Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

1, L <10 6 1 , !/H , > 1/-!/+ *191M ,1: / L ; > 1 !",+,0 >< 1 : , < 1 /,61 !" ,:,51 : *1 , L-0 ,1 ,/-> 16 * *?1-,0 8 <> 1/,-6-0,<1-/,+7:,0 *16,+=; ,->G1/,+ ,<,2 51 + 1 < KL ",-*1",-!6-0 ,",1-!-101 H +*G1+ 2 ,",1, ," L *1 + 1 :1 , >->G1/, !=6 5(1 6 ; +7 >51 : , 1 IF1 / , 0,6 5-0 1 , !/H J1 ,/ 6 +* 1 1 -+ 6!KL <1 , :,<11 I:+,!/, + 1 -+!= ><1 /,+,= <?1 6 2 1 0:* ?1 /,+!2 1 0:* ?1 ,<< 2-51 /,6 !/1 + ,1 , 1-/,+7:,0 1 . : 2-<1 + H,<1 -0, ",1 6,+= ,-,",1 /,+,= ; *10,/ 1: , ><1-<1, L-0 1 1",-!6-0 101H +*G1 /,+!2 *10>",6>1010 6 16 "?1H ,-5?1 ,",1 <!L-0 1 + 1 !-+!"1 <!L-0 ,",1 G ?1 >G1 / 01 6+*1 - *1 + 1 6+*1 7 G1+ H?1+ ,1 : , , 1/ 6,-0+ 1 ,510>",6>1! : ; ,<!1+ H!16 !" < 1 . : 2-< 1+ H < J(%1 0,0 6>1! :>0 K 1 1 -+,= ,-71 1 /,+ , !1 6 . H ?1 , , *1 1 !2 >0 1 0-G1 0 ,016 2 1 1/,+!2 *10:* ?16 5-0 5?1 1, *: +7 ,10 6!; L G1 1., < +7 ,<!1/,+!2 K1< +7 ,510>",6>?1: ,1-!+*L G1 ,0!K101 !6!L <1 1 (6(#17 ",6 *1 , !/H *1,G0 >0 1 ,+ 18 ; , 516 / :, 1/ 0, !8 5(1 1 ",10 +K2 K 110, ,0-0,?1 + 1 : , , 1/-0, 1, L-0 ,",1 <!L-0 1 + 1 / + Y1/ ; , =101 ! ,0 1 1",-!6-0 !K1 + 1<! H / +7 !K1 -+!= !?101-/ 6 + 1 K6= >G16,G,6,0?1I , ",0+K10+ * <J1 91, -/ 2 1: 16 7" 1/ * *10>",6 >G1 8 5?1: +K2 1 ",-!6-0 >G1 , ,01 01 -G1 ,/ 6 + >G1 + H1 + 1 ,</ 5Y16 2 1 1/,+!2 10:* ?1 1< ,", 16 !", (1 , ,51 , !/; H *1 -,-6-0! 1 -16 !" < 1/-!/+ *< ?1 1 G1 !6 ,1, 6 + 71 6 !"1, 16 !" Y101 , , >G1-+!2 *G1M+ < >1 , !/H 1/-!-; 0!K ?1 ,1 1*0+*K-*1,/ 6 +*KL < (1

O ,1 < ," > 1/,1-0, <!1-,6 = K1: , >Y1/ * 1 1! 0 =6 1/ 0,0>G1 ,01-1-/,+7:,0 <16 : ., < H 1 1 , < Y1 . +7-. H *1 :!+7 ,01 0> , ,01 1 . 6!<,0Y1 / 0,0,51/ , :0,+1, " ,01",-!6-0 ,510+-1 16,+= ,-; >G1+ HY1 !8 *1 ,-!H , ,",1/, *6 1: , ,6 +7 ,51 1/ 0,/ < +7 ,516 * +7 ,-(11

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17, 1: , ,6 +7-0 13 (1#$$&(1Q1)#1SW(1%T(17 (1F##&(1

#12A 67! 8 7D ., < H , *1 : 1/ , 0,6 5-0 *12 +,0 1 1, L-0 1 , !/H 1331 E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$$E(1Q1E(1

1

$

, >2 ,1 16 K 1/,2 1 ,",1 :!+7 ?1/, ,<!12 ,1 1<-1!-; >G1S := +,0 >G1 + 1 : >G?1 1018 T1/,*0+*K-*1 ,0> 1 : , 6>1 1 0><," + 1 0:* , (1 8 1 / 0 +,?1 H +7 , 1 / 0 +7-0,1 1 < 1-+16+*1 , +7 ,",1 , ,+*1 616 * +7 ,; -7K12 ,0 ,0?1/,M ,<!1, ,1, >2 ,16,0,+7-0!-*1/,66 = <1 , , ,51 I / <,51 , <>J1 , !/H ?1 /-*1 + 871 -6 +7; > 1 1,/-> 1., <>1 1/ ,*0+ *(1I ,.--, +7 !K1-+ ,-71 1 +7 !K1, ,0 ,-71",-!6-0 ,",1 // 1 12-!K1 0>",6!1 01 !-+,0 *G1 , .+ 1-,0?191 -2 1F(1A <-?191 -+ 6! 1 / : 71 0 = 58 51 !/ 0+ 2-,51 / , + <,51 -",6 *8; 513,--?10+ *KL 51 10-1-. >1, L-0 ,51= : 1 1!-!"! ; +*KL 516 5-0 1 *6 1 " 0 >G1. , ,0J(%11

1 *0+*-*1 / H 51 1 ,< 6 H *1 I8, 0 H 1 / , 01 , !/H J1SFF ?1#$$R1"(T1/,1-,:6 K1-/ H + : ,0 >G1",; -!6-0 >G1, " ,01/,1 , 7 1-1 , !/H 5?1-+!= 1-, -0 ; ,51 :,/-,-10,10-G10 6,<-0 G?1/,-,+7 !101/,-+ 6 10 ; <*1 !2-+-71 -,, L *1 ,1 6,+= ,->G1/-!/+ *G1,. H ; ,01!= 1-!L-0!KL G1-+!= (18 1 :0-,?1-,:6 1-+!= 1-, ; -0 ,51 :,/-,-101-+!= G1-, -0 ,51 :,/-,-191M ,1 / ,"--1 01 I6! !K1 -, 2 ,-7J(1 5K ,51 0 ! 0 6,<-0 ; >51 , ,+7?1 ,-, ,1 01 !-+,0 *G1 /, = *1 ",--! ! 1 H ; :<,<1 1 /,", 51 : 1 < +7 ><1 + ",/,+!2 <?1 : = ,?1 ,1 + 1/,:6 ,?1 2 1 !-,0 7?1-+!= 71 1: , !?1 10 6,<; -0 ,<!1 ! ,0,6-0!(1 , ,<!1/, 10 *61+ 1<,= ,1 6 * 7-*1 1 M..0 ,-71/ ,6,+ *1 , !/H 1-/,+ +7 ,510+-7K?1 0 ,1 1 16 !" < ?1., < +7 ,1, 1 1 : 0-<>< 1-! ! ; < ?1 ,1 1 6 + 1 , P 6 >< 1 -1 K1, L < 1/,+ 2-< 1 1 <!L-0 >< 1 -< (1 ?1 , < 2 1 7(4(1 A-,0?1 0 *61 + 1<,= ,1!/,0 71 1/ , ! ! !?1/,-,+7 !1IZ/, *6, 1 : ; 2 *1 16,+= ,-71/ , ! , ,01 1. 2-*1: 0-<,-71 G1, 1 / : 6-G1 -! ! ?1 1 = 1 , 1 " , +7 >G1 M+ ?1 6 + K 1 M 1, " >1/--0 >< ?1-+ 1 271: G,6 1,1 , !/H 1010>-8 G1 M8 +, G10+-J(#11

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1, D 9CA57618, !/H , 11 6 + 1/,+ ,<,2 <1 1,2 71,/-1331E,-!6-0 *1 -+!= (1#$$E(1Q1)(17(1'(1

#1,35A96F7 7, < ,0 1 , ,+7 ,510 0 1",-!6-0 ,510+-1 1," 2 1 , !/H 1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1#$$#(1Q1R(17(1%$(1

U , ,6 +7 , 100 6 1 1/ < 1/, * *1 : , ,; ",1 , ," L *1 : 2 +7 ,1 , + "2 1 !",+,0 , 1 /-+ 6,0 1 , !/H (1A+*1 ,",12 , >1,-!6 71 : , 6 1 10:* ,2 ?1 1 , *: +7 ,16, :>0 7?12 ,1, 1! +1 + 1/,+!2 +10:* (1 1,/ ; 6 + >G1, -,* +7-0 G16,-,2 ,16, : 7?12 ,16 , 16,+=; ,-, 1 + H,1 , + 6 1 <!L-0,<1 1 0 < ?1 / ,-G,=6 1 , , >G1, ,1 101-,-,* 1, P*-71+ " +7 >< 1-,2 < 1 6,G,6,0(1 1 + 8 < 1 !6! 1 1 < >1 ,/ 0 ,; ,:>-,",1 G ; 1/,10>*0+ K1-> ,",1 <!L-0 101-+!2 1-,< 5101 2-,-1 2 ,0 (1 1 , .-H 1 <!L-0 1 : 1 , ; !/H , > 1 /-!/+ *?1 / * *1 0,1 0-G1 H 0 + :,0 >G1 -G?1/,:0,+ + 10-7< 1 -!L-0 ,1 -: 71 G1! ,0 7(1D-; G,6*1 :1< ,0,51/ 1 1/ < +7 ,1 1 ,--5-<1!-+,0 ; *<10/,+ 1, ,-,0 ,1/ 6+,= 100-101 812",+,0 >51 ,; 6-1 -7K?1 / 6!-< 0 KL!K1 , 0-0 ,-71 : 1 1 :>; 0 <, 1 : , , 1, ," L ?1 ?1 / < ?101D + ?1"6 12 ; ,0 1 6,+= 1 !< 71 6, :>0 71 + " +7 ,-71 / , ,",1 <!L-0 191-0, ",1 1-0, 51-<7 (18-?1 1018 ?101-,, 0-; 0 1-,1-7 51RE)12",+,0 ,",1 ,6-1/ 1,2 0 6 ,<1/ 0>8 ; 1 -, -0 ,-1 1 -G,6,01 ",-!6-0 ,",1 , 1 61 ",1 : , >< 1 /,-!/+ *< ?1 <,= ,1 ,0 71 ! : *1 1 G1-,2 (1 1-+!2 1 !6,0+ 0, +7 ,",1, P*-*1-+!= L 51 <,= 1 > 71 : 1+ 8 <1-0, ,6>1 1-, 16,1)1+ Y1 : H 101 -!<< G1--< 0-*1 1 : , >516,G,6Y12-71-, -0 ,; -?1/ 0>8 KL *1: , !K?10:>-0-*(1

,-,+7 !12 <16 + ?1 <1 ,+ 1 , !/H *1/ , 1., ; <>1 :,L >G1< ,",G,6,0>G1 -G <1 -10+ * +7 ><1/ > <1 10-G1 G1M / G?1/,M ,<!1,-, ,10 = ,1-/,+7:,0 1M , ,; < 2-G1-/,-, ,01/ , 0,6 5-0 *?1, , >G1< ,6 1 ; + : 1 .-,0,51 6 * +7 ,-1 1 /,+!2 *1 6,-,0 ,51 ., ; < H 1,1 / 2 >G1/-!/ >G1,/ H *G(15 0 6 H *10,:<,= ,; -51 + " + : H 1 6,G,6,01 , 1 , !/H , ,51 6 * +7 ,-1 + 1 -!L-0 , 1,-+,= 10,:<,= ,-1/ < *1-G <1 G1+ " ; + : H 1-0 1/,61-,< 1H +-,, : ,-71-,0 8 *1 , ; !/H , >G1/-!/+ 5(11

C ," ?1 / 2 <1 , L / : ,?1 6 <, 2-1 ",-!6 ; -0 1-,: +7 ,1/,8+ 1 1 :0-, 1," 2 1/ :!</H 1 ;

1

$"

0 ,0 ,-16+*1",-!6-0 >G1-+!= L G100 6!15 51,/-; ,-1 , !/H 16+*1, L-0 (1,:<!L ><16 < "," <1S, ,-; +7 ,1 :> + <>G1/ 012 +,0 T1<,= ,1 /,< 7?12 ,12 +,0 ?1 /,-!/ *1 1 ",-!6-0 !K1 -+!= !?1 6,+= 1 > 71 : 2 +7 ,1 ", ,01 1 :0-,<!1!L <+ K1-0, G1/ 0(1D:0-,?12 ,1016 <,; 2-G1",-!6-0 G10-16,+= ,-> 1+ H 1 = ",6 ,1/,6 ; K 16 + H K1,16,G,6 G?101 , , >G1! :>0 K 1-!<<>1 1-,2; 16,G,6,01 1-G,6,0?10 +K2 *160 = <, 1 1 60 = <, 1 <!; L-0,(1 5K , 1 -,, 0-0 1 6,G,6,01 1 -G,6,01 6 1 / 0,1 / 6-0 +K1 +,",0>G1, " ,01: 6 0 712 ,0 !1-,, 0-; 0!KL 1 0,/ ,->(1 B-+ 1 2 ,0 ,01 / ,-,1 : >+1 ! : 71 : , ; >51-,2 16,G,6,0?1 / < ?1/,+!2 , 1-+ 6-0,?1, 1 ; -1, 0-0 ,-71: 1 !/+ !1 +,",0(1 1,-!-0 16, : ; +7-0 1 : , ,-1 6,G,6,01 0,: !=6-*1 !",+,0 , 1 6 +,1 /,1

. !1 : , ,",1 , ," L *(1 4/ ++*H *1 1 / :!</H 1 0 ; ,0 ,-1 + 1= 1 1<, +7 ,<!16,0,6!1,1: 0-101- -< 1H ,; ->G1 ,, 6 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 1 10,-/ <-*(11

8 1 0-7< 1 6 5-0 , 1 -6-0,1 , 7 >1 -1 6,+= ,->< 1 / 0, !8 *< 1 , ! ! 1 3 1 --< 0 1 1 :>0 ; <!K16-0 + . H K191 ( (1+ 8 1/ 0 1: < 71 ! ,0,6*; L!K16,+= ,-7101-,, 0-0!KL <1-/,+ +7 ,<1, " (17!; 6 *1 / 1 6,-,2 ,1 ! 6 +7 ,1 /, : + ?1 2 ,1 -1 /,6, ; ><1 /* ,<1 01 ," . 1 --2 >0 71 1 !-/ 8 !K1 7 !1 01 -. 1!/ 0+ *1!= 1 1/ G,6-*1 16-0 + . H *16+*1< ,; " G1 2 ,0 ,01 , :>0-*1", :6,1 ,+ 1 -! ,0><1 : <?1 2 <18 .1 + 1 , 1< +7 , 1+ 8 (1

7/ 0 6+ 0,1/ ,0,:"+ 8 1+,:! "1-,:6 *1 <,-. >10-; , L 51 / <,-1 1 , !/H ?10,, L 1/ 0,0,<!1 " + :<!(1 ,1/ 1M ,<1,-!-0!K 12 1 1*-> 1/ 6-0+ *1,1 ,<?12 ,1 /, <-*1/,61I <,-. ,51 / <,-J?1 1 < ,1< >1 1 -/,-, >1 , L-0 ,",1 0,:6 5-0 *1 ,+ 1 M..0 >1 1 / <+ <>(1 1 , 2-0 ,51 + ! 1 -->+ K-*1 1 ,/> 1 7X4?101 , , >G1 ,+ 1F$n1 :, + 2 >G101-10:* ,2 ,01 0>*0+ >1 /,1 /-7< <1 -+ *1 SI !6*L G-*JT1 01 -/ H +7 > 1 -+!= >1/,1 , 7 1-1 , !/H 5?1-,, L 08 G1,1. G1: 2 +7; ,",1 -G,=6 *1 , : 1 = : 1 2 ,0 1 1 0,:<,= ,-51 ",1 -+!= ,",1/,+,= *(18, 2 ,?1< +7 ,-71 8 ",1-+ *1

/, 1, K671 1< +7 ,-71 +,",/+ +7L ?1 ,?1<,= 1 > 7?1 -, 1 , 71 0 < 1 1 -,:6 ?1 0,--,0+ 1 +7 ,51 : 0-<,-1 -6-01<--,0,51 ., < H ?1 -/,-, >G1/ ,0,; 6 71 -<,-,* +7 , 1 --+ 6,0 1 . ,01 , !/H ?1 / =6 1 0-",101 G1-! ! G?1 , , > 1 <1 ,+ 1/,60 = >1 1-< 1 6,+= >1M <1: < 7-*(1

06 ?1 / 1 M ,<?1 2 ,?1 -, -0 ,?1 1 -,-0+* 1 / , + <!?1 0>-!/+ *1 7CD?1 + ?1 -= <?1 F L-0 ,51 / + >?1 6 !" G1 , " : H 51" =6-,",1, L-0 1 16,+= >1/,0-71010,:6!; G ?1/,+!2 71., < +7 > 1, /-1 + 10,, L 1: < +2 0 7-*(11

1 M ,<1 ,-1 :-+!= 0 1 0 < *1 / 6+,= 1 / ,;

.--, 134E71 (17, ,+,0 1,1 ,<?12 ,10-* , 1/! + 2 ,10>-: ; , 1-,< 101 !8 1: , ,0?1 , <1<, + 101, ,8 1",; -!6-0 >G1-+!= L G16,+= ,1--< 0 7-*1 1M 2-, 1 , 0 ?1 U 2 ?1 , ,1 6,+= ,1 0+ 271 : 1 -, ,51 , *: +7 , 1 , ; > , 1, P*-191I, !6 1!1 ",16 7" 1 1< ++ , > 1 >?1 01-+!1 G1/ 2 1 ",1-> 10+ 6 1," ,< ><1-,-,* <?1/,2 ; <!1,6 1 1 1= 1. < 1/,+!2 1, 1 ",1",-!6-0 > 1: :>J1 1 (6(1 1 (/(%171M ,51 6 510/,+ 1-,"+-!-*16 5-0!KL *101 ,; , >G1 -G1 , < 1 !",+,0 ,",1 / 0 1 ,1 , .-H 1 dm1 cl`1 91 , .-H ?1/ 1 , , ,51 <*16, :>0 *1: , ,-1/ , ; *1 <!L-0 1/ ,- -*1 1 ",10+ 6 +7H 1S01-+!2 ?1 ,"6 1 0,: K 1 6,-,2 > 1 ,-,0 *1/,+ " 7?12 ,1, ,1/,+!2 ,101 :!+7 1 , !/H , >G16 5-0 5T(1U , ,6 +7 , 100 6 1 1 / < 1/, * *1 : , ,",1, ," L *1: 2 +7 ,1, + "; 2 1!",+,0 , 1/-+ 6,0 1 , !/H (1A+*1 ,",12 , >1,-!6 71 : , 6 1 10:* ,2 ?1 1, *: +7 ,16, :>0 7?12 ,1, 1! +1 + 1/,+!2 +10:* (1 1,/ 6 + >G1, -,* +7-0 G16,-,2 ,1 6, : 7?1 2 ,1 6 , 1 6,+= ,-, 1 + H,1 , + 6 1 <!L-0,<1 1 0 < ?1/ ,-G,=6 1 , , >G1, ,1 101-,-,* 1, P*-71 + " +7 >< 1-,2 < 16,G,6,0(1

10>:>0 1-,< *1 6 *1,1 , G,6 <,-10 6 *1 ,; 6-,01M 2-,",1/,0 6 *1",-!6-0 >G1 1<! H / +7 >G1 -+!= L G?1 < KL G1 -+!1 , < 0 ,;/ 0,0>G1 ,0?1/,6 /; + >G16 * +7 ,-7K1-/ H +7 >G1 ,<--51/,1--+ 6,0 K1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%16C6 6F7'13,+71, L-0 101 , .+ 1-,01331E,-!6-0 *1-+!= (1#$$&(1Q1)(1

1

$