Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

6 <><1 ! ,<1- -0 ,",1, L *1 :!< >G12 +,0 2-G1 6 0 6,0(1 ,12 , >1, ,1-+,1 +7 ,51-+,5?1/ 1 , G,6 <,; -1<,"+,1 > 71 + :,0 ,?1 1 !-*1-!L-0,0 1",-!6 ; -0 ?1 , , , 1/ 0 L 1- -0 , 1-,-,* 1, L-0 101/ ; 0,0, 1",-!6-0,(1

E+ 0 ><1 -/,-, ,<?1 <1 <,= ,1 6,-271 / 0,0,",1 ",-!; 6-0 ?1 *0+*-*?1 /,1 8 !?1 :6 + 1 0+-1 1: , ,6 +7; !K?1-/,+ +7 !K1 1-!6 !K?1/ 2 <1/ 0,51 :1 G1, 6-*1 / 6/,2 ?1 1 ?1-,:6 0 *1: , >?1, 10> = 1-!0 1 ,6 (1D-/,+ +7 *10+-71 :6 1-/, *= *1 16 5-0! 1 1,-,0 1M G1: , ,0?1-!6 *1= 1",0, 1,1 ,<?12 ,1-71/ 0,?1 2 :1 / 6-0 + 51 ,6 1 91 /-*= >G?1 8 *1 -!67 !1 , 0 ; * <,",1 + 1 *= !1-H (1F ,-,0>0 *1 , G,6 <,-71-!L-0,; 0 *1/ 6-0 +7 ,51-!6 ,510+-?1 ( (10> , 1/-*= >G?1 8 1-->+-*1 1 ,?12 ,1 ,"6 1 L 1, + 6 +710+-1 1, ; :>0 +-*1, 1-, + : 1 ,+ ,0 71: , >101-0,K1/,+7:!(1

7,10-< ,;-, 2-<1/ ,"--,<12 +,0 2-,51-0, ,; 6>1-0*:>0 1/ 0,0, 1",-!6-0,16 !",51" +7 >51 < H 51

. +,-,.1E(1E " +7?1-2 *1 , <>1/ 0 1< ,51-0, ,6>(1 ?1/ 0,1 2-,51-, -0 ,-1G :! 1 + : H K1-0, ,6>1+ 2 ,; -(1 , < +7 , ?1/ 0,0, 1 0-0,1+K6 51 < ,1 1-0, ,6; >G1 + 2 ,-51 : +K2-*1 01 G1 ,6 ,0,<1 / 0 1 1 2-!K1 -, -0 ,-71S ,1 101 :< 10+ 6 *1-, -0 ,-7KT(171M G1 /,: H 51 E " +71 ! 1 :+ 2 > 1 -,H +7 > 1 ! ,/ ?1 ; !KL 1, , L-0+ *1 <!L-0 1 1!-,0+ *1. 2-,",1 0-0 ?1 2 *1 -1 /+ , ,0-,",1 6 +7 ,",1 ",-!6-0 (1 ; , 1 /, < 1 -0, ,6>1 1 / 0 1 / 0+ ,1 / , 01 , 2!=6 *1 + 2 ,51 -0, ,6>?1 0-0 ,-?1 0 ,-/,0 6 *?1 ( (1 / , 01-0 1 1 /,-2-0 (1

3 :+ 2 *1" =6-, 1, L-0,1 1/,+ 2-, 1",-!6-0,?1 E " +716 1"+! , !K1 ,0 !1 G10: <,6 5-0 *?101 , , ,<10 ; 6!L *1 ,+71/ 6+ = 1/ 0,0,<!1",-!6-0!?12 ,12-,1 ; ,0 +,-71 1 /,+," 1., < +7 ,;K 6 2-G1,/ 6 + 51 1 / !--,51 <, G (1 1 M ,<1 , ->0 +-71 6 5-0 +7 *1

., <,, :!KL *1 ,+71",-!6-0 1 1/,+ 2-,51 1K 6 2 ; -,51, " : H 10-",1, L-0 (1 671" =6-, 1, L-0,?1/,1 E " +K?1/ 6-0+* 1-, ,51-. !1 + : H 12->G1-,01

1

!

1H + 51 : 0-<,5?1, 6 +7 ,51+ 2 ,-(1F ,1 1<,= 1 > 71 ; :0 ,1 , L-0,<1 /,6+ ,51 -0, ,6>?1 ( (1 -G *1 -,+ ,0 *1 2->G1 -,01 , != 0 1 , G,6 <,-71 , L ",1 2 + 1 + 8710 8 <1 1-+!2 5 ><1, :,<?12 :1 , 7 !1 1 ", :<1 +K6 5(1E " +71-,0 8 ,12 ,1.-! 1 ,->1 ,"-0 1 1 L-0 1 1 , P <+ <!K1-, , !1" =6-,",1, L-0 (1 ,1

.! H , ,0 1-, -0 ,-16,+= ,1 > 71 6 = ,1: L L ; ,1, 1/ !/ : ,0 ,512-1-+ *1: , ,<?1-!6,<1 1/,+ ; H 5(11

,:0>8 ,",1 ?1 1 810:"+*6?1-/ 0 6+ 0,",1/ .,-16,-; " 1E " +7?1,H 0 *1",-!6-0,1 10,/+,L 1 6 1 :!< ?1 -0, ,6>1 1/ 0 ?10>-!/ KL ",101 , ,<10 6 1 1/ 0,0, 1 ",-!6-0,(1E,-!6-0,1 1H +, 1 1/ 0 2 , 1/,1, ,8 K1 1 " =6-,<!1, L-0!191= 0,51, " :<?1 1 1< G 2-, 1-,; 6 1 ,< : ,0 >G1 6 0 6,0?1, " 2-51-:1-0,; ,6>1",-!6-0 ,;, " :,0 ,",1 ,6 1 1 6 0 6! +7 >G1 -0, ,61" =6 (1IE,-!6-0,?191/ 8 1E " +7?191M ,18-0 1 ," 1 01< Y1 ",1,-,0 <1-+!= 10+-71 :!< ?1,-!L-0+*KL ",1 - *1 10,+KJ%(1 <1, :,<?1/ 0,0, 1",-!6-0,10 6 1" ; =6-, 1, L-0,1 1 ,+ 1-+,= ,51, " : H 1-,, L-0 1+K; 6 51 91 /,+ 2-,5?1 I!-< *KL 5J1 ", :<>1 M",-2-G1-,0?1 1 <1-<><1, ,1-,6 5-0! 10,/+,L K1 0-0 ; ,",1 6 + 191, L ",1 + " 16+*10-G1" =6 (1

,62 <?12 ,1-<1 < 1I/ 0,0, 1",-!6-0,J?1/,+!; 2 08 518 , , 1/ < 1/,-+ 1/ : *1 !6,01 < H ,",1 ",-!6-0,0 6 13(1C,+*101R$;G1",6 G1NAN10 ?10> = +1!= 1 ; :!+7 >1< ,",0 ,0,",1 :0 *1/,+ 2-,51= : 1 1/ 0,0,51 <>-+ 1H 0 + :,0 >G1 -(1 2 + 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1! ; 0 =6 +-71 01 , 7 1 0 ,/ 5-G1 ,6,01 : 1 / 0 1 1 -0, ,6>1 + 2 ,-1/ , 01/ , :0,+ 1/ 0 +7-0 1 1/ *: 51",-!6 ; -0 ,510+-1-1NoA10(1 1,-, ,1/ , 010-, P <+KL 51 1/,; 6 0+*KL 51 ,/ 1 /,+ H 5-,; K , 2-,",1 ",-!6-0 1 NoAA1 1NoAAA10 ,0(1

1,-0 +-7101-, , 1, 1M G1/ ,H--,01 13,--*?10,/ 1 , *<?1, 2-0 ><1 1: ! = ><?1-,"+-,1 , , ><101 51 ; ,"6 1 1-!L-0,0 +,16 <, 2-G1 6 H 5(1BL 101/ ,8+,<1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%13%3 )7 7'1 +,-,. *1/ 0 (1C(?1%EE$(17(1##&(1

0 101/, ., < ,513,--1/,*0 +-71 101H +,<16,-,2 ,1 >; -,1 :0 0 +-711 < ,",/ 5 *1 /,+ 2-*1 - -< ?1 / ,.-,; K: , 160 = ?1,//,: H , *1/--?1: <-1!2 =6 *1 1-!6>1 /-*= >G(1 + 1-+!1 :+ 2 ,",1 ,6 1/ 6-0 +7 > 1!2; =6 *1 1, L-0 , 1< (17,-0 ,512-7K160 = *1 ,-; -5-,",1 , L-0 1 1 /,+ 2-,51 6 <, 1 *0+*+-71 !6>1 1 6 10 6 58 G1, 2-0 >G1/ 0,0 6,0(1F H +7 ,1, ,-*-71 1 -,+K :<!1H-,510+-?1, 1-< +-710-101",-!6-; 0 , 10+-0,0 1/ 0,0> 1/ H />(1

F-, , 1 0 < 1 6, 0,+KH , *1 /,+ ,;K 6 2-*1 <>-+71!6 +*+ 1/ , + < 10: <,, ,8 *1",-!6-0 1 1" =6 ; ?1-2 *10 = ><1/ H /,<1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1, -/ 2 ; 1/ 01 1-0, ,61+ 2 ,-(1E =6 101, ,8 1 1/,6: , ; ,51/ 0 +7-0 ,510+-?1/,1< K1 (C(1E--?10>-!/ ; 1-! P ,<1/ 01 1, *: ,-5?1 1 1, P ,<10+-?1/,66 ; ><?1 1M ,1 < 1<-,101 -,+K ,51<, G%(1

6 +>1 6 * +7 ,-1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 ,+78-0,1 !2 >G1!-< 0 + 101I , P <+ <>G?1 !8 <>G1 1 / ,-,; 0 >G1/ 0 GJ1+ 2 ,-(171/,: H 1-, , 1 , 1I0,: ,=; 6 ,",J1 - -0 ,",1 / 0 1 (4(1 8-* ,0-51 0 + . H ,0 +1 / 0 12 +,0 1 1 16 ,0 > 1",-!6-0,<?1 ,1 16 > 1 <!1 , 1 ,=6 *(17 6 1/ 01 1-0, ,61+ 2 ,-1 1/ 0, 1<-,1, 1-; 0 +1 / ,-,0 ,-71+ 2 ,-?1 :1 , , ,51 0,:<,= ,1,-!L ; -0+ 1 6 !" G1 -0, ,6(1 -1 / 0 1 1 -0, ,6>1 + 2 ,-1 6,+= >1 > 71 "+ < ,0 >?1 1, " >1",-!6-0 ,510+-1 6 + >1 /,+ ,<,2 *< 1/-71 !8 *1: , ,0(1 ,101/ 0,0,<1",-!; 6-0 1/,+ ,<,2 *1, " ,01",-!6-0 ,510+-16,+= >1 > 71 /,-0+ >101-," 1 < 1: , ?1 , , > 1 1-,:6 K 1 1 :>0 ; <!K1 / ,-,0 ,-71+ 2 ,-(1

1,6 ,<1 :1 ,< ,01=! + 1I ,+* *1:0 :6 J?1 :6 0 08 ; ",-*1/,-+ 1 0,+KH 1%E$)1",6 ?1. +,-,.17(1 1,/! + ,0 +1 / , 1I22 6 +7 ,",1: , 1,10 2 >G1 1 , P <+ <>G1/ 0 G1 ,--5-G1" =6 J(1E+ 0 , 1, + 2 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1, 1 6-/, 2-,",17(1 10 6 +101 ,<?12 ,1/ 0,0, 1",-!6-0,1 I(((1-<,1- *1," 2 0 1 *6,<1/,-,* >G1 , <?1 , , > 1, ,1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 7<(11 399357' ((1 , *1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1331,+ 2-51-,51 -,0 < >G1 ",-!6-0117 (1-(1 (1%(17 (?1%E$)(17(1%R'(1

1

!"

01-0, G1-, -0 >G1-G1 8 1-, +K6 7J%(1F < <?12 ,1 01M G1-+,0 G1:0!2 1<, 01-<,," 2 *1",-!6-0 ?1 ; ! <>51 ,"6 1 18 "1 : 61/,1 -0 K1 -1 , 51I, L-; 0 ,",16,",0, J?1/,-,+7 !1 , 1",-!6-0,1-<,?1!-0+ ; 0 *1-0, 1" H>?1<,= 1 1-2 7-*1-10,+ 51 ,6 (1817(1 !1 /,6, *1/ : *1 1/ < < ?1 ( (16 + 1, 100,6 1 1 ," 2 *1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 91 " =6-, 1 0-0,1 1 + 2 *1-0, ,6#(1

(4(18-* ,0-5?1C(4(13 5 ?14( (1 01-2 + ?12 ,1, ; L-0,1 1<,= 1-71-0, ,6 ><?1 1,-0, ,6 01 =6!K1+ 2 ,-7(1 E,-!6-0,1= 1 1<,= 1-2 7-*1-,1/ 0,0><?1 1," 2 01 -0,K10+-710,1 <*1/ : >G1/ 01 1-0, ,61+ 2 ,-?1 , , > 1 1 <,"! 1 > 71, 2!=6 >1 2 1 1/,1-!6!(13 :0 0 *1 ,0-!K1 , ; H /H K1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 ?1 7(4(1 8, +* 0-51 -0 1 1 0: < ,51, 0-0 ,-1",-!6-0 1 1+ 2 ,-16 !"1/ 616 !; ",<(1 : 0-<>51 ,-!H , >51 -!61 6,+= 1 -,* 71 1 -= 1 M ,51, 0-0 ,-?1/ 2 <100 6!1/,6, ,51 ,+ 1-!6 1,-, , 1: ; 2 1 /,+!2 1 6,0 1 ,6 1 1 -!6!(1 2 1 ,6 ,",1 6,0 *1 ,+ + 1-< 1,-,0>1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 (1

,51/ : ?1 1/,6: , ,-71/ 0 +7-0 ,51 1-!6 ; ,510+-?1 (C(1E--10 ,-+101,/ 6 + 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-; 0 11I 0,0><1 :>0-*1",-!6-0,?1 , , , 1/ : 16+*1- *1 1/ 0 +7-0 1-,:6 0 <> 1 <1= 1 1: , ,6 + <1K 6 2 ; -1 , <>(1 0,0, 1",-!6-0,101-0, 516 * +7 ,-?101,-!L-; 0+ 1/ 0 +7-0 >G1 1-!6 >G1.! H 51-0*: ,1 1," ; 2 ,1/ 0,<?1-, 1/,61/ 0,<?1 1 10 1/ 0 1 1 1 61 <(1F + 2 ; +7 ><1 -0,5-0,<1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1*0+*-*1/,6: , ,-71 / 0 +7-0 ,51 1-!6 ,510+-(1 *1/,6: , ,-71/ 6/,; + " 1, ,-, + 10+-5191, 6 + 1/ 0 +7-0 ,510+-1 , 1: , ,6 +7 ,51 1-!6 ,51, 1 ,51 16 !",5JR(1

D-, 1 : < 2 1 ]6 + +1 D( (1 g , ?1 /,+ " 08 5?1 2 ,1 /,< <,1, L G1,-,01/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 ?1 -0,5-0 >G10-<1 H 0 + :,0 ><1 -<?1 6+*1 3,--?1 : < KL 51 ," ,< !K1 , K?1 , G,6 < 1 :!< *16 H + : H *1/ 0 +7-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11 ,+* *1:0 :6 (1%E$F(1Q1@(1)1* 0(17(1##@(1

#17<(11 ,+* *1:0 :6 (1%E$F(1Q1@(1)1* 0(17(1#)$(1 R1399357' ( 7F1/ 0,0,<1",-!6-0 (17 (?1%E$F(17(1%#(1

0 >G1 , " ,0?1 !< +>51 !2 1 : ,, : *1 <->G1 !-+,0 5?1 01 ,<12-+ 1 1 H , +7 >G(1F 1-2 +1-,* +7 ><16+*13,--1 : , ,6 +7 , 1! 0 =6 1-0, ,6>1+ 2 ,-?1-,0-1 10 ,;-/,0 6 *?1 / ,-,0 ,-1 <!L-0 ?1 , ,+*1 , L-; 0 ,-1 : 1 -/,+ <1 K6= ?1 : 2 +7 > 1 / 0 1 -<,; !/ 0+ *1 6+*1 : <-0%(1 7(4(1 8, +* 0-51 ,-, ,1 /,62 0 +?1 2 ,1 I-/ 71 8 , >1 -<,!/ 0+ *1 01 / 6 + G1 6 ,",1 ",-!; 6-0 1 -71 ,6 1 :1 -<>G1 "+ 0 >G1 / : ,01 ,",?1 -,+7 ,1 , ,1-/,-, ,1,-!L-0+* 71/ H /1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 J#(1

,6,+= *1 " " + 0-;6 + 2-!K1 6 H K1 ,+ ,0 ; *10: <,, ,8 51" =6-,",1, L-0 1 1/ 0,0,",1",-!; 6-0 ?1 (4(18-* ,0-51 -2 +?1 2 ,1 I + ",6 *1 ,6 ,<!1 / 0 +7-0!1 1/ 0 <12 +,0 1 1" =6 ?1" !KL <1 /,+ 2-!K1-<,6 * +7 ,-71 1, 6 +7 >G1+ H?1 1 1, L ; -0 >G1 " !//?1 0-*1 , " : H *1 / 0,0,",1 ",-!6-0 1 < 1 2-,1 , L-0 >51 G (1 0 +7 , 1 1 , < +7 , 1-/,+; 1",-!6-0 >G1.! H 5101/ 0,0,<1",-!6-0 1: 0-1 , 1-<,6 * +7 ,-1, L-0 1 1 ,6 >G1<--JR(1

0 6 >510>8 1 51M-!-101-, K1 :0 *16 ; <, 2-G1 1 + +7 ,;"!<-2-G1 6 51 ",-!6-; 0 ,",1 1/,+ 2-,",1!-,5-0 1/,:0,+* 1*-10 6 71-!L ; -0 , 1 :+ 2 1 < =6!1 < 1 1 6 !",51 6 H 5?1 6!L 51 , 1 + , 1 1<-:<!;+ :<!(18+--1<-:< ?1 10/,-+ 6; -0 1 (D(15 10,10-G1 -+!2 *G1+K + 1/,62 0 71 +--,; 0!K1/ ,6!1",-!6-0 191I< 8 >J16+*1/,6 0+ *1 +--,0>G1 / , 0 ,01 ",-/,6-0!KL <1 01 M , ,< 1 +--,<(1 C- -; -, 1 , P*-1 ",-!6-0 1 1 , !6 *1 -+ *1 ! 6 +7 ,1 /,6 0 6 +,-71 1,/> 1 8 ",1",-!6-0 ?1 , , , 1 1/,-+ 1F ; * 7-,",1 / 0, , 1 ,-+,-71 -!< ,<1 6+*1 /,6 0+ *1 ,+78-0 1 ,6 (1 3 :0 1 -,0-,51 ",-!6-0 ,-1 /,; -+ 6,0 +7 ,18+,101 / 0+ 1/,+ ,",1,",-!6-0+ *10-G1 -. 1 , L-0 ,51 = : ?1 / 0 L *1 ",-!6-0 1 01 -6-0,1 <--,0,51 /--(1 G,61, 1",-!6-0 16 ! >1/ ,+ ; 1 1, L ,6 ,<!1",-!6-0!191 1 ,+ 12 <1 < ,+," ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1FA657! 418 1!-,0 71013,--1/ 0,0,51",-!6-0 >51-,5V15 5/H "?1%E$)1

#16 3F9CA 71 +-71 1/ 0,11/ , + <>1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 (1C(?1%E%)(17(1R#F(1 R1A9 C6F9CA 7(12 :(1-,2(17(1%)%(1

1

"$