Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

= ,1 0,: 1 / , + < 1 , ,-,0 *1 ! 0-+7 ,-1 M G1 I ,6,01 + 1/ H /,0J1S , <T(11

A53 6 "1/,6G,61-0 1 1! 0-+7 ,-1<, ; + ?1 , < <1 1/ H / <1 , , ,516,+= 1/,62 * 7-*1+K ,51 ; :!< >512 +,0 ?10>:>0 *1 1= : 1 +," 2 >510,/ ,-1S, 1,-,; 0 *G1! 0-+7 ,-T1 16,/,+ +7 ,191,1/ 2-,51 ; + : H 1 ,51<, + 101= : 1 : ,, : >G1 !+7 ! ?1H 0 + : ; H 5?1-,H +7 >G1, L ,-51 1" !//(1 13 & 6 51/,6G,6 1 1 / 0, 1 <-,1 0>G,6 1 / , + < 1 -, :< <,-1 , <1 1 / H /,0?1. 2-1 ! ,0,6*L G1/,0 6 <1+K6 5101 : >G1 -,H , !+7 ! >G1 - -< G?1 -,H +7 >G1 " !// G1 1 , L ,-*G(1 ,+!2-*?12 ,1 < 1I<, +7J1!/, +*-*101 : >G1 , ; -G?1 -1 :+ 2 ,51 , , 0 ,51 " !: ,5(1 3 :+ 2 >51 -<>-+?1 0 + 6>0 <>51 01 /, * 1 <, + ?1 .-! 1 3(E(1 4/-*%?1 / ,; -+ = 0 KL 51 /, : + 1 0,6, :6 + 1 < =6!1 6 0 6! +7 ,51 1 , L-0 ,51<, +7K?1 + ?1/,1 8 <!1< K?1< =6!153 +1 13 6 6 5 +811 +7 ,516 5-0 +7 ,-1<, +71 1 0; -0 ,-71/ /+ >?10: <,6 5-0!K 16 !"1-16 !",<?1 ,1-71 , G,6 <,-712 ,16 ..H ,0 71 G1/,1-! P <1 1< G ; :< <16 5-0 *(11

7! P ,<1<, + 10>-!/ 1 6 0 6?1-<,,/ 6 +*KL 5-*1 01 2-0 12+ 1, L-0 ?1, 0-0 ,",1: 1 ",?10>/,+ *KL ",1 -0,516,+"1 :, ,-+7 ,1 1-0, 51 + 1 ,51-,H +7 ,;" !//,0,51 ,/ 6 + ,-(1 C, +7 , 1 -,: 1 0 +K2 ,1 0,1 0 ! KK1 <, 0 H K1/,0 6 *12 +,0 ?1, ,1-0*: ,1-1 < 1 ", *; < ?1 1< +,-6 ?1-,-7?1-,< ,-7?1/,6+,-7?1+ H < ; ?1 1 < KL < 1/ *<,",1K 6 2-,",1-<>-+ (1C, +7 , 1 ; "!+ ,0 1/,0 6 *1+K6 51! 0-+7 ,1: " 0 1< =+ 2; ,-> 1 -/ >1 , ,8 *1 I2 +,0 1 91 , L-0,J(1 -!; H , +7 ,-71 , <1<, + 1-0*: 1-1,-!-0 <1/! + 2 ,",1< ; G :< 1 G1 0,/+,L *1 01 = : 7?1 -1 ,H ,5?1 0> >0 <,51 01 / H / 1 0 1 G;+ ,1 ,. H +7 >G1 -! ,0(1 ,: *1 -/, ,1 :1< =+ 2 ,-,51 -,+ 6 ,-?1<, +7 > 1 , <>101 -0, <16 5-0 1,/ K-*1 1-+!15&3 B1 1-,0-71 1-/,-, ,-71/,62 * 71-0, 1/,0 6 1 :!-+,0 ><1 ,0 ; *<1-+ 6,0 *16,+"!(1 ,1D(18 !?1<, +7 >51: , 1/ 6-1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(118 39 57B(12 :(1-,2(?17(1F)9FE(1

/ 61 2 +,0 ,<1 1 6,+=-0,0 ?1 ", 2-51 </ ; 011IZ/,-!/ 51 ,+7 ,1-,"+-,1 ,51<-< ?1 ! ,0,6-0!*-71 , , ,51 >101 ,1= 10 <*1<,= 871/,= + 7?12 , >1, 1-+ 10-; , L <1: , ,<J%(1C, +71/ 6-0+* 1 -, ,51 - -<!1, L : ; 2 <>G1 , <?1 : 6 KL G1 ! 0-+7 !K1 -0*:71 < =6!1 +K67< ?1 1 -!L-0! 1010 6 1 6 +7 >G1 , <?1M +, ,01/,0 6 *(1 1<, + 1 -,0/ 6 K 1 6 0 61 1 ,6?12 +,0 1 12 +,0 2-0,?1<, +71/ ; H / +7 ,1 ! + (1

7! P ,<1 0-0 ,-1 *0+*-*1 -,H +7 *1 " !// ?1 , L ,-7?1 , 6 +7 , 1 , L-0,?1 ,/ 6 +*KL 1 G 1 /,0 6 ; *1 1 6 0 6 ?1 1 1 ,++ 0 ,51 H +,-,-(1 0-0 ; ,-710> = 1, >2 <?1 6 H 5?10 ,0,51/ 0>2 ,5?12 +,0 1 0 +K2 1 /,-6-0 ,1 01 / 2-1 ., <>1 /,0 6 *(1 6-0+ *1,16, 1 1:+ ?1-,0-1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-?1->6 ?12 ; -,-1 1 (6(1, !-+ 0+ 0 K-*1!-+,0 *< 1= : ?1/, ,-*< 1 1 -< 1 2 +,0 ?1 G ,<1 M 2-G?1 / ,.--, +7; >G?1 + " ,: >G1 1 (/(1" !//1 1, L ,-51+K6 5(1

7 ",6 *1/,; ,<!1 -0-*1 1 8-*10,/ ,-1,1 -,, ,8 ; 1 -!H , +7 ,-1 / 0 1 1 -!H , +7 ,-1 0; -0 ,-1S, L-0 ,51<, + T(1 1., 1< ,",, : ,",1,/>; 1 , /, 0 ,51 M ?1 / 1 M 2-,",1 ,6 . H ,0 *1 / ,.--, +7 ,51 6 * +7 ,-1 1 (/(1 != 1 +7:*1 " , ,0 71

.! H , +7 , 1 /, < 1 -,H +7 ,",1-! 1 1 -,0, !/; ,-1 -6 ,01 /,0 6 *1 1 0: <,6 5-0 *(1 ,M ,<!1 0-; 0 ,-71S, L-0 *1<, +7T1*0 ,1-!H , +7 1 1I- -; < 1 /,66 = 0 <>G1 01 -,, L-0 1 / H /,0?1 H ,-51 1 , <?1 1 = 1 -/ H +7 >G1 -H 5?1 /,-6-0,<1 , , >G1 M 1 /,66 = 1 ,-!L-0+*-*?1 1 = 1 -,H +7 >G1 < G :<,0?1 -1 /,<,L7K1 , , >G1M 1-H 1 + :!K-*J#(17 H ?1 + 16-; H /+ > 1 G ,+," 1 0-0 ,-?1 0> = K-*?1 / =6 1 0-",?1, L-0 ><1< <(1DG16 5-0 ,-71! + 6>0-*101 6 / :, 1, 1 2 ,= ,-16,1 5 51=-,-19101: 0-<,-1 , 1G 1-,H +7 ,51, L ,-1S" !//>T?1-/ 1, ,; 0 ,-1 6 0 6 1 1 1 / , > 1 H ,-1 1 H ,-1 -< = >G1-,H +7 >G1" !//(1A+*1/,6 ,-?1 / < ?1 . ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%15 7!17,2(11 1F1 (1C(?1%EF)(1 (1@(1W(1%(17(1##R(1

#17<(118 39 57B 72 :(1-,2(?17(1F'9F&(1

1

,51 " !//,51 0>-!/ K 1 -< 1 /,6 ,-?1 H ,-> 1/ 6/,2 ; *1I 56= ,0J1, :>0 K-*1/ 6/,2 +7 1 0-0 >G1 </ 0,01-<7 118 ,+>(1S 1, < 1M ,1-,-,* 1+ ,11 / G,6*L ?1, +, *1<,"! 1/ 0,6 71 1-<7K1/,6-!6 <>G(T1 7+,0,<?1 0-0 ,-71 1 +7 > 1 0>1-!L-0! 101 2-; 0 1 / 0>2 >G1 ., <1 , L-0 ,",1 /,0 6 *?1 : /+* 1 < !1 2 +,0 2 ,-1 / < +7 ,1 1 :+ 2 ><1 -,H +7 ><1 " !// <1 S", ,6-1 1-+7-?1<!=-1 1=-?1<,+,6 = > ?10 2 ; > 1 1 (6(T(1 1M ,<101, + 2 1, 1<, + ?1 0>1<,"! 1 > 71 1 6, >< ?1 1 1:+>< 1SI-10,+ < 1= 7191/,;0,+27 10> 7J?1I<,*1 G 1-1 KJ?1I-0,*1 ! 8 1 + = 1 1 +!J1 1 (/(T(17+ 6! 1/,<; 7?12 ,1<, +71I012-,<10 6 J1-!L-0! 1 ,+7 ,101 , 2 ; -,51 -H ?1, 1 , 6 + < 1, 1 0-0 ,-?1, 10,: ; 1 1 :0 0-*12 :1 6-0,1 1/ , 0, 2 *1-1 +7 >< 1 ; 0 < ?1, *1-, -0 , 1-,6 = 101G,6 1 :0 *12 +,0 1 1 2 +,0 2-0 (11

D-!H , +7 ,-71= 1 , <1/ 0 1: +K2-*101 G1., ; < +7 ,51,/ 6 + ,-10>-8 <1 0 , ,<1/! + 2 ,510+-?1 ,G 1 1/,66 = 1-+,510+ * *1-,, 0-0!KL G1, " ,01M ,; ",1 0 , (1 B-+ 1 <, +71 "!+ ! 1 < =+ 2 ,-> 1 , ,8 ; *?1 -+ 1 0-0 ,-71 /,66 = 0 1 -,H +7 ,;" !//,0> 1 , <>?1 ,10,: ,0 1/ 0 1-0*: ,1-1 "!+*H 516 * +7 ,; -1+K6 5?1,/ 6 +* <,51 G1-,H +7 ><1/,+,= <1 10> K; L < 1 ,-K6 1 -/ H . 2-< 1 -< 1 01 ",-!6-0 ,; , " :,0 ,<1 , L-0 (1 1 : <+ 1 1 -!L-0! 1 6 +7 >G1 /-, . H 51 <, + ?1 I-0* ,-7J?1 / 1 0-51 1 : 2 <,-1 01 / 2-,<1 ! 0 =6 1 6, ,6 + ?1 , ,-+7 (1 ,: ; ,0 1 1 :0 1 H 0 + : H 1 ! 0 =6 1 ., <>1 = : 6 *; +7 ,-1 M",-2-,",1 6 0 6 (1 7!0 >5?1 : 0-<>51 6 0 6?1/-+ 6!KL 51-0, 1H + ?1! 0 =6 KL 51-0,K1-<,-7?1 != 1M <1,6 <10-!/ 101/ , 0, 2 ?1 , ! H K1-16 !" ; < ?1 -,+71 = 1 -<,-,* +7 >< 1 1 /,0 , <>< 1 + 2 ,-*< (1 A = 1 0 > 10,:<,= ,-?1!-+,0 *1 1/ 0 + 1-, 0 ,0 *?1-,; / 2-0 1 !6! 1 : = ,1/ 0,6 71 1 :+ 2 ><1 :!+7 <1 91/,*0+ K10> " 08 G1 1/ , " 08 G?1 ,6 ,0,51< 1!-; / G (18 ,< 1 ,",?1/ !6 +7 >51G 1 0-0 >G1 , <?1

., < !KL G1 1 0,-/ , :0,6*L G1 + 2 ,-71 01 ,/ 6 + ,51 -,;

H +7 ,51-6 ?1, !-+,0+ 0 1-!L-0,0 1 G1, H +7; >G1M",-2-G1<, 0,0?1 1= 6 ,-7?1: 0-7?12-,+K 1 1 (/(1O", :<1<,= 1 > 71 1 ,+7 ,1 6 0 6! +7 ><?1 ,1 1 , /, ; 0 ,;" !//,0><1S-< 5 ><?1M 2-<?1 +--,0><?1 H , +7; ><T(1 ,62 <?1M", :<!1 +7:*1/ :K< ,0 71: 0 6,<,1:+!K1 / ,6!11I ?1 , , > 1 !K 1/ , 01M", :< ?1! 0 =6 KL ",-*1 01-0, <1/ 0 ?191/-+1 (1W 2 ?191/,-*" K 1 1-<, 1: 0 , 1 -0* + L 12 +,0 2-,",16!G ?1 10 ! KK1-0, ,6!?1 , , *1 ,6 1 < 1 8 KL 51",+,-101 0-0 >G1 1 : 0-0 >G1 /,-!/ G1+K6 5?1/,6+ = 1-!6!1, L-0 ,51-,0-?1 ,1, K671 1/ !6 +7 ,<!1: , !J(%1

C, +71 1 6 +7 , 16,+=-0,0 1 G,6-*101/,-,* ; ,<1/ , 0, 2 1-1! + :<,<1/,0-6 0 ,51= : ?1,/ 06>; 0 <,51 0 < (1C, +71 101-,-,* 1M..0 ,1 "!+ ,0 71 < ,",2-+ > 1 1 , ! !KL 1/ *: *1 6 0 6,01 1< ; +7 > ?16!G,0 > 1 1 > 1H ,-?1/,:0,+*KL 1 , < +7 ,1-!; L-0,0 71016 >G1 , ,;-, 2-G1!-+,0 *G(11

,",1 ,6 1/ *: *1-71 12 ,1 , ?1 1-,H +7 > 1/,;,-1 1->?1/ , KL 1/ 0,0,51G (1 1 +-; -,0,16 ..H ,0 ,<1, L-0 ?1, < 2 15(7(1C <! ?1, ,; 8 *1/ 0 1 1: +K2 > 101 G1-,H +7 > 1/ *: *1 !=6 ; K-*101 "!+*H 1-,1-, , >1",-!6-0 (1 0,1-G,6 1 :1, ; ,8 *1 I" =6 1 91 ",-!6-0,J?1 , + 2 *-71 , 1 <, +7 >G1 : 5?1 ! =6 5?1 , <1 / =6 1 0-",1 <?1 2 ,1 01 <1 6,+= , ?1 -/ 0 6+ 0, 1<>-+-*10-"6 1 1 ,?12 ,16,+= ,1 > 71",-!6-; 0 ><1: , ,<?1: 1 !8 12 ",16,+= 1-+ 6,0 71 : = *1 -H *(1 1M ,<?1 , 2 ,?1 !6 <1/,< 7?12 ,1I<,6 +716,+= ,; ",1 1 -/ 0 6+ 0,",J1 / =6 1 0-",1 ., < !-*1 0-0 >< 1 / 6-0+ *< 1 0+-0!KL 51 M+ >(1 A !",51 0,/ ,-1 91 01 ,51 < 1 H , +7 , 1 : , ,6 +7-0,1 ,-,0 ,1 1 6 H , >G1 0-0 >G1 H ,-*G1 , L-0 1 1 -,+7 ,1 / 0,/ < ; +7 *1 / 1 -,, 0-0! 1 <?1 1 1 , -+!= 0 1 / 0*L 51 +--(1

1 -,0 < ,<1 H 0 + :,0 ,<1 , L-0 1 / 0,0> 1 , <>1 / 6/,+ " K 1!-+,0 <1-0, ",16 5-0 *1M+ < > 1<, +7 > 1 , <>191I< <!<16, J(1 ?1 1/ < !?1/ 0,-,: 1 <>-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 %1A23 A571 +,-,. *1/ 0 (17(1E@(1

1

+ <,1 :1 +7 ,",16 5-0 *1 G1/ H /,01 1 , <?1 1!0 = ; 1 6,-,-0 1 6 !" G1 +K6 5?1 2!0-0,1 + 2 ,51 , 0-0 ,-1 : 1-0, 1/,-!/ ?1/ : 1 , G,6 <,-1!2 >0 71->1 6 !" G1+K6 5?1!0 ,-7101 ,<?12 ,1-0, ,6 10-G1+K6 51 0,:; <,= 1 :1-0, ,6>1 =6,",12 +,0 ?1 1 , , , (14 +," 2 ,1 1 *0+*K-*1 /,60 ",<1 -<,, 2 *1 ,0 *1 6, ,-,0-,",1-/,+ *16,+",0>G1, *: +7-0?10,:6 = *1, 1! 5-0 1 + 1 : ,*(11

H /1 / 0 191I : 8 ,10-?12 ,1 1: / L ,J191M.;

. 0 ,1 , 1+ 87101 ,<1-+!2 ?1 ,"6 101, L-0 1-!L-; 0!K 1<,L >51<, +7 >51.! 6 < ?1!-,52 0> 1<, +7 > 1/ ; 0>2 1 1! =6 *?1 ,"6 1!1+K6 51-71-,: +7 , 10 ! 1 -,"+-1 1-<,," 2 ?1 ,"6 1 1<, +7 > 1 2-0 12 ; +,0 ?1 1 + ", ,6-0,?1-,0-7?1/, *6,2 ,-7?1*0+*K-*12 ; < 1/,0-6 0 ,51= : (1 ,, L 1/ ,2 ,-71+K ,",1 , < 0 ,",1 "!+ ,0 *1/ *<,1: 0-1, 1/ 0 L *1 , <101+ 2 > 1! ; =6 *12 +,0 ?1016 ,<1-+!2 1910,10 ! 1<, +7 , 1 ; ,0 1: , ,/,-+!8 ,",1/,0 6 *(11

1, L-0 ,<1 -,: 1 +7 ><1 -,6 = <1 /,+ *; K-*1 1 < >1 : , ?1 , , > 1 /, * >1 1 / 2-1 ; ,-!L-0 <>1 :1!2 1 , <1 1 01, L-0 ,51<, + ?1 / < ?1 IG!+ "-0,J?1 I,-, + J?1 I + 0 J?1 I-+K2 ; +7 >51H :<J1 1 (6(1 1 1/,<,L 1 , : !K-*1 1-; ,0*-*1 , L : 2 <>< 1 1 ,H ,2 > 1 /, * *?1 1 I!0 = ; +7 *1/ 2 J?1I6,-,2 > 1,-,0 *J(1

A+*1/, < *16 + 1/ 0 1 1<, + 1/,+ : ,1 :+ 2 ; 1D(18 ,<1/,0 6 *13 5 5*B10 +K2 KL ",1-+K2 ; +7 ,10 8 ?1., < +7 > 1, ,8 *1+K6 5?1 13 53 5 5*?1 / 6-0+*KL ",1 -, ,51 0 ! KK1 -/,-, ,-71 :!< ,",1 -!; L-0 1 !-0+ 0 71 6+*1 -<,",1 - *1 ! 0-+7 >51 1 , G,; 6 <>51 0-0 >51: , 1SI ", 2-51 </ 0JT(17 ",; 6 *1 M , 1 0:"+*61 -!L-0 ,1 ! ,2 1 -,, = <1 ,1 ,<?1 2 ,1 I 1, +-10 ! ",1 10 8 ",1/,0 6 *?1 , , *1 1<,"+ 1 >1/,6+ = 71 1<, +7 ,5?1 1 1/ 0,0,51,H J%(1E(13 6 !G1-G,6 1 :1 ,+78,",1 2-+ 1 / < ,01 1 0+ * *1 0 ! ",1 /,0 6 *1 1 / 0,0, 1 "!+ ,0 1 ,/ 6 + ,",1 0 8 ",1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(11B E4 .7(1 +,-,. *1/ 0 (1C(?1#$$@(17(1)$(1