Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1
;1 !8 1 / 01 2 +,0 ?1 G1 1 / 0,1 1 = : 7?1 2-7?16,-,-0,?1 <!L-0,?1 :,/-,-7Y1-+ *1/ 0,0 *1 : L L ,-71 2 +,0 1 : = ,1 /,6 >0 1 0 !1 01 : , ?1 -/,-, ,-71 ",-!6-0 1 /,66 = 0 71 / 0,/, *6, ?1 ," =; 6 71 +K6 51 , 1 /-!/ >G1 /,-*" +7-0Y1 2-*1 -, -0 ; ,-71 !1 -1 /, ,51 -!L-0! 1 2-,1 ,< +7 ,11 -+ 1 01 I+ ; G GJ16 0* ,->G1/ 6/ < + 1, + " +-71I6 7KJ1 6 ; < ?1 ,1 /,-/ ,1 I-**J1 S!",+,0 *T1 I >8 J1 -+ 1 -< ; * 7-*1I-,5J?1 ( (10><," +7-0,<1-,1-, , >1-+,0>G1 1 6<-0 >G1 -! ! (1 ,1 = 1 -<, 1 56-0,1 91 : ; , >51 : G0 1 2!=,51 -, -0 ,-1 91 0,:<,= ,1 :1 0; ,",1!2-*101 <1 , !</ ,0 >G12 ,0 ,0?1-!6 5?1< ; + H , ,0(1
;1 , H?1<,= ,1",0, 71,1 , 2-,51., < 1/ 0,0,",1 " + :< 191 -,+K : H 101/ 0 1 +--,0,",1/,6G,6 1 + 1/ ; !=6 *1S , , , 191: !8 0>0 *1-,H +7 ,",1 0-0 1 1 /,+," 1-,H +7 ,",1 ,</ ,<--T?1-0 6 *1/ 0 1 1 , < (1 F-, ,10>6 + <1G !K16,1-G1/, 16+*1 ,--5-,51< +7; ,-1/,6< !1/ 0,0,",1 "!+ ,0 *1 K 6 2-<1<, ; + :<,<?1/ 6-0+*KL <1/ 0,10 , ,-/ ><?1 : 2 +7 ><1 -/,-, ,<1-,H +7 ,51 "!+*H (1 1<--,0,<1/ 0,-,: 1: ,; !1 / , 0,/,-0+*K-*1 1 :>0 <> 1 I/, * *J1 91 !+7 1 I/ 06>J1 / :0 1 ,</-,0 71 -G1 + 1 0 ,6!8 1 / 61 : , ,<?1,. H +7 ><1/ 0,<(13 . ,0 > 1 , 1 / +; + !K 1 1 : 2 +7 ,51 0,-/ <2 0,-1 !--<1 ,6,<12!=; 6,",1 0 ,/ 5-,",1/ 0 ?1 !+7 0 !KL ",1M",-2-,",?1-; 2 + 0,",1< L (1 ?1/,1< K1-+ 0* ,. +,0?1 !--512 ; +,0 1 , + 2-*1 -, , ,-7K?1 ,++ 0 :<,<?1 < +,-6 <1 1 (/(17K= 1 : >5?1 ,1016 ,<1 ,-1:-0+* 10-/,< 71 -G, 0, > 1 -,2 1 /,M ;K<,-1 ( (1 4+< :,0 1 01 ! ,; 0 ,5?1 ,1/,1-!L-0!10 ,51., < 1/ 6 KL ",1-! 71/,6G,6 1 -+ 0* ,. +,01 1/ 0!11
11
1 ,1/ 2 <1, " 2-<1 1C>1-,0-<1 1- = >1 1U6 0><1-<>-+,<1K 6 2-<?1 17 <1-2 67 <1->(1 1
1
#
1 1
1X , 1 ! >1 !--?1 1 8 51/ 06>1 6 +1 1 10+ : 101., <>1!: 1
14 6 2-G1 2 +Z1
11
F , , ,51-, , ,51/ 0,0,",1 " + :< 10>-!/ 1/ 0,; 0,51 6 + :<?1 : +K2 KL 5-*1 01 0 ,51 0 1 0,1 0- -+7 ,-71 / 0 ?101/ ,H 1 ",10,:<,= ,-51 1-!< 1 "!+*H 1 S-1 :0->< 1,-,0 *< 1 ",1<,= ,1--< 0 71 1 1/ 0,; 0,51 . 8 :<?1 1 1 / 0,0,51 :<T(1 / < ?1 01 / <* 1 -8 G1/, ,+ 51 ,--5-,",1, L-0 1= 0>10,-/,< *1,1 G10 < G?1 ,"6 1/ < +-71 : ,, : > 1I-, 2-J?1 I-!67 , ,-> J1 1IM/,G +7 > J1/+ >?1 8 *?1/,-,0+ *?1 / 0+ > 1 1I6 +7 58 1 :0 J?1I/,0>8 J?1I!-, ; J?1I-,0 8-0,0 J1 1 (/(1 G,0 *10+-716 <,-,; 0 + 1-0,K1<!6 !K1, 2-!K1: , !1, 1, L <1 + " ?1 ,610/ 6 +1 01 + = !K1M5., K10 >101I-0 +, 1 !6!L J?1/ 1M ,<1 2 ",1 1< *+,-71 101+ 2 ,<1/,0 6 ?1 101, L-0 >G1, ,8 ; *G(1O !1 6 H K1-+ /,510 >1012!6,6 5-0 !K1-+!1: , 1 / ,6,+= + 1!= 1 ,--5-*10+-7101 2 1E$;G1",6,0?1/,-/ 8; ,1/ < *1! :>?1: , >?1, 6 +7 > 1K 6 2-1 , <>?1 , ,; > 1 >+ 1: 0 6,<,1 0>/,+ <>1S2 :1Q1%1 : 6 1IF1/ ; 0,,2 6 >G1< G1/,1 :0 K1, :,0 *10137 73J?12 :1IF1 , 7 1 -1 , !/H 5J?1 IF-,0>1 : , ,6 +7-0 1 ,1 !+7 ! J1 1 (6(T(1 U , ,6 +7-0,1 I: " +,J1 0/ 61 01 H /H 1 S: <-0,; 0 T?1/ 2 <1/,0 G ,-,51 1 "+! , ,5?1: / 6 >G1/,+ ,; / 0,0>G1-! ,0?1 , <1 1H ,-5?1 1, 0 2 KL G1M , ,< ; 2-<?1/,+ 2-<?1/-G,+," 2-<1 1 !+7 ! ><1!-+,0 *<1 3,--(11
1 <1-<><1/ ,-G,6 + 16-6 H *1 16 0 +70 H *1: , ,01 1 / 0 ?1 ,-, ,1 ,"6 1 : , >1 :6 0 +-71 01 /,/!+- -G1 + 1 , PK ! >G1H +*G?1 1 8 *1/ , + <>1/,1-!L-0!?1 ,1: ", **1 G10"+! 7(17 ",6 *1-! H *1-+ 1< * 7-*1 1+!28 <!?1 ,?1/,-,+7; !1/ 0,0,51 6 + :<1-0*: 1 L 1 1-1 : >0 ,510 ,510,10-<,"!; L-0,1/ 0,",1+ H 1",-!6-0 ?1 1 >1, ,1,. H +7 ,1 1 < ,; 0 +,-71SH 7?1" +7 >51-7?1/ : 6 T?1 ,101!-+,0 *G1-,; G *KL 5-*1013,--1/-, + : H 10+-1, 1/ ,*0+*-*101-,; H +7 ,<1 =6 0 2-0 ?1/,+ 2-,51/--0 ,-1 1 ,<!1/,6, ;
1 #!
>G1*0+ *G(1 ,-/ , :0,6*1",-!6-0 >51/ + :<101, ,; 8 *G10+-1 1, L-0 ?1/ 0,0,51 6 + :<1 : = ,1, , 2 ; 0-*1 :,2 ,0 <10,10-G1" 6 ,: >G1/+ G1 1/ , G?1 <1 -<><1!6, * 1/,20!16+*16 +7 58 ",1 ,-1 " +-2-,",1, ; ,8 *1 10+-1 1: , !(1
1 , -!=6 1 0,/ ,-1 ,1 < G1 1 -/,-, G1 / ,6,+ *1 / 0,0,",1 " + :< 1, >2 ,1! :>0-*16 0 ,1 :0->51 , 1 ,< 6 H 51., < +7 ,",?1 ,1-71 --,6 = +7 ,",1G ; (1 / < ?1 !6 ,1-/, 71-1/,= + *< 1/,0>8 71 2-0,1 K 6 2-,",1, :,0 *?1 1-+ *?1 2 *1-,18 ,+>?1 1 1 0 + . H ,0 >G1K-,0(1 ,1!-0, 1/ 0,0,51 ., < ; H 101/ 0!K1,2 671-<!+ !-*16 5-0 ,-7K1/ < *1 K 6 2-G1 : 5?1 ,1 -71 G1 +7 ,51 0,- ,0 ,-7K1 01 = : (1 O ,1 ,: 2 1 -,0 8-0,0 1 / 0,/ < +7 ,51 / 191, -/ 2 1: , ,-1 1/ 0,/, *6 1 10-G1! ,0; *G1/! + 2 ,510+-1 1 10-51 , 1",-!6-0 ?1 0-; 0 1/ 61-!6,<1 1: , ,<10-G1" =6 1 :, ,-+7 ,1 1 G1-,; H +7 ,<!1 1 6,+= ,-,<!1 /,+,= K(1 1 , 7 1 -1 /-!/ ,; -7K1 , G,6 <,1 0 , 1-/,+7:,0 1< =6! ,6 ,",1/ ; H / 11+K ,<!1-8 K10,:<,= ,-51 : : ,51/-!/; ,-16,+= ,1 > 71/ , 0,/,-0+ ,1-8 10,:<,= ,-51 1 -/,-, ,-51 01 < G1 : , 1 --+ 6,0 71 1 :>0 71 / ; -!/ , 1/,0 6 (1
>/!-1K-,01013,--1," ,< ><1 ,+ 2-0,<1, :,0 ; +7 >G1-! ! 101/,-+ 6 1",6>16,-" 1%)$1 >-*212 +,0 101 ",6(18 2-0,1 G1/,6", ,0 ?1/,1,H 1-<,",1K 6 2-,",1-,; , L-0 ?1 ,+78 512-7K1 !6,0+ 0, +7 ,(1 1 > 1 !6 1 6 +,16,G,6 16,1 ,",?12 ,1 , ,6 + 1, :>0 101/ < ?1-; G,6*1 ,+7 ,1 :1 :0 *1!2 ,",1: 0 6 *1 1 ",1-+,= 08 5-*?1 5 1 : ,5?1 /! H (1
, 0,6 5-0 1/ 0,0,<!1 " + :<!1 0 ,< 2-1,: ; 2 1! /+ 1/ 0,0>G1 2 +10-G1-, , 1= : 6 * +7 ,-1 ,--5-,",1 , L-0 (1 ,M ,<!1 , G,6 <,?1 ,/ *-71 1 != 1 < KL-*1 :!+7 >?16, 0 7-*11
911/ *<,",16 5-0 *18,-!H 1 10 G,0-0 1/ 0 1 61 : , ,<1 1+K >< 1 , < 0 >< 1 < ?16 !" < 1-+,0 < ?1/ ; 0 L *18,-!H 101-6-0,1-,H +7 ,",1!/ 0+ *Y1
1
#"
1 |
1 |
911 + : H 1/ H / 1 G : H 1/-, +7 ,51, 0-; 0 ,-16,+= ,->G1+ H?1,2 L *10+-,51M+ >1, 1 , !/; H , ,0Y1
91 1 / * *1 / 1 : , ,01 ,1 " =6-,<1 , ,+ 1 61
,-/ 2 <1/ 012 +,0 101: > >G1 1/,+!: > >G1!2 =; 6 *G10-G1 /,0Y1
91100 6 *1-! 1/ + <-,",1--+ 6,0 *Y1
91 1 / 6 *1 -!6 ,51 - -< 1 +7 ,51 : 0-<,-1 , 1-/,+ +7 ,51 1: , ,6 +7 ,510+-1/ 1!-+ 1 , ,+*1 61-< <1-!6,<Y1
91 1 :0 *1 <-,",1 -<,!/ 0+ *1 -1 !-+ <1 ",1 . ;-,0,51-<,-,* +7 ,-1 1 ,+ 1 ,6 ,",10,+ :P*0+ *Y11
911 8 +7 ,",1 ., < ,0 *1/ 0,,G +7 >G1, " ; ,0?1 1-0,6 <,",1 1/ < ,0 K1< + H 101/,+ H K?1 ,1: ; " 0 KL ",1 1 6 !" 1 -+,0> 1 -! ! >?1 01 / 0!K1 ,2 671 7 (17 G1/ 61< + H 51S/,+ H 5T16,+= 1-< 7-*16,0 ; <1 1 <?1 ,1I-+!= 1 1: L L J(1
,6, ,1 ,+ 1/ 0,0>G1, ,8 5101- -< 10-G1, L-; 0 >G1 , ,8 5?1 / 0,-,: 1 .! H , ! 1 01 -! ! 1
,L-0 ,",1-,: *1 16!G,0 ,",1/ , :0,6-0 ?10+ **1 16 !; " 1 ., <>1 , L-0 ,",1 -,: *1 1 -/> >0 *1 , , 1 0,:; 6 5-0 (1-101/ 0!K1,2 671-! 10: <,6 5-0 1/ 0 1 1/ 0,-,: *1-16 !" < 10 6 < 1 , < 0 ,;H ,-,",1 "!; + ,0 *1, L-0 >G1, ,8 5(1
1
25 35 " 165&35 "1 1 1?1
%(18 ,0 1 ,+71/ 0,-,: *101/ 0 1 1, L-0 1 01H +,<V1
#(18 11! ,0 11 1., <>1<,= ,10>6 + 7101/ ; 0,-,: V1
R(1W <1 , + 2 K-*1 1 ,--5-*1 1 0 ,/ 5-*11 / 0,0 *111< +7 ,-7V1
@(1>6 + 1,-,0 > 1M+ < >1/ 0,0,51/-G,; +," (1
)(1F/ 6 + 1G 1/ 0,0,51 6 ,+," ?10>; = ,5101 ,--5-,<1: , ,6 +7-0 (1
1 |
## |
1
3!233 D3B3 C E &3
1
1
,+78 512-7K1 : >0 !K1-0*:71/ 0 1 10+-1!-< ; 0 K 101. 1, -/ 2 ,-1",-!6-0,<1/ !6 +7 ,51-+>1 / 0 ?1 ( (1",-!6-0,1*0+*-*1H +7 ><1-! ,<1/,+ ; ?10G,6*101,/ 6 + 1 1-!L ,-1 1 , 7 >1: 1",-!6-0 ; !K1 0+-7(1 -2 1 / 0 1 1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 6 1 -,0/ 6 1 , L G1 6+*1 G1 ", 511 I: , ,-7J?1 I/-!/; ,-7J?1I0+-7J?1I = <J1 1 (6(1 1M ,<1-<>-+ 1 1-+!2 5 ,12-; , 1 !/, + 1 G >G1 -+,0,-,2 51 91 /,+ ,; K 6 2-10:"+*6>?1/,+ ,;/ 0,0,51 = <(1
1 < G1 K 6 2-,",1 , < 0 :< 1 - -0 ><1 / 6; -0+*-*1 ! 0 =6 ?1 2 ,1 ,+7 ,1 ",-!6-0,1 01 -,-,* 1 , -/ 2 712 :1< G :<10+-1 1!/ 0+ *1 + : H K1 6 ; >G?1 , L , *: +7 >G?1 -,",1 ,/ 6 + >G1 , <10: <,, ,; 8 51 1 /,0 6 *1 01 ",-!6-0 ,;, " :,0 ,<1 S-+ 6,0 ; +7 ,?1 -,H +7 ,; ,6 , ,6 ,<T1 , L-0 ?1 !8 1 , , >G1 0+ 2 1 !1 + 1 !K1< !10,:6 5-0 *(1 1 ,<1, L-0 1/ 0,1 1 ,+7 ,1/,66 = 0-*1 1, -/ 2 0-*1",-!6-0,<?1 ,1 1-<,1 /,66 = 0 1 1, -/ 2 0 1 ",(1 <1-<><1/ 0,101., < 1: ,; ,6 +7-0 1 0> = 1 H ,-> 1 ,-,0 *1 ",-!6-0 ,51 /,+ ?1 /,-6-0 ,1 "!+ ! 1 6 * +7 ,-71 ",-!6-; 0 >G1, " ,01 1-,:6 1!-+,0 *16 * +7 ,-1/,+ 2-G1, ; " : H 5(1
,1 , ,8 K1 1 ",-!6-0 ,51 0+-1 -/ H . 1 / 0 1 : +K2-*101 "!+*H 1-,H +7 >G1-,012 :1/ :<!1/ ; *: +7 ,;, *: +7 >G1, ,8 51< =6!1+K67< 1 1-,H +7 >; < 1-! < ?1 ,"6 1 101/,+ 1 1/ 0>51/+ 10>G,6* 1, ; ,8 *10+-,51 1/,60+-,510,+71S6,< ,0 191/,62 ; T(1
W ,1 = 1 , 1 0+-7V1 8 1 -,H ,; !+7 ! >51 . ,< 1 , 1 < ,",< ?1 -+,= 1 1 ,6 ,: 2 (1 +-7?1 /,1 -0, <!1 / 6 ; : 2 K?1 0>-!/ 1 <,L 58 <1 -6-0,<1 !/ 0+ *1 1 "!;
1
$$