 6 51 /,1 / H /!1191I3-3 4 516 B1% 51 1-&3 9 5JY1

;1/ *<, 1K 6 2-, 16 5-0 1 ,-!H , >G1 , <(18, ; -!H *1-+!= 153 35 1!-1-,:6 *1 1-,0 8-0,0 *1 / 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1 13 310> , 1-6-01 1< ,6,01M ,",1 / ,H--?1" 15 561 16 . ,0101, " : H 1 16 * +7 ,-1-! ,01",-!6-0 1 1 G16,+= ,->G1+ HY1 535 1: , ,/,-+!8 ,",1/,0 6 *1 1 :0 *1/ 0,0,51 !+7; ! >1" =6 ?12 ,0 ,0?16,+= ,->G1+ H1+K ,",1! ,0 *?1, L ; -0 1 01 H +,<Y1 5351 -,, 0-0 *1 ,-!H , ,; / 0,0,<!1 6 +!1 +7 ,516 5-0 +7 ,- %Y1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 ,1< K1< ," G1/ 0,0 6,0?1-+ 6! 1!2 >0 71-1: /+ *101 ,--5-,<1F-; ,0 ,<1U , 1H ,-51: +,",16 <, 2-,",1 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 (1F 1-,-,; 1 010,: ,0 1*0 ,1: 0>8 >G?1/,M ,<!1/,+ ,-7K11,-!L-0 <>G1I:6-711 -52-J1 ,= 6 5(1 I !6,0+ 0, ,-7?1 0>:>0 < *1 , < 2 0>< 1 1 /, ,<!1 ,-!; L-0 <>< 1 6 =6 < ?191 *= +>51 7 1 1/! 1/ 0 +7 ,",10,-/ * *18,-!; H 13 (1 *1 !6,0+ 0, ,-71/ /*-0! 1 -/- -,51,H 11 -, 2 ; -,",1: 2 *?1< 8 1, P 0 ,51G-1 -+7 >G1 1!*:0 <>G1 1 -, , J(1 S7<(11( D 78(17,0 < *1 ,--5-*1",-!6-0 ,-71 1 !+7 ! 16 <, 1331 E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$$E(1Q1%(17(1%$(T1

1

"

191 /,60 6,<-0 ,-71 -!6!1 +K ,",1 -/, 1 ,1 / 0 ?1 < =6!1 <1 >1, 1 10,: +1 1/ 0,0, 1 0-0,10-G1-, , 1-/, 191 1 ,+7 ,1 < =6!1 ,0 ,/ , :0,6 +*< ?1 0-!/ 08 < 1 < =6!1 -, ,51016,",0, > 1, ,8 *?1 ,1 1< =6!1",-!6-0,<1 1. : ; 2-< 1 1K 6 2-< 1+ H < 1S-(1%F1E =6-,",1 ,6-101 2-0 1/, / 08 G?1 , , > 1 < K 1/ 0,1 10,:< L 10 ; 6 ?1 :>0 1 1" =6 ?1 1 1K 6 2-G1+ HY101 2-0 1/ ; 2 + 510 6 191 1 ,+7 ,1, " >1",-!6-0 ,510+-1 1 G1 6,+= ,->G1 + H?1 ,1 1 +K > 1 ",-!6-0 > 1 , " >?1 , " >1 <-,",1-<,!/ 0+ *1 1 G16,+= ,->G1+ HTY1

;1 1 ,+7 ,1/,62 1< 78-0 1 ,+78-0!?1 ,1 1" ; 1: L >1: , >G1-,01< 78-0 (1

3 :!<-*?1 / < 1 6 5-0 +7 ,1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 <,= 1 > 71/ 2-+ ,1", :6,1 ,+78 Y1-1/,+ ><1,-,0 <1 1 <1, ,-*-*1 ?1 11/ H /1 / ,-,0 ,-16 /! ?1 -!61/-*= >G?1 : 0-<,-71-!6 51 1 (6(Y10>6 +*K-*1 1 :>; 0 <> 1 I G J1 / 6/,->+ 1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 ?1/, !=6 K; L 1 : , ,6 +*1 1 / 0, 0, 2-0!?1 1 6,/!-KL 1 ! ,/ 2 ; -,",1 !0+ 2 *1 / ,. + ,51 /-!/+ 5?1 0 6!L 1 1 , ; 0 <,-1/,-+ 6-0 51 / 0,< >G16 5-0 5%(1 1+K ,<1-+!; 2 1 !",+7 >51 < 71 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 91 . 5

1 1 &5 % 1 3 1 -9 "1 % 5 +1 65 ,1

&3 61& 3 1 .5 1 +!5 51&35-65 811

A+*1 -,G *1 2!0-0 1 +7 ,-1 -+ 6! 1 /,< 7?1 2 ,1 , H /H *1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 0> = 1 -, ,51 -,H +7 ,; / 0,0,51 6 +?1 -:1/ 6-0+ 51,10,:<,= ,<1 1= + <,<1 !-,5-0 1/! + 2 ,;/,+ 2-,510+-(1 1< ,0,51-, 1 1 >+,1 1,6 ,",1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 ?1/,+ ,-7K1-,0/ 6 KL ",1 -1 ",1-G,6 ><1: <>-+,<1 1/ 6 : 2 <(11

C-,?1 , , , 1: < K 1/ 0 12 +,0 101 !+7 ! 1, L-; 0 10,, L 1 101/,+ 2-,51 !+7 ! 1012-,-?10,1< ,",<1,/; 6 +*-*1G ,<1/,+ 2-,",1 = < ?1! ,0 <1 -,H +7; ,;M , ,< 2-,",1 :0 *1->?1: , ,6 +7-0,<1 1-, ; 2-< 1 6 H *< ?1,-, ,-*< 1/ 0,0,",1< + 1" ; =6 1 1 (/(1 1+K ,<1/,+ 2-,<1!-,5-0 1",-!6-0 1/ ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 ,6 , 1-<(11C35 %3 )7(1F1/, * 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1331F L-0 > 1 !; (1%EE$(1Q1#(1

0 1 1-0, ,6>1" =6 1/ 6-0+*K 1-, ,510 = 58 51/,+ ,; K 6 2-51 1 -,H +7 >51 -! ?1 , P 0 ,1 0>-!/ KL 51 < +,<1 6,-= 51 6 ,",1 , L-0 ?1 ",1 I0 : ,51 ,2; ,5J?1/, : + <1H 0 + :,0 ,-(1O , 1/, : +71->0 1 +7 !K1 6,-!/ ,-71 6+*1 + 2 ,-1 6!G,0 >G1 1 < +7 >G1 + "?1 < G :<,01 ,6,0+-*?1 0,+ :P*0+ *Y1 01 ,1= 10 <*1 M ,1 91 / < , 1 !-+,0 1 -,0 8-0,0 *1 -<,",1 2 +,0 ?1 !/ ,2 *1 ",12-1 16,-,-0 ?1 : 0-<,-?10,:<,= ,-51 /,+ ,H ,",1-,H +7 ,",1 16!G,0 ,",1 :0 *(11

11 M ,<1 <>1 0/+, !K1 /,6G,6 <1 1 / , + < 1 !-+,0 51 1 / 6/,->+, 1 -,0+ *1 1 :0 *1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 91 " =6-,<1, L-0 1 1/-!L 51 <!1M , ,< 2-,51 : 0-; <,-1+ 2 ,-1, 1 // 1/! + 2 ,510+-(1E,0, 71,1" =; 6-,<1, L-0 1<,= ,1+ 871 ,"6 ?1 ,"6 1, ,1-,-, 1 :1 : ; 0-<>G1 1-<,-,* +7 >G1" =6 ?1-,: KL G1- *1 ,0>< Y1 01-0,K1,2 67?1 < ,1/ 0,0, 1",-!6-0,1" ! 1 + ; : H K12 +,0 !1 ",1,-,0 >G1/ 01 1-0, ,6(1B-+ 1--< 0 71 / 0 1 1-0, ,6>1" =6 101 ,-10: <,6 5-0 *1+ 2 ,-1 1 ",-!6-0 ?1 ,1, 1/ 6 : 2 >1 -+!= 71/ 6 +,<1,-!L-0; + *1",-!6-0 ,510+-(1

1 -0*: 1 -1 M <1 ,-,0 <-*1 1 /, : +7 ,<1 I 6, :!< ; J?1 : .-,0 ,<1 (7(1- -* H <1 01 ",1 .! 6 < +7 ,<1 !6 11IF2 0 6 ,?12 ,1-, 2-1-+,= 08 5-*1 < 1h3 5 15!9 65F1*0 ,1 1-,, 0-0! 1 ,<!?12 ,1 <1, ,: 2-*(1 671 -,, L-0,<1 " =6 1 *0+*-*1 1 " =6-, 1 , L-0,?1 ?1 / , 0?1",-!6-0,(1 1-. 1= 1" =6-,",1, L-0 1910,/ ; 1 < ,0 K191<>1 < <16 +,1 1 :1 1-1" =6 ,<1S 1-1 /,+ 2-,51. "! ,5?1 1-1-! P ,<1/! + 2 ,;0+->G1, ,8 ; 51 1/! + 2 ,",1/ 0 T?1 1-12-><?1 /,+ 2-<1 1 /! + 2; ><?12 +,0 ,<191 ,-+ <12->G1-,0?1-! P ,<12-,",1 / 0 ?1!2-,<1" =6-,;/ 0,0>G1, ,8 5J%(1

A 5-0 +7 ,?1 01 !: ,;K 6 2-,<1 /, < 1 < 1 I" =6 J1,: 2 1K 6 2-!K1-0*:71 6 0 6 1S+ 2 ,-T1-1 ",-!6-0,<(1 1M ,<1-+!2 1 6,!< 1, P*-<,(1 ,1 ,"6 1<>1 : 6 <-*1 0,/ ,-,<1 ,1 / ,-G,=6 1 -+,0 1 I" =6 J1 01 !-; -,<1 *:> ?1 ,1 6,-,2 ,1 >-,1 0>*-*-*?1 6 = 1 /,1 -<,<!1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 3 939 5#7'12 :(1-,2(17(%%$(1

1

""

1 1

:0!2 K?12 ,1, ,1/ , :0,6 ,1, 1I", ,6 J1S" 6 T?1/ 0, 2 +7 ,1 < 1 /,+ 2-; 5 +7 , 1 -,6 = 1 1 , ,: 2 1", ,6; -G1= + 5(1 ,:6 ?1/,1< 1: ,<-0 1 ,--5-,51/! + 1-1 -,2 *< 1 + +7 >G1 0 ,/ 5-G1 . +,-,.,01 1 M , ,< ; -,0?1, < 2 1A( (1 <,. 0?1" =6 1 2 10>-!/ 71 1 -! P 1 / 0 ?1 , , >51 < +1 1 ,+7 ,1,/ 6 + > 1, *: ,; -?1 ,1 1 1< 12 ,1-., <!+ ,0 > 1/ 0 (1 ,6, , 1: ; <-0,0 1-0, <1-,2 ,<10/,+ 1: , ,< ,1 < +,1, L ; -0 ,;/,+ 2-!K1/ !1-,0*L ",-*1! 3 -5 51, ; L-0 101U / 6 ,51B0 ,/ (1 ,?1 1 :0-,?1 ! =! 101/ 0,6 1-1

. H!:-,",1 *:> 1 ,: 2 1 0-1 ,",1 = 1 ", ,= ?1 -+ 6,0 ; +7 ,?1/,1/ *<,<!1-<>-+!?1 1-< !1. ,6 +7 ,<!1 -,+K :<!1 / G,6 1 < ,1I", ,6-, J1, L-0,(1 /,-+ 6-0 101 !--,<1 *:> 1<>1-,+ <-*1-1 ,/+ <1 " 0 >G1 , , H 51-+,; 0 1 I ! =! J1 1 0-G1 , 1 ",1 / , :0,6 >G1 91 !1 4(1 +, 1 01 /,M< 1 IA0 6H 7J?1!1 (1C * ,0-,",1SI6 71 0,51/,-+ 6 51/ G,6 ?1

/ ,1 ,?12 ,1/ G,6 71 1 , !1010>"+ = ,51 ! 8 191I ! ; =! : ,J?1 1 (/(1-1= 1-! 1/ ,-, 1 1/ 0, 2 +7 , 1, ; -,* +7-0,19101-6 0 ,0,51. ,6 +7 ,51B0 ,/ 1 > ,0 + 1/,; ",0, 11I8 =6>5?1 ,1-6 + +1"+, , 1", ,6-,",10,:6!G ?1-,; 0-*1 -0, ,6 ><J?1 , , ,51 -,, 0-0,0 +,1 , >2 , 1 / 0,?1 /,1 , , ,<!1 -7* ?1 ! = 08 51 01 ", ,61 , 1 -0, ",1 . ,6 + 1 1 / ,= 08 5101 <1",61 1,6 16 7?1-,0 +-*1+ 2 ,1-0, ,6 ><(1

A !" < 1 -+,0 < ?1/ 0 2 >51 -<>-+1 ! =! : ,",1, L-0 1 1, L-0 1", ,6-,",1-0*: 1-1+ 2 ,51-0, ,6,512 +,0 \1

8 1 1 0-* , 1 /, * ?1 " =6-, 1 , L-0,1 !=6-*1 01

., < +7 ,;+," 2-,<1,/ 6 + (17!L-0!KL 101-,0 < ; ,51+ ! 1 ,2 1: *1. +,-,.,0?1/ 0,0 6,01 1/,+ ,+,; ",0101H +,<1-G,6*-*1 10>6 + 1," 2 ,",12-+ 1/ : ; ,01" =6-,",1, L-0 Y1 -16 !",51 -, , >?1<>1-+ 0 <-*1 -, 1-1,/-<?1/ 2-+ <?12 <1 , H / ! + : H 5(1 ?1 /,1 < K1 4(4(1 A< 0 ?1 " =6-, 1 , L-0,1 0 +K2 1 01 - *1 6, ,0,+7 ,1 -., < ,0 08-*1 / 0 2 > 1 -<,!/ 0+*K; L-*1, L ,-1+K6 51S-<7*?1 , /, H *?1, L-0 *1, " ;

: H *?1 0, 2-51 -,K:?1 , .--, +7 , 1 , P 6 1 1 (/(TY1 / , :0,6-0 !K1 1 2-!K1 = : 71 +K6 5Y1 -. !1 -<,!/ 0+ ; *1-0, ,6 >G1 6 0 6,01 1 G1, " : H 5%(14 +," 2 ,1 1, ; + 2-*1 +," 2-,51 -,",-7K1 /,6G,61 /,+ ,+,",0?1 ,/ 6 ; +*KL G1" =6-, 1, L-0,1 1-. !1 /,+ 2-,",1 > *1 2 +,0 2-0 ?10 +K2 KL ",1 1., <>1= : 6 * +7 ,-?1 1 !61 1-, -0 ,-7?1-<7K?1+K ,07?1!6,0+ 0, 1/ 0 2 >G1 /, ,-5?1G, 1 1 (6(11

7,H , !+7 ! , 1 :< 1" =6-,<!1, L-0!1/ 6 ; 14(7(14G : ?1-0*:>0 *1 ",1 :0 !K1., <!1-1+ +7 ,51H ; 0 + : H 5?1-!L-0!KL 51 1,-,0 1", ,6-,51= : ?1 -; ,",1 <>8+ *?1 ,0 ,;6 = >G1 , ,8 51 1 > ?1 ,-,: ; *1H ,-51+ 2 ,-?1+ 2 ,51 H 0>1 12-,51-, -0 ; ,-(17/ 0 6+ 0,1, < 2-*?12 ,1" =6-, 1, L-0,191M ,?1 / =6 10-",?1 ,-1+ 2 ,51, 0-0 ,-1: 1, L-0,?1-/,-, ; ,-71 ., < ,0 71 1 /,66 = 0 71 -/ H +7 > 1 -! >?1 , ; " : H ?1--,H H ?1 / 0+ > 1 1: L !1 1 :< 1, ; L-0 101H +,<#(1A !" < 1-+,0 < ?1 1<,= 1 > 71" =6-,",1 , L-0 1 :1 " =6 1 91 2 +,0 1 -1 !-,52 0>< 1 0-0 ; >< 1 2-0 < ?1, + 6 KL ",12!0-0,<1 -, -0 ,",16,-, ; -0 ?1 : 0-<,-?1 !0 = <1 / 01 1 -0, ,61 6 !" G1 " =6 ?1 : , ,/,-+!8 ,-7K?1-,+ 6 ,-7K?1-,0-7K1 1/, *6,2 ,-7K(1 E =6-, 1, L-0,1 <1= :-/,-, ?12 <101 ,+78 51-/ ; 1 ",12+ >1, + 6 K 10>-, <1! ,0 <1-,H +7 ,",1 12 +,0 2 ; -,",1 / + ?1 -+ 6,0 +7 ,?1 -/,-, >1 1 -<,-,* +7 ><1 1 H 0 ><16 5-0 *<?1/ 2 <1 1 ,+7 ,16+*16,-= *1-, ; -0 >G1H + 5?1 ,1 10,1 <*1, L-,H +7 >G1H ,-511I< +,5J1 1 I ,+78,5J1 3,6 >?1 6 <, ?1 -0, ,6>1 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-1 1 (/(1E =6 191M ,12 +,0 ?1, + 6 KL 51" =6-<1<!=-; 0,<?1 ,1 -71 ", ,0>51 8 +7 ,1 ,-0 71 -0, 1 " =6-, 1 6,-,-0,?1 , , 7-*1: 1-0, 1" =6-1/ 0 1 1H ,-1, ; > ,",1, L-0 (1

1U-+!= 0 10 < *1/,: H *18(7(1E 6= 0 ?1-,"+-,1 ,; , ,51I" =6-, 1, L-0,191M ,1- -< 1, -/ 2 *1= : ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11,DA A3F7/17,, ,8 1/, * 51/,+ 2-,51 1",-!6-0 ,510+-101!-; +,0 *G1., < ,0 *1" =6-,",1, L-0 1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1%EE@(1Q1'(17(R$(1

#17<(11.A373 713,--*11 1-, 2-,",1,/> (1C(?1%EE$(1 (1R(17(1F#(1

1

#$