Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

/,6, KL ",1 -+!= ,",1 /,0 6 *?1 : 8 K1 , .+ 1-,01 101/,+7:!1",-!6-0 1 1, L-0 (1

,10>6 = 1 :1M 2-,",1 ,6-1",-!6-0 >G1" =6 ; -G1-+!= L G14+ 5-,",1 *1 "+*6 ,1-0 6 +7-0!K 1,1 5 51 -/ 1/ ,. H 1M ,51 6 1 , ,<16-; 0 >G1/,= + 511 IE =6-51 -+!= L 51 6,+= 1 > 71 , ><1 1 0 =+ 0><10,1 0: <,, ,8 *G1-1 ,++ " < ?1, L 7-*1 1 <1/,1 < 1 1, 2-; 0!(1E =6-51-+!= L 51 16,+= 16,/!-71 <, +7 >G1., <1 /,0 6 *?1 > 71-,< ><101/,0-6 0 ,51= : 1 1 > !J(1

1M ,<1= 1 +K2 1/ G,6-*1 ,0 71 1 6 0 1 :P*-; 1 + !< 1 G,0 ,",1 -!6 1 =-,*L <1 -!6 <1 /,1 6 + <1 ,1 6,+= ,->G1 / 0, !8 *G1 2 ,0 ,0(1 D<1 ,< 6,0 ,1 0/ 671--< 0 71 1!",+,0 , 1/-!/+ ?1 :>0 <, 1/,1 -(#&)1 281 3 1 S:+,!/, + 1 6,+= ,->< 1 /,+ ,<,2 *< T?1 / , H , :<1 91 : , , 1 -,6 5-0 1 01 !6,!-,5-0 ?1 / ,; 60 = 1 /,1 -+!= ?1 /,,L 1 /,62 ,",?1 1 = 1 , 1 /,; ,0 +7-0,1/,1-+!= ?1-,0 8 , 1 :1 , >-,51 + 1 ,51+ 2; ,51:-,0 ,-(1 + ", 1/,= + 1/ , 0,6 5-0 *1 7 ; :<!?1 -< 5-0 ,-?1 + ,0,-1 / G,6 1 01 *0 , 1 / , 0, ; 2 ?10,;/ 0>G?1-1/ 2-,51 0,:<,= ,-7K16, : 71/-!/; , 1 /, ,0 +7-0,?1 0,;0 , >G?1 2 ,1 ", :6,1 0 = ?1 -1 ! , 0; 8 5-*1- -<,51/,6 , ?1--,0 1 1,H 1 6 ,01/,1/ H /!1 + 2 ,51/ 6 ,-1 ! ,0,6 +K(1 >G,6 ?1 G,0 >51-!61 ,= 1 0 +K2 +-*101I </ KJ(1C =6!1 <?10>G,6,<1 :1-! H 1<,"+,1 >1-+!= 71/,M / , 10 6 1- -<>1/,= : ,",1 5< 1",-; -+!= L ",?1 +," 2 ,51 / 0,0,<!1 -! !1 /,= : ,",1 2 ; ,0 2-0 101 3E(1 ,1 : = 1 6, :!< 51/,62 <11 271 6 1 1,1< G 2-,51 H /H 1 , <?1-+,= 08 G-*1 1-!L-0 ; ,1 ,51 !+7 ! ,;H 0 + : H , ,51/,20 ?1 ,191, 1 :0+ 2 1/,; +,= +7 ,",1,/> 1 :1, " : H 1",-!6-0 ,51-+!= >?101 ,; , ,512 ,0 1+,*+ 1 1 2 +7 !1 + 10 6,<-0!?1 1-<,<!16 ; <, 2-,<!1",-!6-0!?1 <1-<><191, L-0!(1

7-< >51G 1 , !/H ?1 ( (1 10-, P <+KL 1/ ,; ,0 10,10-1-. >1= : 6 * +7 ,-1, L-0 ?1,-,0,/,; + " KL 1-! >1",-!6-0 ?1/ =6 10-",1910+-> 1-! ; ! >?1/ 0,,G +7 > 1 1-!6 > 1, " >?1, !-+,0+ 0 1 ; ! +7 ,-71 + : 1 1 < ,",, : >G1 ., <?1 -,, 0-0!KL G1

< 1/ ,6,+ *?1/ , 0,6 5-0 *?10>*-*1!-+,0 5?1/ 2 1 1

. , ,01 1 0,: ,0 *1 1 !-,52 0,",1 -/ ,-*?1 1 = 1 , G,6 <,-71 H 1 1 - -<,, :!KL G1 <,< G1 , !/H ?1 , 6 + <>G1, 1. ,< ,01/,+ 2-,510+-?1",; -!6-0 ,",1!/ 0+ *(11

06 ?1-, 1,",0, 7?10,1 : = 1-, + : ?1/!-716 = 1 0,+7 ,",?1 :0 2 , 1 8 1/- -10,10-<10 71I 2 +7; -0,J?12 ,0 ,0191 K , ,01 1 = 1-1 < (1 1 , !/H 1 ; 6 H , ,1 0>6 +*K 1 60 1 ! ,0 *11 I0 G!8 2 >5J1 1 I :,0,5J(1 G!8 2 *1 , !/H *1,G0 >0 10>-8 1 1-6 1:0 7*12 ; ,0 2-0 1 1/,+ ,01SM 1" !//>101: 2 +7 ,51-/ 1/ ;-K-*T?1 -,/ *= > 1 -1 / * <1 : 2 <>G1 0+-,; !/ 0+ 2-G1 8 5?1 < KL G1-,, 0-0!KL!K1H !?191, ; ,-+7 ,1 : , ,01 1 , < 0 >G1 ,0?1 ",-: !/, 1 1 ! H ,; ,0?1 :< *1., <1-, -0 ,-1 1 (/(1 :,0 *1= 1 , !/H *1 0/+ 101/,0-6 0 !K1= : 7?1 ! , 10: <,6 5-0 1" =; 6 ?1 . : 2-G1 1 K 6 2-G1 + H1 -1 -/,+ +7-<1 :0 ,<1 ",-!6-0 ,51 1<! H / +7 ,51-+!= >191 "-H ?1-/ 0; ?18 .>?1 <,= > 1- , >1 1 (6(11

10, ?1/,16 ><18 , ,<-8 ,",1 ,",1,/ ,-1 ; -+ *1D-! ,<1-,H ,+," 134 1S#$$&1"(T1/,6 0 6 +-71,6 1 :1 " 0 >G1 ,-, ,-51 -,0 < ,",1 ,--5-,",1 , L-0 (1 3 : , ?1 / < <, 1,-!=6 1 : , 6-0 ?1<:6, <-0 1 10>; <," +7-0 1I0 G,0J10/,+ 1!= 0-*1 -,1 - -G,6 +7 ><?1,/; 06>0 KL <1, ,8 <1 1 :,0,51 , !/H ?1 , , !K1I 1: < ; 2 K J?1-2 K 1- -0 ><1., ,<1, >2 ,51= : (11

,M ,<!1 <,= ,1 -< +,1 ! 0 =6 7?1 2 ,1 , !/H K1 0,:; <,= ,1/ ,6,+ 71 :1 +7 ,51/,+ 2-,51 , ! H ?1 :; = ,1 -,/ ,0,=6 KL 5-*1 1 /! + 2 >< 1 :, + 2 *< 1 6,+= ,->G1:+,!/, + 5?1/ , H , :< ?1 : , 6-0 1 1 (/(101 -1/,+ 2-G1/ , 0 ,0?1 1 1 -, -0 ,",1,2 ; L *1 , 1 + H?1 6-6 !KL G1 / K1 + 1 ",-!6-0,(1 O ,1 ,: 2 ?1 01 2-,-?1 ,0 1 /, , 2 71 -1 ::-2 0><1-/,+7:,0 <1 6<-0 ,",1 -!-1 / 1 ., < ,0 1 / 6-0 +7 >G1, " ,010+-?1 0 ,1 1 1 ,0 16 5-; 0 +7 ,",1 :6 + *1 0+-51 1 ., < ,0 *1 - -<>1 0: <; >G1-6 = 1 1/ , 0,0-,0(1

1

A,1 G1/, 1/, 1 !6 1-,G * 7-*1 1,/ 06>0 7-*1- -< 1 0 , ,51/,+ 2-,510+-?1-0,6*L *1 ,+71/,+ 2-,51 ,//,: H 1 1 +,! 6 ?1 !6 1-,G * 7-*1 1 < H , >51G ; 1 I , 7 >1 -1 , !/H 5J?1 -1 : 1 / 6-:! <><1 1 / 2 +7; ><1. +,<(11

F-, ,1* ,1/ , 0, 2 *1/ 0 1 1/,+ 10> = K-*101 / ,6>1 0,+KH , >G1 /, *-51 , L-0 ?1 -< >1 ,6 ,",1 , ; L-0 ,",1 -,*1 6 !" <(1 1 / < 1 1 :>0 <,",1 < <,",1 ,-!H , + :< ?1 / 6-0+*KL ",1 -, ,51 " 61 ,0>G1 S , ; -!H , ,;/ 0,0>GT1/,+ 2-G1., <1 1-,",1S 0 , ,; ",T1/,+ 2-,",1-,6 = *?1<,= ,1 +K6 71/ 0 L 1 , ; -!H 1 101-6-0,1-,H +7 ,",1 , ,+*?1 101-6-0,1+ " ; < H 1 6 H , >G1 ,-+ 51 0+-1 /,1 , :H <1 != 1 -!L-; 0!KL G16 <, 2-G1 = <,0(1A+*1-1-",6 *10-7< 1 ; -10>0,61,1 ,<?12 ,1M , 1/,+ 2-51<! 10>-!/ 1-, 1 1 H *1 1 6 +7 >51/ G,61, 1 0 , ,",1 = < 1 16 <,; ?1 -6-0,1 - + : H 1, L-0 101-G1 6 H , ,1 / 0*L ",1 +--1S-,H +7 ,51" !//>T?12 <1 1/ G,6 *1., < 1 1 / 0,0,<!1",-!6-0!(1 ,1< K1--+ 6,0 +*1M ,51/ , + <>?1 6 >51. ,< 1/ 6-0+ 101-, 1 : >G1-1 *6,<1., <191 , 1 ,-!H , ,51<, G 16,1/ : 6-,51-/! + 1 1 :; + 2 >G1., <16 ,-G1 = <,0%(1

C =6!1 <?1/,6+ , 1/ 0,?1/ 0,1 1 ,0, 1 0,:<,= ,1 :1: , ,6 +7 >G1," 2 5?1 , , > 1, L-0,1 + " 1 1 0,:<,= > 1 , >-> 1 + 1 /--0 > 1 6 5-0 *1 -<,",1 ",-!; 6-0 ,",1< G :< ?12 ,0 ,0(1O 1," 2 *1.-!; K-*1018,-!H ?1 < KL 51-<>-+1 ,+ 1 /,-6-0 ,; ",10> = *10,+ 1 ,6 1 1 -!0 (1D< ,18,-!H *101 2-,<10 6 10,/+,L 1: , ,-7101, + 2 1, 1 6<-0; ,; K , 2-G1/ 6/-5?10>-!/ *1.! 6 < ,<1/ 0,; 0,51- -<>(181-,= + K?101-,0 < ,513,--1 :0 1 , ; -!H , + :< 1 ,/ 6 +*-*?1 1 != 1 , < 2 +,-7?1 1 -,+7 ,1 ",10 ! 51+," ,5?1-,+7 ,1-,, ,8 <1 :+ 2 >G1/,+ ; 2-G1-+?1-,H , !+7 ! ,51/ ,6,510+-(1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1 ,6 , 1 -<(11 (3E 33F9CA 7 1 W ,1 , 1 < <>51 ,-!H , + :<V1 331 7,H ; ,+(--+ 6,0 *(1%EE@(1Q1#(1

F6 <1 :1 -,H , !+7 ! >G1 :< 51 0+-1 *0+*-*1 1 5?1 ( (1 / : 1 1 / * 1 0+-1 ,+78-0,<1-+ *?1 ",1 -,"+-1 1 /,62 (1 = ><1 -/ ,<1 + " ; < ,-1 0+-1 0>-!/ 1 1 5191: , >51/, *6, 1

., < ,0 *?1-/,-, ,-71-,:6 0 71: , >?1 , <>1 1 < 1 ! ,; 0,6-0,0 7-*?1 ( (1/,66 = 0 71 = <1: , ,-(13 :!<-*?1 1 01/ ,8+,<?1 101-,*L <12 +,0 2-0 1 6 1-! H 1-,0; / 6 *1+ " < ,-1 1+ " +7 ,-19101: 0-<,-1, 1 / 1+ ; " < ,-(1 /,< <?12 ,101-, 2-,<1 ,-10>6 +*K 1-,+7 ,1 /,01+ " < ,-10+-111

;1 3 . 5 " B1 ,-,0 >51 1 6 H , >G1 H ,-*G1 , L-0 Y1

;1 , 3-% B1 -,:6 >51 0 ,51 ,6 >G1 <--1 01 -; +K2 +7 > ?1 -0 GP- -0 > 1 2-0 1/,+ 2-,",10,=; 6*?1, + 6 KL ",1+ 2 ><1 0 , ,<Y1

;15 5 % B1, !-+,0+ >51,/, ,510+-1 1,/ 6 ; + > 1 6 ,+," 2-1H ,-11

1565?1, !-+,0+ >51/, 6,51,6 ,51 :1/ , 0, ,-; 0!KL G1-, , 1S01" =6-,510,5 TY1

;1 35 51 . 5 356 "?1 ,1-71,. H +7 ,1 / : >51< =6! ,6 ><1-,, L-0,<1 16 (1

7 / 71 + " < ,-1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 ,/ 6 +*-*1 ! ,0 <1/ !=6 *?1-/,+7:! <,",16+*1!6 = *10+-1 1 ; + : H 1 /,+ ?1 6 ,+," 2-,",1 < /!+ ,0 *1 <--,0><1 -,: <?1-,H +7 ,51 / *= ,-1 1" =6-,",1 /,0 ,0 ; *1 1 (/(1 ,M ,<!1-71-<>-+1",0, 71,1., < +7 ,51+ " +7 ,-1 0+-?1 , -/ 2 ,51 /,6-,0 ,51 :!+7 ,010> , ,0?1-/,+7:,; 0 <1 6<-0 ,",1-!-?1 1/ 0,0,51+ " +7 ,-(12 1 : +*< 16,0 *1 1-! !10> , ,0?1-,5 , 12!0-0,?12 ,1, 1 G1 2 ",1 1: 0-?1 1-+ 6-0 191<--,0>51!-B1-0 6 ; +7-0!K 1,1. 2-,516 + " < : H 10+-(1

=3 656 1 5 10+-101-,0 < ,<1H 0 + :,0 ; ,<1, L-0 1, -/ 2 0-*16 <, 2-< 1 : +7 >< 1 / ,H 6! < 110-, L < ?1 0 >< ?1 5 >< ?1/ *<>< ?12->< 1 1 , ! >< (1 ,M ,<!1+ " < ,-716 <, 2-,510+-1 ,/ 6 +*K 101 2-0 13 . 5 5 &3 6565 811

1

!6!2 1 -., < ,0 ,5?1 + " +7 *1 0+-71 6 5-0! 1 1 ,-; ,0 1, > >G?1, ,-,0 >G?16,-!/ >G16+*1-0 6 *10-",1, ; L-0 1/ 0,0>G1 , <(1A+*1 1-0,5-0 1 G : H *1, 0 ; -0 ,-1 6,+= ,->G1 + H?1 ,/ 6 + 1 / 01 1 , *: ,-51 0-G1 !2-,01 / 0,, ,8 5Y1 , ,-+7 *1 - +7 ,-71 / 0,0>G1 , <1 1 G1 : 0-<,-71, 1+ 2 >G1,-, ,-51 ,-; + 51 0+-Y1 ,6 ,< ,-71 : , 1 91 ",1 6-0,1 6+*1 0-G(1 ,1 0-<1 M <1 ,-,0 *<1 + " +7 *1 0+-71 / , 0,-, 1 + " +7; ,5?1-+ 6,0 +7 ,?191/-!/ ,5?1,/ KL 5-*1 1-+!1 1/ , :; 0,+(1 8,-!H *1 + " + :! 1 ",-!6-0 !K1 0+-7?1 , 1 6 5-0 +7 ,-71 16 5-0 ,-7101 ,51< ?101 ,51 ,+78-; 0,1-+ *1 :6 +* 1 1H ,-1 1-+ 6! 101/,0-6 0 ,<1/,; 0 6 1 1 , < <(1 8 ,< 1 ,",?1 /,6+ >51 ,-!H , + :<1 , 6 + <1 , 1 + 8 *1 K , 1 0+-,51 -+K2 +7 ,-1 /,1/-, . H 1",-!6-0 ,510,+ (1

0,1-1<,< 1-0, ",1: ,=6 *1 >+,1/ :0 ,1 1!-+ 71 0+-71-+7 ,",?1 ,?1 , , , ?1," 2 71 (1 1-+!2 5 ,14-,; +71--< 0 +1/ 0,1 1/,+ 2-!K1-/ 0 6+ 0,-7(1

D-,2 1/ 012 +,0 191-<12 +,0 ?1 ",1/, ,-1 1 ;->?1 ",1, :1= : ?1 ",1/, ,-7101-0, ,6 1-<, + : ; H 1 1! 0 =6 101< 1+K6 51-0, ",12 +,0 2-,",16,-, ; -0 1 12-(17 <1= 12 +,0 1 10>-!/ 1 ,-+ <1M G1/ 0?1 /,6 0 =6 *1 <1-<><12 +,0 2-, ?1-,H +7 , ?1 1 1",-!6-; 0 , 1/ ,-G,=6 1/ 0 (1

7,H +7 , 1/ ,-G,=6 1/ 0 1,: 2 1 ",1/ 0 2 ,-71/,1 , ,8 K1 1",-!6-0!?1/! + 2 ,510+-(1E,-!6-0,1= 1S01-,; H +7 ,; ,6 , ,6 ,<1 , L-0 T1 0>-!/ 1 -!< ,<?1 -/,-,; ,<16,-= *1 1 + : H 1/ 0 ?1-,:6 ,",1, L-0,<(1 1-0*: 1 -1M <101-,0 < ,<1H 0 + :,0 ,<1, L-0 1 10 6!L 1<-,1 -6 10-G1,-+ 51/ 0 10>60 "-*12-, 1S01 ,<12-+ ?1 1" =; 6-, T1/ 0,?16 !" 1= 1,-+ 1/ 0 10>/,+ *K 1/,1, ,8 K1 1 <!10-/,<," +7 !K?1, -/ 2 +7 !K1 ,+7(1

71 M ,51 ,2 1 : *1 ,-!H , , 1 : , ,6 +7-0,1 < 78 10-",1<,= 1--< 0 7-*1 16 ,0 1/ 012 +,0 1 91, 1/ 6+ = 1 <!1, 1 ,=6 *?10> K 1 :1 ",1-!-1 1 2 +,0 (1E+ 0 , 101-,6 = 1 ,-!H , ,",1/ 0 1 1 ",1 ; "!+ !KL <10,:6 5-0 191M ,1-,:6 1 6+ = L G1,-,016 *;