Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

/ 1= : J?101-,, 0-0 1-1 , , ><12 +,0 1-<1,/ 6 +* 1< ; !1 /,<,L ?1 , , !K1 G, +1 >1 /,+!2 71 / 1 0,:<,= ,<1 : ; 6 = ,<1-,-,*%(1 1< 1#$$E1"(1: , ?1+ " + :,0 08 51M0 ; : K?10-!/ +101-+!1015K-< ! " (1 ,1 <!1I0 21<,= 1, ; : 71/,<,L71016, ,0,+7 ,<1!G,6 1 :1= : 1 :+ 2 <,1 ,+7 ,; <!?1 01 -+!2 1 -+ 1 , 1 ,6 , ,1 0>-= 1 !K1 / ,-7 !?1 1 / , 01M0 : 1 1 !6 10,: = 71 ,-+ !<1 :160!G10 2 51 1 " !//>1M-/ ,0J#(1

,60,6*1,/ 6 + >51 ,"?1<,= ,1: < 7?12 ,1M0 : *1 1 <,= 1 > 71 <--,0,51 < 6 H-,51 / ,5(1 8 1 -+K2 ; +7 *1 1<-< +7 ,1 "+ < ,0 *1/ ,H 6! 1M0 : *1 6,+= 1 > 71+ " + :,0 1 1 , P <+ <, 1/ 0,12 +,0 1 > 71 : 0+ ><1, 1 0> ,-<>G1-6 5(1

,;/ 0>G?16,+= >1 > 71,/ 6 + >1 , G,6 <> 1!-+,0 *1 / < *1M0 : 111

911/ H 1-6 1, 1 :+ 2 <,5?1-< +7 ,51 ,+ : Y1 911,-!-0! 1/-/ 0 1, > *1 1/ < *1< 6 H ;

-G1-6-01, 16 ,51 ,+ : 101 2 1,-08 ",-*1-, 1= : Y1 91 1 01 :!+7 1 ,+ : 1 / H 1 -6 1 , 1 0> ,-<,51 ,+ ?1 + ,10 6 1 -!L-0,0 ?1 / <+ <,1, < +7 , ?1 : 0-*L 1, 16 !" G1+K6 5?1 + 1, 1-!--0 ,",1/,66 = *1

= : Y1

911/ H 1 1-/,-, 1/, , 2 71-1-, ,51 :1/,-, , 51 /,<,L (1

,;0 , >G?1 6,+= 1 > 71 : , ,6 +7 ,1 : /+ 1 / ,H ; 6! 1,., <+ *1M0 : ?1,-,0 > 1<,< >1 , , ,51/ 6+,; = >1 (C(1 0><11

911-,"+-1 ,+7 ,",1 1/,+!2 1 ., < H 1,1-0, <1: ; ,+ 0 Y1

911/ 6,-0+ 1-,51 ., < H 1,1: ,+ 0 1 ,+7; ,<!1 1 ",1 ,6-0 <Y1

911-,: +7 *1 1!-,52 0 *1/ ,-7 1 ,+7 ,",1, 1M0 : Y1 91/ ,0 6 1!"+! + ,",1/-G,+," 2-,",1--+ 6,0 *?1 0 +K2 KL ",1 01 - *1 ,/ 6 + 1 -,H ,/-G, / 1 + 2 ,-?1 1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(113C6F7'17,H ,+," 2-1 1/ 0,0> 1-/ >1M0 : 1331 ,/ ,->1/ 0 (1 %EE#(1Q1#(1

#1 15K-< ! " 1/ + < 1+ " + :,0 +1M0 : K13318,<<-;Fmkdml(1#$$&(1#$1. 0; +*(1

1

= 1 -+K2 1 : ,+ 0 5?1 < KL G1 01 -0, G1 / ,*0+ *G1 -<+ 1 1-< Y1

91 1 /,/> 1 /-G, / 0 2-,51 , H 1 !-,0 1 ,+7 ,",1 1M0 : KY1

911/,6 0 =6 1-,: +7 ,51 1!-,52 0,51/ ,-7 >1 ,+7; ,",1, 1M0 : 101/-!-0 1 60, 1S/ 6-0 +*T?1 , ; !-?1-!6 ,",1/-G ?1!/,+ ,<,2 ,",1/,1/ 0 <12 +,0 1 S , +7 ,1 : 0 *1 ., < 1 : 0 L *1 -1 , < ,51 ,1 6-/,; -, ,-1 1-1! : <1M0 : 101 2-0 1/,-+ 6 510,+ TY1

911-,:6 1 : 0-<,",1 1 5 ,",1M-/ ,",1-,0 16+*1 ,H 16 " ,: 1 1/ ," ,: 1: ,+ 0 *Y1

911/ ,0 6 1/,6", ,0 +7 >G1/ 0,,G +7 >G1< ,; / * 516+*1, != *1/ : ,010,:<,= ,",1/-!/+ *?1 1 = 16+*1! ,2 *1/, *6 1-+ 6,0 *Y1

91 1 / ,0 6 1 : > ,",1 -!6 ,",1 :-6 *1 6+*1 /,6 0 ; =6 *1!-+,0 51/ < *1M0 : 1S-1, *: +7 ><1!2-<1 1: +K2 <1/ , ! , TY1

911-!6 , 1 8 Y1 911,-!L-0+ 1M0 : Y1

911,., <+ 1/ , , ,+ 1,1/ ,0 6 1M0 : 1S-1, < ; ,51,1/-!-0 1 1 ,-H 1-< T%(1

1

25 35 " 165&35 "1 1 1ED1

1

%(18 ,11<,= 10>-!/ 711, P ,<1M0 : V1 #(1,2 <!101-,0 < ,<1< 10,: ,-+ 1 ! +7;

,-71/ , + <>1M0 : V1

R(18 1 -!L-0!K 1 0 6>1 M0 : 1 1 2 <1 , 1 / H / +7 ,1, + 2 K-*16 !"1, 16 !" V1

@(18 1 -0*: 1 M0 : *1 1 - -0 > 1 S,-,0; > T1/ 0 12 +,0 V1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1" 5 3F7' ((10,11-< 71331 -1E!< ,",1! 0-(17 *110,(1 Q1%(S%T(1%EEF(17(1@%(1

1

1

1

3 233 D3B3CB+ DE &233 3+5CD 5 3

1

1

5,:! "1/ 012 +,0 10-"6 1 >+101 0 " 6 1 , 7 >1: 16 ; <, 2-1 / , :,0 *?1 / , 01 / , :0,+ 1 1 1 : 1 -0, ,6!1 1-!0 ,-71+ 2 ,-(1

,-G,=6 1 / 0 1 , 6 + <,1 , 1 0,: ,0 *1 1 /,; -+ 6!KL ",1 :0 *1 , ,8 *1 < =6!1 2 +,0 2-< 1 6 0 ; 6 < 1 1, L-0,<(1O+ < *1 10 = 58 *1/ 6/,->+ 1<-; -,0,",1+ 2 ,-,",1 :0 *101-,0 < >G1!-+,0 *G1: +K2 ; -*101 ,<?12 ,1, L-0,1" ! 1-0, <12+ <10,:<,= ,-71 0; , ,< ,",1/,0 6 *(17 <,1-!L-0,0 1 6 0 6! +7 ,-12 ; +,0 1/,1,/ 6 + K1 -0*: ,1 -1 ",1 : 0-<,-7K?1/,+ , ,51 -<, + : H ?1, 0-0 ,-7K1 1 H 0 ,-7K(1U , ,6 ; +7 , 1/ : 1: 1 =6><12 +,0 ,<1 ",1 0-0 ,51 1 ; ++ ! +7 ,51 : 0-<,-?1 -/,-, ,-1 -<,-,* +7 ,1 0>; 71 H + 1 1 -6-0 1 6 * +7 ,-?1 G 1 /,0 6 *1 1 (6(1 / 6-0+* 1 -, ,51/ 0, 2 +,1/ 0 1H 0 + :,0 ,",1, L-; 0 (1 ,+ 1 ,",?1/ 0 12 +,0 10>G,6* 1: 1/ 6 +>1-!"! ,1K 6 ; 2-,",1/, * *?1-,0*-71,6 <1 :1,-,0 >G1 , H / ,01-,0 ; < ,51 / 2-,51 . +,-,. 1 S<, +7 ,5?1 / 0,0,5?1 /,+ ; 2-,5T(1 , * 1I/ 0 12 +,0 J10 101- *1-,+7 ,1-<>; -+,0?1G :!KL G1 ,"-0,1 ",1-,6 = *111

911/ 0 12 +,0 1 1< 1-0, ,6>Y1 911/ 0 12 +,0 1 10> = 16,-,-0 1+ 2 ,-Y1 911/ 0 12 +,0 1 1/ *: *1 1,/ 6 + > 1 + " 1 1

0,:<,= ,-1 G16,-= *Y1 911/ 0 12 +,0 1 1H ,-, 1," 2 10+-Y1 911/ 0 12 +,0 1 1-/,-, 1, " : H 10: <,, ,8 51

" =6 1 1",-!6-0 (11 7,H +7 *1H ,-71-! 1/ 012 +,0 ?1 <1, ;

:,<?1: +K2-*101-/,-, ,-1,/ 6 +* 71 < 1 0 ,-?1-,; H +7 ,1 /,+ : > 1 ., <>1 /,0 6 *1 6 0 6 1 01 G1 + 1 >G1 -. G1= : 6 * +7 ,-?1 <1 -<><1, -/ 2 0 71!-,52 0>51

1

"

1 1

/, *6, 1 01 , L-0 >G1 , ,8 *G(1 D-! 1 / 01 2 +,0 1 / /*-0! 1 : , ><10< 8 +7-0 <101 ",12-!K?1, L-; 0 !K1 1 6 +,0!K1 6 * +7 ,-71 -,1 -, , >1 7 G1 + H?1 01 ,<1 2-+ 1 -,1 -, , >1 ",-!6-0 ?1 , -/ 2 0 *1 ,/ < +7 , 1 -,2 ; 1-0, ,6>1 1-/ 0 6+ 0,-(1

0,0, 1, -/ 2 1 : 0-<,-1+ 2 ,-?10> = KL ; -*101" *G1-0, ,6>1-+,0 ?1-,0-1 1 (6(?1-,:6 1, L-0,1I ; ,<>-+*L GJ?1 ( (1 +K6 5?1 -/,-, >G1 1 -,:6 K1 , " +7 >G?1 0, 2-G1 1,/ 0 >G1 8 5?101 ,<12-+ 1 1 1/ 6-0 +7; -0!1," ,< ,",1 : ,, : *1-,01+K6 5?10>:>0 KL <!1 ,+ 1 " 1 1 , 1/ 0,0> 1-6-0 1 "!+*H 1 G16 * +7 ,-(1F ; L-0 , 1 :0 ?1 1 1 :0 101/ ,6 10,, L ?1 0,:<,= ,1 0 16 0 H 5191, +, 51, 1 , <>Y16 !", 16 +,?12 ,1M 1, +, ; *1<,"! 1 > 71-,H +7 >< ?16-! 0 >< (1

4 + :1/ 0 101 ",1+ 2 ,-,<1 :< 1/ 6/,+ " 1/ ;-1 H 1-1 G1-0,5-0?1 1 "!+ ,0 1 1/ !=; 6 ?1 1/, * 1-0, ,6>(1

: 1 =6,",12 +,0 1 -0, ,6 ><1, 1 ,=6 *1910 ; + 2 58 1: 0, 0 12 +,0 2-0 (13,--5-, 1, L-0,1-",6 *1 /,;/ = <!1-1 !6,<1,-0 0 1 6 K1,1 ,<?12 ,1-0, ,6 1 1/ 0,1 91 6 *1 -! 7(1 ,: ,=6 1 , H /H 1 / 01 2 +,0 1 01 8 51 -1-+,1 ,",<1 G 1 /--0 ,51- -<>1: , ,6 +7-; 0 ?1, L-0 ,51 , G,6 <,-1-,:6 *1!-+,0 516+*10,:-; *1-,H +7 ,5?1M , ,< 2-,51 1/,+ 2-,51 H 0>?1,"; =6 *1 =6,51+ 2 ,-1, 1",-!6-0 ,",1 127 ",;+ ,1/ ,; :0,+ ?1 ,",<1 , 7 >1 / 0,: L ,01 1 +!28 G1 / 6-0 ; + 51 ! 1: 10 G,0-0,1/ 0 1 61: , ,<(1

7 ",6 *1 01 -1 8,-!H 1 3 1 0 +K2 >1 , < 0 > 1 /,+,= *?1 -1 6,-,2 ,51 /,+ , ,51 0,-/ , :0,6*L 1 ,-,0 > 1 / 0 1 1 -0, ,6>?1 / : > 1 < ,0><1 -,, L-0,<(1 7,"+-,1 -(1%)18,-!H 13 1, L / : > 1/ H />1 1 , <>1< =; 6! ,6 ,",1/ 0 1 1< =6! ,6 > 16,",0, >13,--5-,51 6 ; H 1*0+*K-*1-,-0 ,512-7K1 1/ 0,0,51- -<>1 1 < K 1 / , 1/ 61 , < < 1 H , +7 ,",1: , ,6 +7-0 ?1 ,< 1 -<,51 8,-!H (1 , 1 /,+,= 1 6 +1 , !-+,0+ ,1 ,-, ,51 H ,-7K1< =6! ,6 ,",1/ 0 ?1: +K2 KL ",-*101, , L 1 1 , H H 1/ 0,0,51- -<,51-,0, !/ ,",1,/> 10-512 +,;

0 2-,51H 0 + : H ?1/ 2 <1,-, !K1 ,+710>/,+ * 1-<1-/,-, 1 , <,, :,0 *?1 /,+!2 08 51 01 , 1 < =6! ,6 ,",1 / 0 1 :0 1 I-,"+-,0 *1 0,+7J?1 -0*: >51 -1 !0 = <1 1 ,-,0; ><1 / 0 <1 2 +,0 ?1 6, ,-,0-><1 0>/,+ <1 < =6! ; ,6 >G1, *: +7-0?1-/,+7:,0 <1-+7-0 >G1-/,-, ,01 / 0,, -/ 2 *(1 06 ?1 , < 2-*?1 2 ,1 /, 1 01 8,-!H 1 3 1 + 101-/ H +7 ,<1. 6 +7 ,<1: , 1 1 !6 1: /+ 1-; 2 />0 KL 51 / 2 71 , L / : >G1 / H /,01 < =6! ; ,6 ,",1/ 0 1 1 1/,*0-*16 . 0 *1K 6 2-*1 , < 1,1 -,6 = 1 =6,",1 :1 G?1 !6 ,1/ 6/,+ " 7?12 ,1-(1%)1 !6 1 / 2-1 + :,0 Y1 1< 10 = ,1 < 712 , 1 , < 0; , 1/ 6-0+ 1,1-/,-, G1/ ,6,+ *10,:<,= >G1K 6 2 ; -G1 ,++ : 51< =6!1 H , +7 ><1 ,--5-<1: , ,6 +7-; 0,<1 1 , < < 1 1, >2 *< 1< =6! ,6 ,",1/ 0 (1

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

06 ?1,= 6 *?12 ,101/-/ 0 1/ 0 1 1-0, ,6>12 +,0 1 01 8 <1, L-0 1/ , ! 1 /,-6-0 ,1K 6 2-, 1: ; 2 1 1-! 1 <1/ 1 8 1K 6 2-G16 +101-!6 G1 1 6 !" G1 K 6 2-G?1 01 ,<1 2-+ 1 < =6! ,6 >G1 , " G?1 1 -, 1/ 71 0 >G1 ++K: 5(1 ?10>-, *1,H 1 , >1 0 ,; / 5-,51- -<>1 , ,+*1 61-, +K6 <1/ 012 +,0 10>:>; 0 1/,-,* ,1-!L 51 1 51-1-,1-, , >1" =6 1",-!; 6-0?10G,6*L G1016 !K1- -<!?1 1-,, 0-0 ,10,:-1 ,+ 2-0,1 = +, (1 W-+,1 = +, 1 -1 1 01 -0*: 1 -1!0 + 2 <1 2-+ 1",-!6-0191!2-,01B0 ,/ 5-,51 , 0 H 1/,1: L 1

1

$