Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

/,0 6 *1 S., < 1 0 >?1 6, ,-,0-,-7T?1 1 10>:,0 1/ 0,; 0>G1 /,-+ 6-0 51 0 ! <1 /,0 6 <(1 ,M ,<!1 +7:*1 ",0,; 7?12 ,1/ 0,1,/,-6-0! 1+ 8710 8 16 5-0 *(14 +," 2; ,1<, +7 > 1,H 1 1," 2 0 K-*1-+K2 +7 ,10 ! ; <1 /,0 6 <1 S ,1 1 0 6 1 :-+!" 1 01 I + " G1 < *G?1 0 6!L G101 6J?1 +7:*1!-< 0 710 !101I/, ,2 >G1= + *GJ?1 I-!8 J?1I-, + : JT%(1

1 <1 1< ?10 ! 1S<, +7 , T1/,0 6 1/,/ 6 101 -. !16 5-0 *1/ 0 1+ 87101 ,51< ?101 ,51/ ,*0+*-*101+ ; " +7 ,<1/,0 6 (1 <1-<><1/ 0,0, 1 "!+ ,0 1,-0+* 1 :0->51/ ,-, ?1/ ,- -0,16+*1 <, +7 >G1/,-!/ ,0(1

18+K216+*1 8 *1M ,51/ , + <>19101: , ,6 +7 ,<1/ ; : 1: 1 =6><12 +,0 ,<1 ",1<, +7 ,51 1 ++ ! +7 ,51 : 0-<,-?1-/,-, ,-1-<,-,* +7 ,10> 71H + ?1-6; -0 1 6 * +7 ,-?1 G 1 /,0 6 *1 1 (6(1 -*1 ,+ 1 ,/-> 1., <>1:+ ?1/ 0,1,6 ,0 < ,1-, 1 1-= 16, ,; 0,+7 ,",1 0> , 1 6, (1 S 0,1 /,:0,+* 1+K6*<16 + 71 -0, ,6; >510> , 1< =6!16, ,<1 1:+,<?1/,1< K1 +(17,+,07 0 ?1, ,1 ,+7 ,1 01 -G1 , L ",1 + " 1 / /*-0! 1 :+,<!1 2 +,0 !1 -71:+,6 <191IU 6 2 1/ 0 1 101 ,<?12 , >1+ = L 510,1:+ 1< 1 , +-*101g-0,1 ,= ?1 1 ,+7 ,101 ,<?12 , >1, 1916,10 < 1 1/ 0 +-*101 6JT(#1 <1-<><1, ,1-,0-*1 , < 0 ><1 7 ,<1 1 ,+7 ,16+*1, L / : >G1/-!/+ 51S! 5-0,?1 0, ,0-0,?18 =?10><," +7-0,T?1 ,1 16+*1/,/> , 1/ !6 ; +7 ,1-,:6 71/ 0,/, *6, ?1,-,0 >51 1 G1 + 1 >G1 0; -0 >G1/ H / G(11

0-0 > 1 / 6-0+ *1 ,1 / H / G1 / 0 1 -/,-, >1 /,6< 71 / 0,1 : ,, : >< 1 1 / , 0, 2 0>< 1 / 6-0; + *< 1,16, 1 1:+ ?1-/ 0 6+ 0,<1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,<(17 = <?1-, 1 0-0 , 1 ,0 1 -,</ ,<--,-1 01 , 7 1 -1 /-!/ ,-7K1 / , 0, 2 1 1 / H /!1 6 ..; H H 1 1 6 0 6! + : H 1, 0-0 ,-1: 1/ 0, !8 ?1 1 1/,+ 2-,<!1 2-0!1/ 0 (1 1/,-+ 6 <1-+!2 1 <-*1 010 6!1 "!+*H *1/ 0,<1 1-,-0 *12-710 ! 51/,+ ;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1B E4 .7(1 +,-,. *1/ 0 (17(1)$((1

#16 6F)3F7'11F/ 06 16, (17(1@)@(1

1

1->?1-<*L 5-*1 5 1 :!< >51 ,</ ,<--1< =6!1 ;-< 1+ 2 ,-?1" !//>1 1, L-0 101H +,<(1

BL 1 <>-+ + 1 M/,G 1 ,-0 L *1 ! 6 +7 ,1 /, : + ?1 2 ,1 I<, +-2-*1 : , ,-7J1 1 ,+7 ,1 1 -/,-, -0! 1 , < +7 ,51 = : 1 , L-0 ?1 ,?1 , , , 11 , :>0 1 : !8 ; +7 , 1 0,:6 5-0 1 1 M , ,< !?1 /,+ 2-!K1 1 6!G,0 !K1 = : 71+K6 5(1U , ,6 +7-0,?10,:0,6*L 1 0-0 > 1/ ; H />101 "1/ 0 ?1/ 0,6 1 1 ,<!?12 ,1/-!/+ 1S 1 0; -0 , 1/, * T1-,0-*1/,0,6,<16+*1 +7 ,51 /--1 / , 010-",1, L-0 ?1 :0 L KL 51 ",1-0 G!16, :!(1 1M ,<1 -+!2 1 : K1 /,6+ = 1 1 ,+7 ,1 !+ 2 , 1 1 6, : , 1 /-!/ , 16 5-0 ?1 ,1-<1, :1<>-+ 5?10 ! 1 < (1 +- -, 1",-!6-0,101-0, G1-G,6 >G1/,: 0 >G1,-,; 0 *G1-G,6 1 :1/ : *1-0, G1/,66 >G1-,0 8 ,+ ; < ?1 ,1-71I-<>8+ >8 < J?1 , , > 1-<,-,* +7 ,1 101 -,-,* 1 :+ 2 716, ,1 1:+,?1/ 6,-0+ > 1-< 1- 1 ; / < ,1 /,66 6!-*1 -, + : !1 /, , ,0(1 ,1 < ,<!1 -0 K1 O( (17,+,07 0 ?1 , 1",-!6-0,10,-/ , :0,6 1 :!-2-51 / 6,-1-6 0 ,0,51 0 : H ?1!2 =6 ,51I0,1 <*1/ 0 1 =6,",1G-1 > 71-/-<><1, 1- *1-<,",191, 1/ ,+,; " 2-,51-,0 L <,-?1 , , *1-0,5-0 1 <!1 1-!L-0!?1 /,0 =6 ,<!1" G,<J(%1

,-,+7 !1-!L ,-71<, + ?1-<1-/,-, 1 1 > *1 , 6 + <1 , 1 -, ,0 ,",?1 0 ! ",1 < 1 2 +,0 ?1 ,1 /! + 2 ,; , < 0 >51G 1 10> = *1S/ 0,6101 0-0 > 10>; -:>0 *T1/ ,0,H ! 1 < H K?1/,6< !16 + H *< 1 -,; +K >G1/,1-0, <!1-,H +7 ,<!1: 2 K1H ,-51<, + (1 >; -!/ *1 01 2-0 1 -,+K >G1 / 6 +,01 / ,- -0 1 2 +,0 2 ; -,51 !+7 ! >?10>G,61: 1 , , > 10+ 2 1 : = , 1 1-<, :; !8 ?1, 1, :>0-*12 :0>2 5 ,1!*:0 <,5101, ,-+7 >G1 S" !//,0>G?1M 2-G?1 6 0 6! +7 >GT1., < G1-0, ",1-!L-; 0,0 *(11

,M ,<!?1-+ 1 < 71010 6!1/,0-6 0 !K1/ !12 +,0 ; 2-,",1, L *1 1/,0 6 *?1-/ 0 6+ 0,1< ?1-,"+-,1 ,; , ,<!1I(((0>-:>0 *1,1<, + 1",0, * 1 1,1<, + 1 1 1 ,<?1 2 ,1<>1 < ! <1<, +7K?1 1,1 8 <1, ,8 1 1 ,<!?12 ,1<>1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%16 6F)3F75 /(1 0,0,51 " + :<(17(1#$&(1

< ! <1<, +7KJ%(1A !" < 1-+,0 < ?1+K *1, P 0 H *1<, ; + 1 , :>0-*1 1 : = ><1 -= <?1 ! + 6>0 KL <-*1 01 6 / :, 1< =6!1 1/,+ ><1, H <?1H :<,<1 10-6,:0,+ ; ,-7K1S 1,-,0 1, ,-+7 ,-1+K ,",1<, +7 ,",10>-; :>0 *T1 1<, +7 ,516 < "," 5?1/-0, <1/ 0 1",0, 71, 1 < 1<, + 1S 1,-,0 1 : = ,-1 0-0 >G1,H , T(1 C, +7 *16 < "," *1, != 0 1 - *101/ " != ,-10>; -:>0 51 <, +7 >< 1 < < 1 1 ,H < ?1 01 /-0, 1 / 0 10> ,-71<, +7 >510 6 ?1 *0 ,1/ 6/,+ " KL 51-, ; -0 !K1 /," 8 <,-7(1U6-71-, 1G =-0 ?1.-5-0 ?1 + H < *(1 3 :0 > 1 <, +7 > 1 - -<>1 8 K 1 M !1 / , + <!1 0>60 = <1 0 = ,",1 , < 0 ,",1 ,0 *?1 /,6 /+ ,; ",?1 1/ 0 +,?1 + " ,: ><1, ,-,0 <191 1-!6 16 !" G\1 g ,-> 1 ,-,0 *1 / 0 1 -+K2 K 1 /,/> 1 / !6 +7; ,",1-,0 8-0,0 *1 1,-2-+ 0+ *1+K6 5(1

1B- -0 ,?1 2 ,1 / ++*H *1 1 < . : 2-<1 H ,-*<1 S0 101 ," T1 1 1-,0-1 1<,"! 1 8 71/ , + <!1 , G,6 <,; -1-/ 0 6+ 0,",1-!6 ?1/ 0,-!6 *(17 : , 10>8 1 1,: 2 1 ,",;+ ,1 / , 0,/,-0+ *?1 : >0 1 / 0 1 1 <, + ?1 -,; -,* +7 ,",1 1-1 , 2-,5?1 1-1/ 2-,51 ,2 1: *(1 U , ,6 +7-0,?1 " , !KL 1 + 1 -+ ,1 !2 >0 KL 1 <,; +7 > 1 , <>?1 / 0,6 1 1 ,51 = 1 6 " 6 H 1 , L-0 ?1 2 ,1 1 <, +-2-*1: , ,-7(1O ,1,: 2 ?1/ =6 10-",?1 ,?12 ,1 2 <1 0>8 1 ! ,0 71 0-0 ,51 : +,-1 2 +,0 ?1 <1 0>8 1 ! ,0 71 ",1 -,*L G1 1 !6!L G1 / 0,0>G1 0,:: 51 16 5-; 0 5Y1 0,;0 , >G?1 -<1 G 1 6 5-0!KL ",1 : , ,6 +7-0 1 6,+= 1-< 7-*1 1, " 2-,<!1 6-0!1/ 0 1 1<, + ?1 1-0, *KL <!1 G16 !"1016 !" 1 1 1/ , 0,/,-0+*KL <!16 !"1 6 !"!(1 1M ,<1/+ 1 !6 ,1/ ,H 71 ,+71/ 0 101! 0 =6 ; 1<, +7 >G1H ,-5(17 = <?1/,1-! 1-0, 51/ 0,1/ :0 ,1 /,6 /+* 71 !K1 <, +7 !K1 H ,-71 H 0 + : H ?1 1 -/ ; 0 6+ 0,-7(1 1-+!2 5 ,101M ,51-0*: 1/-2 1-<>-+,01 ; ", 51I/ 0,J?1I/ 06 J?1I-/ 0 6+ 0,-7J101<, + ?1 0-0 ; ,-1 1 / 0 (1 7 7*1 %FE1 E81 3 1 !-0+ 0 1 6 5-0 +7; ,-71-6 + 1-1H +7K?1/ , 0 ,51,-,0 <1/ 0,/, *6 1 1 0-;

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(1193 56F71C, +7 *16 < "," *1 1., < 1 /,+," 1-+ *1331 ,/ ,->1. ; +,-,. (1%EE)(1Q1)(1

1

"

0 ,-(1 ,+ 1 ,",?1 / 0,1 1 2-71 1 6,-,-0,1 S/, * *?1 < KL 1 <, +7 , 1 -,6 = T1 1 ,G 1 M ,",1 / 0 1 01 6 5-; 0!KL <1 : , ,6 +7-0 1 0,:0 6 >1 01 "1 ,-!H , ,",1 / H / 1 91 -7*1 @$1 8,-!H 1 3 1 !-0+ 0 11 I =6>51 < 1 / 0,1 1 !0 = 1 1 : L !1 2-1 1 6,-,-0 J(1 ,+7; 8-0,1, <1!",+,0 ,",1/ 0 1-,6 = 1: / >11,/ 6 +*K 1 -H 1 1 !8 +*<1M G1: / ,01/,1, ,8 K1 1-,H +7 ,1 ,/-><1 6 5-0 *<?1 / , 0, 2 L <1 <, +7 ><1 H ,-*<(1 2-1=6 *1, < 1-< 5 ,",1/ 0 10,:0,6 10-0 ; > 1, <>101"1: , ?1-<*-71<1-<><11! /+ K1-; <7 (1 IB-+ 1 ,-0, ,6 71 , <>1 -< 5 ,",1 / 0 1 , 1 ,0 51 , <1<, + ?191/,62 0 14(1C(1 2 0 ?191: < 01 G1-!"! ,1 6 +,0>< 1 / 0 + < ?1 , + 2 KL < 1 6 5-0 *1 1 /,-!/ 1 !2-; ,01 " =6-G1 , ,8 5?1 -< 5 , 1 / 0,1 /-1 > 71 ,0><J(%1 <1 1 < ?1 -*1 1 ! 0-+7 *1 / ,6 1 <, + 1 1 / 6/,+ " 1 ,2 ,",1 ! : *1 91 1 < ,1 6,+= 1 > 71 + :,0 1 , *1 , < 1016 ,51-! H (1W +,0 ?1 /,0 !*-71 -0, <1 0-0 ><1 ! =6 *<?1 -<,-,* +7 ,1 -,; 0 8 10> , 1/,-!/ ?101 ,<12-+ 1 1 , L-0 ,",(1 ; 0,0 *1= 1 , < ?1 1/ 0 +,?1-<-*1 1<-< +7 ,51 ,2 ,-1 01! : 16 5-0 5?1 , , > 16,+= >1 > 71-,0 8 >1 + 1, 1 ,; , >G1 , G,6 <,10,:6 = 7-*(1

,62 <101: +K2 ?12 ,1 !6 1,8 ,2 ><1/ 0,6 71 , < 2 > 1G-1 6-0 1/ 0 1 1<, + 1 1! ,0 71 / 2-,51K-/ !6 H (1A!G!1/ 0 1 1 ! 0 1: , 1/ , ; 0, 2 1/ < 1K 6 2-G1 , <1&5 3 6 5101: 0 ; -<,-1, 1<, +7 >G1/ H /,01 1 0(1 ,-+ 6 1 < K 1 , ,8 1 1 / 0!1 01 ,51 < ?1 01 ,51 /-!-0!K 1 01 , < G1 / 0 ?1/,+ 2-100 6 >101/ 0,0!K1- -<!(1 ,M ,<!1 0 ; ,?12 ,1/ 0,1 1, < * 1- *1 :+ 2 <16, 1 1:+ ?1 1+ 871 ,/ 6 +* 1" H>1 -+ 0 KL G-*1-,0?1/ 0 1 1, *: ; ,-1-! P ,01/ 0,0,",1, L *(1B-+ 1: , ,6 +7-0,1 0; ,6!8 ,1 1<, +7 ,; 0-0 ><1! =6 *<1, L-0 ?1 ,1: ; , 1/-K 1!0 = 7(14 +," 2 ,?1 , =-0!1/ 0,-!6 *1 1: ; , 1, K671 1/ , 0, 2 12 +,0 2 ,-71K-,0(11

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 32 3F 7 (17 < 5 , 1/ 0,11/ , + <>1 1/-/ 0>1 :0 *1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ ; 0,(1%EEE(1Q1R(17('R(1

25 35 " 165&35 "1 1 1B1

%(1 8 10: <,-0*: >1/ 0,?1<, +71 1 0-0 ; ,-7V1

#(1 ,2 <!1 , G,6 <,1 :+ 2 71<, +7 , 1 1+ ; " +7 , 1/,0 6 V1

R(1 8 1/ , 0, 2 *10,: K 1< =6!1/ 0,<1 1 <, +7KV1

@(1 12 <1 -<>-+1 6 1I/ 0 1 1< <!< 16, ; JV1

)(1 81 <1/,-+ 6-0 *<10 6 1I<, +-2-*1 : , ,-7JV1

F(1 1 ,51 < 1 K-1 01 -0, 51/ ,.--, +7 ,51 6 * +7 ,-1 ! ,0,6-0!-*1 , < < 1<, + 1 1 0-0 ,-V1

1

3#23 D.C5 3E 5 D-3 ' B3

1

7< *1 : 71 / 0+ + 1 ?1 :1 -,< *?1 !6 1 0-"6 1 / 0+ 71 ,-58 1 0 < 1 +K6 5?1 0>:>0 *1 ", *2 ?1 /, ,51 ,=-,2 > 1-/, >?1-,0 1 1-,0 10>:>0 *1 1= : ?1 1/ 0 ; +,?1,6 1 1 1= 1 "!< >(1 1M ,<1/+ 1/, : +7 >1-,; / > 1 :0 *1< ," G1/! + H 51 1M !1 <!11I: J1 1I/ , 0J?1 1,-0+*KL 1 ,"6 10,:<,= ,-510: <,/, < *(1 < ; 2 +7 ,1 1 ,?12 ,10,6, :6 +1< =6!1-, , < 1 1/ , 0 ; < 1-< ,51 : 1/ ,G,6 1 1< =6!1 , < 1S. +,-,. < ?1 / 0,0 6 < ?1 0,, L 1 "!< *< T1 1 6 !" < 1 +K67< ?1 91 /,1 : > 1-, , >1I 6>J1, :>0 K-*1 1/ 6-0 + 1K ; 6 2-,",1-,, L-0 (1C,= ,1/, * 712!0-0 1+K6 5?1/, *08 G1 + : G1, 1 ! 1=-, ,",1! 5H>?1 <1 1< ?1 8 10,/ ,-1 ,16,/!-<,-1-< ,51 : 1 1<,= 1 > 71H + ,<1/,-0+ ; ,101: 0-<,-71, 12!0-01 1M<,H 5?1 1 >1 1 >+,10 + ,1", (1 1 ,1= 10 <*1 6,/!-<,1 0*:>0 1I-0 G!J1,/ 6 + ,",1 , ,8 *1 1 -< ,51 : 1 91 M ,1 0-"6 1 + 2 ,->51 < ,0,:; : 2-51 0> , 1 -,1 0-51 /,+ , ,51 ++ ! +7 ,51 1 0-; 0 ,51, 0-0 ,-1: 1 ",(11

1

$