Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

1 1

2-51., !-?1/,-,+7 !1012-0 1,-,0>1-,G *+-71,< 6; ,; 6<-0 *1- -< (1A ?16 5-0 +7 ,?1-<1. 1-!L ; -0,0 *1",-!6-0 10> = 1-,H +7 , 1 0-0,?1-!L-; 0!KL 101, L-0 Y1, ,1-,G *-*1 101 G1-G?1 , , > 1/ ; 6!K 1 1/ : K-*101 -!-16 <, 2-G(1 ,+ 1 ,",?101 M/,G!1"+, + : H 1, < 2-*1 6 H *1 1!"+! + K1-,H +7; ,51/,+* : H ?1< /!+ ,0 K1<--,0><1-,: <101!",6!1 0+-71 1-, -0 ,-71 <!L <(1

,1 1-, 1: >0 71 1/ ,1 ,?12 ,1/ 1+K ,<1/,6G,6 1 1",; -!6-0!1, ,1/ 6-1 ,51-0, 51-!L ,-,51-, , ,5191 1 < G :<1!/ 0+ *1, L-0 >< 1, ,8 *< 1/ 1/,<,L 1 0+-(1

1B-+ 1, L-0,1 1/ 0 L ,101 : <!?1 ,1",-!6-0,1-,; -, 1 :1 : ,, : >G1 /,+ 2-G1 -! ! ?1 ,/ 6 + ,51 - -<>1 , " ,01 0+-1 1 !/ 0+ *?1 -6-01 /,66 = *1 , ; L-0 ,",1 /, *6 (1 ! + 2 ,;/ 0,0,51 G 1 -! ,01 ",-!6-0 ?1 / 0+ >51 1+ " +7 , 1 : 8 1 , .+ ,01 01, L-0 ?1 1/,1-K1/, !1 1-= 10 = ,-710,/ ,-11 ,1/ ; 0 101, L-0 V1 ,1-, *1H 0 + : H 1! 6 +7 ,1-0 6 +7; -0! 191 :0 1",-!6-0 1/,1/! 16 <, : H 1 1-0, ,6>1 -0*: ,1-1-,0 8-0,0 <1< G :< 1!/ 0+ *?1/ ,-,<1 H 1-1/ , + <>13 51&3 6 *1 10,/ ,-13% 51&3 6 *(1B6 ; -0,1, L !+7 ! ,",1 1/ 0,0,",1/ ,"--1-,-, 101/ G,6 1 , 1 : / +7 ,;6,:0,+ +7 >G1 , <1 1 -8 K1 6,:0,+ ; +7 ,",1 "!+ ,0 *16 * +7 ,-1" =6 1 1 G1, P 6 5(1 1/ 0>51/+ 10>60 "-*1: L 1-! P 0 >G1/ 01 1/ 0,; 0,",1-!-1+ 2 ,-?10-1 ,+ 1=-, 1," 2 10+-?1-,; 0 8-0,0 1- -<>1/ 0,0>G1-6-01!/ 0+ *(11

7,0 < > 1 !-+,0 *1 !K 1 8 +7 ,",1 , : 1 , 1 /,; < *1/ 0 15 511< G :< 1 +--,0,",1/ , 0, ,-0 ?1 / : *1: 1/ 0,<1.! H 51-,H +7 ,",1 ,</ ,<--(1

8 1 "!< >1<,"! 1 > 71/ 0 6 >101/,+7:!1M ,",1! ; 0 =6 *V1

3 :0 1 , L-0 1 01 -,0 < >G1H 0 + :,0 >G1 -G1 6 1/,1/! 10-1 ,+78 ",1!-+,= *1 16 ..H H (1C,=; ,1-,+7 ,1!",6 ,1-/, 71, 1,-,0 *G1-,H +7 ,51-. ; H 1S*0+*K-*1+ 1,-,0 > 1-,H +7 > 1" !//>1 +--< 1 + 1 G1

6,1 :>0 71 /,;6 !",<!?1 /,1 <1 *<1 1 -,+7 ,1 6,1 0>6 +* 71M+ < ,01-,H +7 ,51-! ! >T?1 ,1"+ 0 , 1016 !",<(1 D1 78 1-0 6 1, L-0 1 1/ , 0,-,* K1-, -0 ,01 1-, -0 ,0?1 , ,01 < ,",1 !6 ?1 -2 +,-71 6,-; ,2 ,1" ! ><1 1!-+,0 ><(17 ",6 *1 : ,1!0 + 2 +,-712-+,1-; <,-,* +7 ,16 5-0!KL G1" !//1+K6 5?1 G1-,K:,0?1--,H H 51 1 (/(?1 ,++ 0 >G1-,01-,0-*1 ,+78 ?1, 1!-+,= *K ; -*1 1 : ,, :*-*(1 O , ,< 2-?1 H , +7 > ?1 " , +7; > ?1/,+ 2-1 16 !" 1 :+ 2 *1< =6!1 !6,<1 1 / +,<1 -= K-*1: 1-2 1 :0 *1-1-,H +7 ,",1, -/ 2 *?1 ,-1 !+7 ! ,",1 1 , :,0 +7 ,",1 ! ,0 *1 -+ *?1 /,0>8 *1 ! ,0 *1< +7 ,",1/, + *1 1 2-0 1= : (1 !6 ,1-; ",6 *1!0 6 71 <!L ",1/ ,+ *101 , KL G1 1-+!= L G1 /,1 5<!?1 < KL G1 -, -0 > 16,< 1 1: < +7 > 1!2-?1 ; H ?1 -G,0> 1 /,+->?1 0 ,<, + ?1 6,< 8 KK1 M+ , !1 1 < ,", 16 !", (1

2-+,= 1, L-0 ,51= : 10>60 " 1 1/ 0>51/+ 1 /,-1, L-0 ,",1-,"+-*(17,/,-0+ <1 :+ 2 >G1 ;-,01 10> , ,51 ,</ ,<-->G1 8 51/ ,6,+ 0-*1-; , / , 1/ 6-0+ 1,16 <, 1 16,< ,0 1/,: ; H 51 10,+ 1 ,+78-0 (17+ 6!KL 518 "1: +K2-*101!< 1 !2 >0 71 ->1 < 78-01 S 1 G?1 /,62 <?1 -,0-*1 0-1 ,+78 T?1 16,/!-71 G1/,6 0+ *?10 6!L ",1 16- + ; : H 1, L-0 ?1: L L 71, 1/ , :0,+ 1/ 0 1 =6,",12 +,0 1 : 0-<,1, 1 ",1/ ,-G,=6 *1 1/,+,= (1

-1M ,1, P 0 ,1!0 + 2 0 1 ,+71 1H ,-71!/ 0+ *1 -+,= ,, " :,0 >< 1/ ,H--< ?101< G :< G1!/ 0+ *191 : 2 1",-!6-0 1 1/ 0 1 1"+ 0 58 G1 "!+* , ,0(1 1!-; +,0 *G1 -,0 < ,",1 !2 ,; G 2-,",1 / ,"--?1 ; H , + : H 1 1 "+, + : H 1 < ,0,",1 -, 2-,",1 / ,H--1 "!+ !KL *1 ,+71",-!6-0 1*0+*-*1 , P <+ <><1M+ < ; ,<1 +K ,51 -! ! >1 , L-0 ,",1 / , :0,6-0 (1 , 1 ! , < G1,-+ 51/ , :0,6-0 ?1/ , + < 1-,2 ,01-> 7*1 1 M " ?1 -,. 2-1 , ,-08 *-*1 M ,+," 2-*1 / , + ; < ?1 0, > 1 , .+ >1 -,* +7 ,1 6 !K 1 , G,6 <,-71 , L H , +7 ,",1 1 < = H , +7 ,",1 91 ",-!6-0 ,",1 91 "!+ ,0 *1M , ,< 2-<1 1-,H +7 ><1 :0 <(1 ,+ 1 ,;

1

"

1 1

",?1 /,-+ 6 1 ",6>1 6 <,-!K 1 <1 / H / +7 ,1 ,0> 1 0,:<,= ,-1 01 8 1 -+,= 58 G1 0,/ ,-,01 < ,0,",1 > *1 F " : H 51 F P 6 >G1 H 5?1 ,/ KL 5-*1 1 < =6! ; ,6 , 1 / 0,(1 7+,0,<?1 ,+71 / 0 1 1 -6-0 1 / 6, 0 L *1 , .+ ,010,10 ! G1 1< =6! ,6 >G16 + G10,:-1 !; 0 +7 ,1 -1 =6><16 <?1< "-+7 *1+ *1 :0 *1< ,0,51 H 0 + : H 1S/ 10-G1 1/ , 0, 2 *G1 1/,/* >G160 = *GT1 -0 6 +7-0! 1,1 6 H *G1/ 0 L *1/ 0 1 1/ 0,0,",1",; -!6-0 101,-,0 , 1-6-0,1 1 51-,H +7 ,",1/ ,"--(1

<1 -<><1 / 0,1 8 1 -,H , !+7 ! !K1 : 6 2!1

. B1 ( (1 " H 1, L-0 101, " :,0 , 1H +, 101 6-0 1 ",1/ , 0, 2 0>G1-, , 1 1/,-,* ,1 :< *KL G-*1!-+,0 5(1 0,10> >0 1 1 :>0 <!K13 +1 3 1/1/ ,; - -0,1-,H , , < 0 ,51 "!+*H ?101 , , ,<1, L ,-71H ; ,-51/ >0 1 :+ 2 *101 6 + G1 : >G1-,H +7 >G1" !//1 S-! !+7 ! T?1-,-0+*KL G1, L-0,(1

7,:6 1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 /,1 -!L-0!1 *0+*-*1 :65 +. 5 5 1 ., <,5?1 / 6/,+ " KL 51 /,-/ >51 / G,61 , 1 / *<,",1!/ 0+ *1 10< 8 +7-0!?1, 10< 8 +7-0 191 1-; <!+ ,0 K?1/,1< 1 ,-1 !+7 ! >1, L-0 ?1! ,0 *1<--,0,51 ,-,: ,-1: 6 2?1-,*L G1/ 61, L-0,<?1 1+ 2 ,51, 0-; 0 ,-1" =6 1: 1 G1 8 (1

, 1/ 0 1 61",-!6-0,<1 1, L-0,<1: , ,< 1 1 , ,-,0 1-, 2-?1/ 0,1/, ,=6-*1M , ,< 2-< 1 1-,H ; +7 >< 1 , ,8 *< 1 1 ! 1 , " :,0 ,51 / !6 +7 ,51 : L >1 -,1 -, , >1 ",-!6-0 ?1 /,-+ 6 1 ,. H +7 ,1 0> = 1 / 0,101: , ,6 +7-0 1 1,G * 1 ",1/,-6-0,<1-!6(11

81-,= + K?1 !+7 ! 10+-1 ,--5-,51M+ >1 6 H , ; ,10,-/ , :0,6 1, H K1 1/ <!L-0 , 1-/,+7:,0 ; 1/,+ 2-G1-6-01!/ 0+ *?1 :, ,-+7 ,1 1-/ 1 G1+ " +7 ,-(1 ,M ,<!1/ 0,10,, L 1 18,-!H *1012-,-1 01 +7 ,51/,+ 10,-/ <-*1 1., < +7 >51 1< +,-!; L-0 >51 . , 1 ," 2 *1 G1 6 * +7 ,-(1 , ,-/ ; , 1 : 2 1 H ,-51 / 0 1 01 -,: 1 /,+ ,; 6< ; -0 ,51 M+ >1 0-G1 ! ,0 51 : , ,< ,1 / 0 L 1 1 8, ; -!H K1 01 1 ,+ 1 2 <1 / 6< 1 0!:,0-,",1 / /,6 0 *1 + 1 H ,0 *1/,1,. H +7 ,; , =-0 ><1/,0,6 <(1

1 -,*L 1 0 <*1 ,6 ,51 :1 0 = 58 G1 : 6 21 ! /+ *1 ,-,01/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 101 ,--5-,<1, L-0 ?1/ 6 *1 <1 6 5-0 +7 ,",?1 1 1< <,",1G 1*0+*-*1 :0 1 ,; 1 1 / 1 ,-!H , ,",1 , ,+*(1 8,-!H , >51 , ,+71 ,-,0>0-*1 1 , P 0 ,<1 / 0 1 01 ., < +7 ,<1 -<>-+ 1 91 1 / 0,!-,0+ *G?1 , = >G1 01 ,. H +7 >G1 , < 0 >G1 G1 ?1 / =6 1 0-",?1 01 ,-!H 1 ",-!6-0 (1 ,1 < K1 7(4(140 7* ?1 ,-!H , >51 , ,+71 I<,= ,1 ,G :,0 71 1-/ H +7 >510 61",-!6-0 ,516 * +7; ,-?1 / 0+ ,51 1 , -/ 2 1 / 0 +7 ,",1 / < *1 ,-!H 1 1, !-+,0+ >G1 K1: , ,0?1 1: L !1: /+ ; >G101 G1,-,01 ,-!H , ,",1-,*1",-!6-0 J%(1F-,0 *1 6 *?1: +,= *101-,:6 1, " 1 ,-!H , ,",1/ 0,-!6 *1 S, 1<,= 1 :>0 7-*1 1!",6 ,191 ,-!H , ><1-!6,<?1 ; ! +,<?1-,0 ,<1 1 (/(T?191.! H 1 101-/, 1< =6!1 :; >< 1 0 0*< 1 0+-?1 , ,+71 : 1 /,62 <1 < 1 = 1 -,:6 ; >< 1 : , < ?1 6,/!L 1 6<-0 ,",1 / , :0,+ 1 1 , !:6 1 K , (1 = ,1/,62 ! 7?12 ,16 +,1 16,+= ,1 -0,6 7-*1 ,+7 ,1 + 871 1 , <, , ,+K?1 ,1 1 0 +K2 71 01 6 *; +7 ,-71 , " 1 ,-!H , ,",1 , ,+*1 ,H !1 / 0,/ ; < +7 ,51 / ?1 ,01 S: , ,0?1 /,-,0+ 51 -/,+ ; +7 >G1, " ,0T1/,1, L K1-!6,0?1" =6 ?1+ ,16 = 16 5-; 0 51 , >G1, " ,01!/ 0+ *?101 , , >G1" =6 1!-< ; 0 K 1 !8 1 -0, G1 ,-!H , >G1 / 0(1 1 /,+ ,<,2 *1 ,-!H , ,",1-!6 16,+= >10G,6 711--<, 1-/, ,01",; -!6-0 >G1 , " ,01 , 1 , P < 1 / 01 1 , *: ,-5?1 -/, ,01 < =6!1. 6 +7 ,510+-7K1 1 1-! P < Y1,/ ,-,0 1: ; , ,-10> , ,01 101, L 1/ 6-0 +7 > 1!2 =6 *?1 1 1 01 / 6-0 +7 > 1 , " >1 ",-!6-0 >G1 , " : H 5?1 -/, >1,1 -,, 0-0 1< =6! ,6 ,",1 10 ! ",1/ 0 ?1, ; 0 1 6,+= ,->G1 + H1 1 (/(1 3 :!<-*?1 M ,51 ,</ H 1 6,+= 1 -,, 0-0,0 71 < G :<1 -/ H +7 ,51 ,-!H , ,; / 0,0,51 , 0-0 ,-1 0 ,0 >G1 01 -/,+ 1 8 51 ,-!H , ,",1 -!6 1 S / < ?1 ,-0, ,=6 1 , 1 6,+= ,-1 0>-8 G16,+= ,->G1+ H?1/ ., < ,0 1-,-0 1",-!6-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11F C) 571 , + <>1 , 1 1/ 1 ,-!H , ,",1 , ,+*1 1/ 0,; -!6 *1331-1C,-(! ; (17 *1%%(1 0,(1%EE)(1Q1@(1

1

"

0 >G1 , " ,0?1!<>8+ ,1 -/,+ *KL G18 *1,-!; H , ,",1-!6 T?1-+ 6,0 +7 ,?1/ 0,1 10,: !=6 1-/ H +7 ,; ",1-/,+ +7 ,",1/ , :0,6-0 (1

0,1 1 /,61/ , :0,+ 1 1 1 7 1 1 ",1/! 191 ; ,0 1 K 6 2-*1 -!L ,-71 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 (1 1 / 0,0,<1 ",-!6-0 1," 2 0 K-*1I ,< 6>J1",-!6-0 ?1 1: , ,6 ; +7 >51 / ,H--1 ,-,0 1 1 :6 0,<1 -<>-+ ?1 -/ 0 6+ 0,-1 1 -+,= 08 G-*101" =6-,<1, L-0 1 -,H +7 ,1/,+ : >G1/ ; 0,/ *: *G(1

,60,6*1 , , > 1 ," ?10,;/ 0>G?1-,"+-<-*1-1!6 2 ><1 ,/ 6 + <1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1 (7(1- -* H <1 1 &3

6565 1 $53 "1 53-. 1 1 5 1 & ! % 5 &5 % 5 16 1 1 16-55 54 1 1 6 1 1

!8 1&3 6 B1 5 1&3 61 1 65!5 1% 56 1 1 3%(1 ,;0 , >G?1<,= ,1 ,1-., <!+ ,0 71-+ 6!KL 1 ,-,0 > 1 / : 1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 ?1 ->0 KL 1 ",1

-!L ,-711

;1/ 0-0,1" =6-,",1, L-0 1 61",-!6-0,<?1/,6; 2 ,-71",-!6-0 1 , ,+K1: +,",1 1 0 , ,",1-,, ; L-0 1 ",-!6-0 >G1 -,K:,0?1 , " : H 51 1 , P 6 5?1 + :!KL G1->1-0, G12+ ,0(1E =6-, 1, L-0,191 1 0 8 51 ,-16+*1",-!6-0 ?1 ,1 +7 , 1-,6 = ?1 , ,; , 1 ,/,-6!-*?1 !/, *6,2 0-*1 1 ,., <+*-*1 2 :1 "!+*; H K1 /,0 6 *1 +K6 51 01 - -< 1 0: <,6 5-0 *1 -,H +7 >G1 " !//1 1-! ,01/ 0,0>< 1 , < < ?1/ 0 + < 1 1/ H / ; < (1 :1 ,2 ,",10> = *1G 1 1-<>-+ 1, ,8 51" =; 6-,",1, L-0 ?1-/ 1 ",1: +,-?1 0,:<,= ,1!-/ 8 , 1 1 H + / 0+ , 1 "!+ ,0 1 ",1 :0 *Y1

;1/ , 1/ 0 1 61/,+ ,51 1: , ,<?10 G,0-0,1: ; , 1 61 6<-0 ><1 ,<1 1 6<-0 ><1 8 ; <(1 G,0-0,1 / 0 1 /,62 * 1 ",-!6-0,1 , L-0!?1 /,; -,+7 !101/,+ 2-G1, ,8 *G1, ,1,: 2 1 , P <+ <, 1 / 0,1 ,6 1 1-!0 ?1 ",1 , 2!=6 <, 1/ 0,1,/ 6 +* 71

., <!1 1-,6 = 1",-!6-0 ?1G 1",-!6-0 ,",1< ; G :< ?1 ,-!H , > 1 / H />1 , " : H 1 0+-?1 1 : ; 6 2 1 1/ 6 +>(1 1M ,<1-<>-+ 1/ < 1/ 0 1 1/,+ 2-*16 ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 3 939 5#7'(1 +,-,. *1/ 0 (1C(?1%EE'(17(%$F(1