Измеренные упрощенные направляющие сравнивались с моделью САПР, а также сравнивалась точность 3D-принтеров. Исследователи пришли к следующему выводу: при сравнении моделей САПР и 3D-печатных частей упрощенных направляющих имплантатов наблюдались значительные различия в точности. 3D-принтеры PolyJet и SLA соответствовали требуемой точности для клинических применений в стоматологии. Однако наиболее подходящий 3D-принтер должен быть выбран с учетом всех обстоятельств конкретной клинической ситуации (состояние пациента, оборудование клиники, навыки врача и т. д.).
Таким образом, 3D-печать обладает рядом преимуществ, которые позволяют ей конкурировать с традиционными методами изготовления моделей и даже вытеснять их. К таковым преимуществам относится высокая точность, что является ключевым фактором в эффективности проводимого лечения и позволяет повсеместно использовать данные модели в клинической практике; сокращение времени операции; высокие эстетические качества; перспектива развития персонализированной медицины, что является ключевой целью современной медицины; простота использования и возможность создания объектов различной сложности.
Все это способствует использованию данной технологии в диагностике и лечении стоматологических заболеваний всех направленностей. Перечисленные преимущества стимулируют создание новых и совершенствование старых моделей 3D-принтеров и программ печати. Следовательно, внедрение трехмерной печати в стоматологию позволяет улучшить качество оказываемой пациенту медицинской помощи.
Список литературы
1. Аствацатрян Л.Э., Гажва С.И. 2017. Современные аспекты использования 3D- технологий в изготовлении съемных зубных протезов. Современные проблемы науки и образования, (5): 194.
2. Визер Ю.Ю., Елали А.Х. 2017. Технологии 3D-печати в медицине и стоматологии. Естественнонаучные основы медико-биологических знаний, с. 114-116.
3. Донских Д.А. 2017. Использование 3D-принтера в стоматологии. Бюллетень медицинских Интернет-конференций, 7 (1): 401.
4. Дьяченко Д.Ю., Гаврикова С.В., Михальченко Д.В.,. Михальченко А.В. 2015. Применение 3D-печати в стоматологии для изготовления провизорных ортопедических конструкций. Электронный научно-образовательный вестник здоровье и образование в XXI веке, 17 (3): 5-7.
5. Зотова А.А., Вдовенко К.Д. 2015. Актуальность применения 3D-принтеров в современной стоматологии. Бюллетень медицинских Интернет-конференций, 5 (11): 1284.
6. Коровкина В.С. 2018. Применение 3D-печати и 3D-сканирования в стоматологии. Физика и медицина: создавая будущее, с. 256-258.
7. Лазаренко В.А., Иванов С.В., Иванов И.С., Объедков Е.Г., Беликов Л.Н., Объедкова Н.Ю., Денисенко А.И. 2018. Использование 3D-принтеров в хирургии (обзор литературы). Курский научно-практический вестник «Человек и его здоровье», (4): 61-65.
8. Милев Минко Милчев, Симов Максим Иванов, Ангелова Светлана Пенева, Великова Валентина Степанова 2017. Применение 3D-технологий в эстетической дентальной медицине. Научные исследования: векторы развития, с. 50-53.
9. Митин Н.Е., Захарова И.В., Перминов Е.С., Калиновский С.И. Исследование влияния иммедиат-протезов с амортизирующей промежуточной частью на репарацию костной ткани в постэкстракционный период и остеоинтеграцию имплантатов в области резцов верхней челюсти. Клиническая стоматология. 2019. 2 (90): 80-82.
10. Чевычелова О.Н., Зубкова А.А. 2019. Реализация 3D-сканирования и 3D-печати в ортопедической стоматологии. Приемущества и недостатки. World Science: Problems and Innovations, с. 239-241.
11. Шустова В.А., Шустов М.А. 2016. Применение 3D-технологий в ортопедической стоматологии. Санкт-Петербург, Общество с ограниченной ответственностью «Издательство «СпецЛит», с. 159.
12. Abduo Jaafar and Karl Lyons. 2013. Rationale for the Use of CAD/CAM Technology in Implant Prosthodontics. International Journal of Dentistry, p. 1-8.
13. Abduo Jaafar, Karl Lyons and Mohammed Bennamoun. 2014. Trends in Computer-Aided Manufacturing in Prosthodontics: A Review of the Available Streams. International Journal of Dentistry p. 1-15.
14. Anderson J., Wealleans J. and Ray J. 2018. Endodontic Applications of 3D Printing. International Endodontic Journal. Blackwell Publishing Ltd 51(9): 1005-1018.
15. Brown Gregory B., G. Frans Currier, Onur Kadioglu and J. Peter Kierl. 2018. Accuracy of 3-Dimensional Printed Dental Models Reconstructed from Digital Intraoral Impressions. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 154 (5): 733-39.
16. Chan Hsun Liang, Kelly Misch and Hom Lay Wang. 2010. Dental Imaging in Implant Treatment Planning. Implant Dentistry 19 (4): 288-98.
17. Chen Jianyu, Zhiguang Zhang, Xianshuai Chen, Chunyu Zhang, Gong Zhang and Zhewu Xu. 2014. Design and Manufacture of Customized Dental Implants by Using Reverse Engineering and Selective Laser Melting Technology. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 112 (5): 1088-1095.
18. Choi Jong Woo and Namkug Kim. 2015. Clinical Application of Three-Dimensional Printing Technology in Craniofacial Plastic Surgery. Archives of Plastic Surgery. Korean Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons 42(3): 267-277.
19. Dawood Andrew, Susan Tanner and lain Hutchison. 2013. Computer Guided Surgery for Implant Placement and Dental Rehabilitation in a Patient Undergoing Sub-Total Mandibulectomy and Microvascular Free Flap Reconstruction. Journal of Oral Implantology 39 (4): 497-502.
20. Dodziuk Helena. 2016. Applications of 3D Printing in Healthcare. Kardiochirurgia i Torakochirurgia Polska. Termedia Publishing House Ltd 13(3): 283-293.
21. Ishida Yoshiki and Taira Miyasaka. 2016. Dimensional Accuracy of Dental Casting Patterns Created by 3D Printers. Dental Materials Journal 35 (2): 250-56.
22. Jeong Yoo Geum, Wan Sun Lee and Kyu Bok Lee. 2018. Accuracy Evaluation of Dental Models Manufactured by CAD/CAM Milling Method and 3D Printing Method. Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics 10 (3): 245-51.
23. Kalman Les. 2018. 3D Printing of a Novel Dental lmplant Abutment. Journal of Dental Research, Dental Clinics, Dental Prospects 12 (4): 299-303.
24. Kasparova Magdalena, Lucie Grafova, Petr Dvorak, Tatjana Dostalova, Ales Prochazka, Hana Eliasova, Josef Prusa and Soroush Kakawand. 2013. Possibility of Reconstruction of Dental Plaster Cast from 3D Digital Study Models. BioMedical Engineering Online 12 (1).
25. Kim Taehun, Sangwook Lee, Bae Kim, Dayeong Hong, Jinhee Kwon, Jae-woo Park and Namkug Kim. 2019. Accuracy of a Simplified 3D Printed Implant Surgical Guide. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry S0022-3913(19)30416-0.
26. Lee Keun-Young, Jin-Woo Cho, Na-Young Chang, Jong-Moon Chae, Kyung-Hwa Kang, Sang-Cheol Kim and Jin-Hyoung Cho. 2015. Accuracy of Three-Dimensional Printing for Manufacturing Replica Teeth. The Korean Journal of Orthodontics 45 (5): 217.
27. Liu Qingbin, Ming C. Leu and Stephen M. Schmitt. 2006. Rapid Prototyping in Dentistry: Technology and Application. The lnternational Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 29 (3-4): 317-35.
28. Louvrier A., P. Marty, A. Barrabe, E. Euvrard, B. Chatelain, E. Weber, and C. Meyer. 2017. How Useful Is 3D Printing in Maxillofacial Surgery? Journal of Stomatology, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. Elsevier Masson SAS 118(4): 206-212.
29. Martins Leandro Moura, Fabio Cesar Lorenzoni, Alcides Oliveira de Melo, Luciana Mendonga da Silva, Jose Luiz G. de Oliveira, Pedro Cesar Garcia de Oliveira and Gerson Bonfante. 2012. Internal Fit of Two All-Ceramic Systems and Metal-Ceramic Crowns. Journal of Applied Oral Science 20 (2): 235-40.
30. Miyazaki T. and Y. Hotta. 2011. CAD/CAM Systems Available for the Fabrication of Crown and Bridge Restorations. Australian Dental Journal 56 (SUPPL. 1): 97-106.
31. Moser Norman, Petra Santander and Anja Quast. 2018. From 3D Imaging to 3D Printing in Dentistry - a Practical Guide. International Journal of Computerized Dentistry 21 (4): 345-56.
32. Nayar Sanjna, S. Bhuminathan and Wasim Bhat. 2015. Rapid Prototyping and Stereolithography in Dentistry. Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences. Medknow Publications 7(1): 216-219.
33. Neumeister Andre, Linda Schulz and Christoph Glodecki. 2017. lnvestigations on the Accuracy of 3D Printed Drill Guides for Dental lmplantology. lnternational Journal of Computerized Dentistry 20 (1): 35-51.
34. Oberoi Gunpreet, Sophie Nitsch, Michael Edelmayer, Klara Janjic, Anna Sonja Muller and Hermann Agis. 2018. 3D Printing-Encompassing the Facets of Dentistry. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology. Frontiers Media S.A. 6: 172.
35. Rhee Ye Kyu, Yoon Hyuk Huh, Lee Ra Cho and Chan Jin Park. 2015. Comparison of Intraoral Scanning and Conventional Impression Techniques Using 3-Dimensional Superimposition. Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics 7 (6): 460-67.
36. Salmi Mika, Kaija Stiina Paloheimo, Jukka Tuomi, Jan Wolff and Antti Makitie. 2013. Accuracy of Medical Models Made by Additive Manufacturing (Rapid Manufacturing). Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery 41 (7): 603-9.
37. Shah Pratik and B.S. Chong. 2018. 3D Imaging, 3D Printing and 3D Virtual Planning in Endodontics. Clinical Oral Investigations. Springer Verlag 22(2): 641-654.
38. Sinn Douglas P., Joseph E. Cillo and Brett A. Miles. 2006. Stereolithography for Craniofacial Surgery. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery 17 (5): 869-75.
39. Tahayeri Anthony, Mary Catherine Morgan, Ana P. Fugolin, Despoina Bompolaki, Avathamsa Athirasala, Carmem S. Pfeifer, Jack L. Ferracane and Luiz E. Bertassoni. 2018. 3D Printed versus Conventionally Cured Provisional Crown and Bridge Dental Materials. Dental Materials 34 (2): 192-200.
40. Wang Chen and Lin. 2019. A Collaborative and Ubiquitous System for Fabricating Dental Parts Using 3D Printing Technologies. Healthcare 7 (3): 103.
41. Wang Ning, Jie Li, Xiaolong Wang, Gang Liu and Bin Liu. 2015. 3D Printing Personalized Implant Manufactured via Fused Deposition Modeling: An Accuracy Research. Hua Xi Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. West China Journal of Stomatology 33 (5): 509-12.
42. Zhang Hui Rong, Le Feng Yin, Yan Li Liu, Li Yi Yan, Ning Wang, Gang Liu, Xiao Li An and Bin Liu. 2018. Fabrication and Accuracy Research on 3D Printing Dental Model Based on Cone Beam Computed Tomography Digital Modeling. Hua Xi Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. West China Journal of Stomatology 36 (2): 156-61.
References
1. Astvacatrjan L.Je., Gazhva S.I. 2017. Sovremennye aspekty ispol'zovanija 3D-tehnologij v izgotovlenii s"emnyh zubnyh protezov [Modern aspects of using 3D technologies in the manufacture of removable dentures]. Sovremennye problemy nauki i obrazovanija, (5): 194.
2. Vizer Ju.Ju., Elali A.H. 2017. Tehnologii 3D-pechati v medicine i stomatologii [3D printing technologies in medicine and dentistry]. Estestvennonauchnye osnovy mediko-biologicheskih znanij, s. 114-116.
3. Donskih D.A. 2017. Ispol'zovanie 3D-printera v stomatologii [Using a 3D printer in dentistry]. Bjulleten' medicinskih Internet-konferencij, 7 (1): 401.
4. D'jachenko D.Ju., Gavrikova S.V., Mihal'chenko D.V., Mihal'chenko A.V. 2015. Primenenie 3D-pechati v stomatologii dlja izgotovlenija provizornyh ortopedicheskih konstrukcij [The use of 3D printing in dentistry for the manufacture of orthopedic structures]. Jelektronnyj nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj vestnik zdorov'e i obrazovanie v XXI veke, 17 (3): 5-7.
5. Zotova A.A., Vdovenko K.D. 2015. Aktual'nost' primenenija 3D-printerov v sovremennoj stomatologii [Relevance of 3D printers in modern dentistry]. Bjulleten' medicinskih Internet-konferencij, 5 (11): 1284.
6. Korovkina V.S. 2018. Primenenie 3D-pechati i 3D-skanirovanija v stomatologii [Application of 3D printing and 3D scanning in dentistry]. Fizika i medicina: sozdavaja budushhee, s. 256-258.
7. Lazarenko V.A., Ivanov S.V., Ivanov I.S., Ob"edkov E.G., Belikov L.N., Ob"edkova N. Ju., Denisenko A.I. 2018. Ispol'zovanie 3D-printerov v hirurgii (obzor literatury) [Using 3D printers in surgery (literature review)]. Kurskij nauchno-prakticheskij vestnik «Chelovek i ego zdorov'e», (4): 61-65.
8. Milev Minko Milchev, Simov Maksim Ivanov, Angelova Svetlana Peneva, Velikova Valentina Stepanova 2017. Primenenie 3D-tehnologij v jesteticheskoj dental'noj medicine [Application of 3D technologies in aesthetic dental medicine]. Nauchnye issledovanija: vektory razvitija, s. 50-53.
9. Mitin N.E., Zaharova I.V., Perminov E.S., Kalinovskij S.I. Issledovanie vlijanija immediat- protezov s amortizirujushhej promezhutochnoj chast'ju na reparaciju kostnoj tkani v postjekstrakcionnyj period i osteointegraciju implantatov v oblasti rezcov verhnej cheljusti [Investigation of the effect of immediate prostheses with a cushioning intermediate part on bone repair in the post-extraction period and osteointegration of implants in the upper jaw incisors]. Klinicheskaja stomatologija. 2019. 2 (90): 80-82.
10. Chevychelova O.N., Zubkova A.A. 2019. Realizacija 3D-skanirovanija i 3D-pechati v ortopedicheskoj stomatologii. Priemushhestva i nedostatki [Implementation of 3D scanning and 3D printing in orthopedic dentistry. Advantages and disadvantages]. World Science: Problems and Innovations, s. 239-241.
11. Shustova V.A., Shustov M.A. 2016. Primenenie 3D-tehnologij v ortopedicheskoj stomatologii [Application of 3D technologies in orthopedic dentistry]. Sankt-Peterburg, Obshhestvo s ograni- chennoj otvetstvennost'ju «Izdatel'stvo «SpecLit», s. 159.
12. Abduo Jaafar and Karl Lyons. 2013. Rationale for the Use of CAD/CAM Technology in Implant Prosthodontics. International Journal of Dentistry, p. 1-8.
13. Abduo Jaafar, Karl Lyons and Mohammed Bennamoun. 2014. Trends in Computer-Aided Manufacturing in Prosthodontics: A Review of the Available Streams. International Journal of Dentistry p. 1-15.
14. Anderson J., Wealleans J. and Ray J. 2018. Endodontic Applications of 3D Printing. International Endodontic Journal. Blackwell Publishing Ltd 51(9): 1005-1018.
15. Brown Gregory B., G. Frans Currier, Onur Kadioglu and J. Peter Kierl. 2018. Accuracy of 3-Dimensional Printed Dental Models Reconstructed from Digital Intraoral Impressions. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 154 (5): 733-39.
16. Chan Hsun Liang, Kelly Misch and Hom Lay Wang. 2010. Dental Imaging in Implant Treatment Planning. Implant Dentistry 19 (4): 288-98.
17. Chen Jianyu, Zhiguang Zhang, Xianshuai Chen, Chunyu Zhang, Gong Zhang and Zhewu Xu. 2014. Design and Manufacture of Customized Dental Implants by Using Reverse Engineering and Selective Laser Melting Technology. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 112 (5): 1088-1095.
18. Choi Jong Woo and Namkug Kim. 2015. Clinical Application of Three-Dimensional Printing Technology in Craniofacial Plastic Surgery. Archives of Plastic Surgery. Korean Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons 42(3): 267-277.
19. Dawood Andrew, Susan Tanner and Iain Hutchison. 2013. Computer Guided Surgery for Implant Placement and Dental Rehabilitation in a Patient Undergoing Sub-Total Mandibulectomy and Microvascular Free Flap Reconstruction. Journal of Oral Implantology 39 (4): 497-502.
20. Dodziuk Helena. 2016. Applications of 3D Printing in Healthcare. Kardiochirurgia i Torakochirurgia Polska. Termedia Publishing House Ltd 13(3): 283-293.
21. Ishida Yoshiki and Taira Miyasaka. 2016. Dimensional Accuracy of Dental Casting Patterns Created by 3D Printers. Dental Materials Journal 35 (2): 250-56.
22. Jeong Yoo Geum, Wan Sun Lee and Kyu Bok Lee. 2018. Accuracy Evaluation of Dental Models Manufactured by CAD/CAM Milling Method and 3D Printing Method. Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics 10 (3): 245-51.
23. Kalman Les. 2018. 3D Printing of a Novel Dental Implant Abutment. Journal of Dental Research, Dental Clinics, Dental Prospects 12 (4): 299-303.
24. Kasparova Magdalena, Lucie Grafova, Petr Dvorak, Tatjana Dostalova, Ales Prochazka, Hana Eliasova, Josef Prusa and Soroush Kakawand. 2013. Possibility of Reconstruction of Dental Plaster Cast from 3D Digital Study Models. BioMedical Engineering Online 12 (1).
25. Kim Taehun, Sangwook Lee, Bae Kim, Dayeong Hong, Jinhee Kwon, Jae-woo Park and Namkug Kim. 2019. Accuracy of a Simplified 3D Printed Implant Surgical Guide. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry S0022-3913(19)30416-0.
26. Lee Keun-Young, Jin-Woo Cho, Na-Young Chang, Jong-Moon Chae, Kyung-Hwa Kang, Sang-Cheol Kim and Jin-Hyoung Cho. 2015. Accuracy of Three-Dimensional Printing for Manufacturing Replica Teeth. The Korean Journal of Orthodontics 45 (5): 217.
27. Liu Qingbin, Ming C. Leu and Stephen M. Schmitt. 2006. Rapid Prototyping in Dentistry: Technology and Application. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 29 (3-4): 317-35.
28. Louvrier A., P. Marty, A. Barrabe, E. Euvrard, B. Chatelain, E. Weber, and C. Meyer. 2017. How Useful Is 3D Printing in Maxillofacial Surgery? Journal of Stomatology, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. Elsevier Masson SAS 118(4): 206-212.
29. Martins Leandro Moura, Fabio Cesar Lorenzoni, Alcides Oliveira de Melo, Luciana Mendonga da Silva, Jose Luiz G. de Oliveira, Pedro Cesar Garcia de Oliveira and Gerson Bonfante. 2012. Internal Fit of Two All-Ceramic Systems and Metal-Ceramic Crowns. Journal of Applied Oral Science 20 (2): 235-40.
30. Miyazaki T. and Y. Hotta. 2011. CAD/CAM Systems Available for the Fabrication of Crown and Bridge Restorations. Australian Dental Journal 56 (SUPPL. 1): 97-106.
31. Moser Norman, Petra Santander and Anja Quast. 2018. From 3D Imaging to 3D Printing in Dentistry - a Practical Guide. International Journal of Computerized Dentistry 21 (4): 345-56.
32. Nayar Sanjna, S. Bhuminathan and Wasim Bhat. 2015. Rapid Prototyping and Stereolithography in Dentistry. Journal of Pharmacy and Bioallied Sciences. Medknow Publications 7(1): 216-219.
33. Neumeister Andre, Linda Schulz and Christoph Glodecki. 2017. Investigations on the Accuracy of 3D Printed Drill Guides for Dental Implantology. International Journal of Computerized Dentistry 20 (1): 35-51.
34. Oberoi Gunpreet, Sophie Nitsch, Michael Edelmayer, Klara Janjic, Anna Sonja Muller and Hermann Agis. 2018. 3D Printing-Encompassing the Facets of Dentistry. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology. Frontiers Media S.A. 6: 172.
35. Rhee Ye Kyu, Yoon Hyuk Huh, Lee Ra Cho and Chan Jin Park. 2015. Comparison of Intraoral Scanning and Conventional Impression Techn.Using 3-Dimensional Superimposition. Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics 7 (6): 460-67.
36. Salmi Mika, Kaija Stiina Paloheimo, Jukka Tuomi, Jan Wolff and Antti Makitie. 2013. Accuracy of Medical Models Made by Additive Manufacturing (Rapid Manufacturing). Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery 41 (7): 603-9.
37. Shah Pratik and B.S. Chong. 2018. 3D Imaging, 3D Printing and 3D Virtual Planning in Endodontics. Clinical Oral Investigations. Springer Verlag 22(2): 641-654.
38. Sinn Douglas P., Joseph E. Cillo and Brett A. Miles. 2006. Stereolithography for Craniofacial Surgery. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery 17 (5): 869-75.
39. Tahayeri Anthony, Mary Catherine Morgan, Ana P. Fugolin, Despoina Bompolaki, Avathamsa Athirasala, Carmem S. Pfeifer, Jack L. Ferracane and Luiz E. Bertassoni. 2018. 3D Printed versus Conventionally Cured Provisional Crown and Bridge Dental Materials. Dental Materials 34 (2): 192-200.
40. Wang Chen and Lin. 2019. A Collaborative and Ubiquitous System for Fabricating Dental Parts Using 3D Printing Technologies. Healthcare 7 (3): 103.
41. Wang Ning, Jie Li, Xiaolong Wang, Gang Liu and Bin Liu. 2015. 3D Printing Personalized Implant Manufactured via Fused Deposition Modeling: An Accuracy Research. Hua Xi Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. West China Journal of Stomatology 33 (5): 509-12.