Материал: ERShOV_Yu_G_FILOSOFIYa_PRAVA-1

1 1

><?1" !//,0><1 1 6 0 6! +7 ><1-<?1 6 0 6>1-+ ; 0 K-*1 -1 6 + <<,511 + ,1 G ,-1 1 G *?1 2 0 > 1 -+ <1 1 0: <,- + <?1+ ,1/ 6-:! <>5?10-, L 51 1H +-,, ; : >51 /, *6, (1 2 <1 01 M ,<1 ,-1 0 = ,1 /,62 ! 71 6 K1D(4(1D+7 1, ,-+7 ,1/ ,6>1/! + 2 ,;0+-,",1 ; "!+ ,0 *1 2 +,0 2-G1 0: <,, ,8 511 IA,+= 1 > 71 , , 2 +7 ,1 , 0 " ! 1 " +7 >51 / 6--!6, 1 ,1 I0 8 5J1 / ,6 1/ 0 1 1",-!6-0 ?16,+= 1 > 71!-<, 1 1!-0, 1 G1 I0 ! **J?1 I6!8 0 ,;6!G,0 *1 -!L ,-7J%(1 ,1 D(4(1 D+7 !?1 : 2 1/ 0 101 ,<?12 , >1-,:6 0 71016!8 12 +,0 1<, 0>1 6+*1+!28 ",1/,0 6 *(1 : 1/,+,= +7 ,",1/ 0 1-,-, 1 01 ,<?12 ,12 +,0 ?1!-<, 01-1,2 0 6 ,-7K1 ",1, P 0 , 1-,; 6 = 1 1, P 0 , 1: 2 ?1-<1, *= 1- *1-, +K6 71 ",1 / 0 + ?1, !-*1 1 G1 1 ,+7 ,101-+!2 *G1/ * *1-,:; +7 >G1 8 5?1 ,1 1-0, G1 /,-6-0 >G1/, >0 G1 1 ; -0 >G1/, !=6 *G(#1

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

.! H ?1-/ H . 1/ < * <>G1< ,6,0?1-,, ,8 1-1 , ; 51",-!6-0 1 1/ 0 (1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%1! )A57!1F1-!L ,-1/ 0,-,: *1331D+7 1D(4(17,2(11 1#1 (11C(?1%EER(1 (%(17(#'F(1

#1! )A57!(17, (1],2(11 1%$1 (1 (@(11C(?1%EE@(17(1%&$9%(1

F6 1 :1 / 0, 2 +7 >G1 0 ,01 ,/ 6 + *1 / 6< 1

. +,-,. 1/ 6-0+ 1 ,2 ,51: *1A(4(8 <,0 (1F 1-2 +?1 2 ,1I/ 6< 1. +,-,. 1/ 0 1<,= ,1,G :,0 71 1 :;, !1+," ?16 + 1 1 , 1/,: *1/ 0,0,",1 > *J%(1 , 1/, < 1. +,-,. 1/ 0 10 +K2 101 1/ 6< !K1, ; +-71. +,-,. K1 1 , K1/,: *?1, L !2 > 1< ,6>?1,G; 0 >0 KL 1 /,61 M" 6,51 . +,-,. 1 < =6-H /+ > 1 -0*: ?1 2-, !2 > 1 1 -/ H +7 > 1 < ,6>1 /,: *?1 0> = KL 1 01 ,+78 51 -/ 1!= 1/ ,6!1/ 0,0,",1: *(1C ,6,+," 2 ; -1.! H 1. +,-,. 1/ 0 101M ,<1-+!2 1, L >1 1 + :!1 /! 51 1< ,6,01/,: *1/ 0 10,10-<1 ",1, P < ?10 ! G1 -0*: 51 1 6 H 51: , ,< ,",1 :0 *1/ 0,0>G1*0+ 5101 G1 6-0 ?1H +,-,-1 1- -< ,-(1

?1 / < ?1,/ 6 + 71K 6 2-, 1: 2 1 G1 ; ", 51 1 I0 J1 1 I, 0-0 ,-7J?1 :1 + : 1 G1 -0*: 1 -1 -,6 = <1 . +,-,.-G1 ", 51 I/ 2 J1 1 I-+ 6-0 J1

1 2-0 1 / < 1 <,= ,1 !/,<* ! 71 6-!--K?1 : " ; 0 KL!K1/ , + <!1K 6 2-,",1/, < *1->(17 ",6 *1. ; +,-,.-1 0 >< 1 0>"+*6* 11 6 *1 ,1 0,:<,= ,-1 6,-= *1-,+K ,51->101-!6 ,51/ Y1/ , 0,/,-0+ 1-; >1 1 :!+7 1K 6 2-,51,H 1/-!/+ *101-!6 ; ,<1 : +7-0 1 1,H 1, L-0 ,;/,+ 2-,51,/-,; -1-,0 8 ,",1/-!/+ *?1 0 ,1 1 1/ 6-0+ 1,1. ; G1 / 0 1 01 2-0 1 -,+K ,51 0 2 ,51 ->#(1 7,0 < , 1 /, < 1->1 1., <>16 * +7 ,-1-! P 1/,: *1 1 6 5-0 *1-0*: ,1-1 10 +K2 <101I6 5-0 +7 ,-7J1 16!G,0; !K1 +7 ,-7(1-H 1-0*: 1->1-1/,+ : ,-7K1: 51 1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%13 AD6F7,1 6< 1. +,-,. 1/ 0 1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1%EE@(1Q'(1

#17<(1 / < 119C6F7' !1D-101!",+,0 ,<1-!6,/ , :0,6-0 1331-1C,-,0; -,",(1! ; (17 (1%%(1%EE)(1Q1RY1 - -.7' (1 ,-!1+ 1 , <>1: , ,01->V1331 E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1%EEF(1Q1'(1

1

-0*: 1 1/,+ , >1-1 2 <10 < 1< ,6,+," 2-1 , ,1 -,, 0-0! 1 -!=6 1 ,1 ,<?1 2 ,1 -1 /,<,L7K1 -!6 ,51 0-1 I!-0+ 0 K-*1 ,+7 ,1. >1 1, -,* +7-0 ?1 < KL 1!",; +,0 ,;/ 0,0, 1: 2 (((1/ 6< ,<1-+ 6-0 ,510-1*0+*; K-*1 1+K > 1. >1 1, -,* +7-0 ?1 1+ 871-!L-0 > 16+*1--+ 6! <,",16 + 1 1+ 87101" H G1/ 6< 1!",+,0 ,;/ ,H-; -! +7 ,",1 6, :>0 *J%(1 D+ 1 = ?1 / < ?1 ! :>0 1 ( (1 70 2 ,011IZ-< 8 1/, * 51I,-,0 J1 1I!-+,0 J1S. +,; -,.-G1 ", 5(191/$(T1 +,= +,1-0,51, / 2 , 1 1 1/, ; < 1/, * *1I*0 1-1/,0 ,5J(1 , , > 1K->1! 0 =6 ; K ?1 2 ,1 *0 1 -1 /,0 ,51 *0+*-*1 ,-,0 <1 ,-0, ,=6 *1 , 1 !",+,0 ,51, 0-0 ,-?12 ,1-(1')1->0 1 < ,1*0 !1-1 /,0 ,5?1 2 ,1 ,-+7 > 1 , -,* +7-0 1 ,-0, ,=6 *?1 / 2-; + > 1016 ,51-7 ?1 1 >16,/,+ *K 1*0 !1-1/,0 ,5?1 1/,1 ,+78,<!1-2 !1 G1 + 2 1 1, *: +7 ,(1C =6!1 <1 ,+7 ,1-!<; < 10-G1/ 2-+ >G1016-/,: H 12(1%(1-(')12813 1, P 0 >G1 1 -! P 0 >G1!-+,0 51 -,-0+* 1,-,0 191 -,0, !/ ,-716,; /!-<>G16,-,2 >G1/ : ,016+*1,-0, ,=6 *1, 1!",+,0 ,51 , 0-0 ,- #(1

5," ,;< ,6,+," 2-*1 .! H *1 .+,-,. 1 / 0 1 /,1 , ; ,8 K1 1K-/ !6 H 1 <1 ,+ 10 = ?12 ,1!"+! + 1/ ,; H--1/,: *1/ 0 10>0,6 1: 1/ 6 +>1-! ! ,51, " : ; H 1K 6 2-,",1: *1S/ + 6 > 1 ! 191,-+ 0> 191-; , ,; , 2-T(17 ",6 *1 :0 1" =6-,",1/ 0 1 ; <>-+ <,10 1M , ,< 2-,51 , ?1!",+,0 ,",1910 1< 6 H >1 1 /-G,+," ?1 6<-0 ,",1 91 0 1 , 1 !/ 0+ *?1 -; < 5 ,",1910 1M 1 1 (6(11

G 2-51/ ,"--1/ 0,6 1 1 ,<!?12 ,101/ 0,/ < ; +7 ,516 * +7 ,-10-1 ,+78 1<-,1: < K 1/-!/+ *1 1/ ,-!/ ?1-0*: > 1-1-/,+7:,0 <1 G 2-G1!-,5-01 :+ 2 ,",1 : 2 *11 M ,+," 2-?1 -/, > ?1 /,= >1 1 0: >0>?1 -0*: > 1 -1 -/,+7:,0 <1 G ?1 1 < ,", 1 6 !", (1 ,M ,<!1 , +,= ,51 / 2-,51 : 6 2 51 -,0-*1 ,2 *1 0 + . H *1 I G 2-GJ1 / 0, !8 5?1 , -/ 2 0 KL *?1

11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

%17<(110A5 A570 017+ 6-0 > 10-101!",+,0 ,;/ ,H--! +7 ,<16, :>0 1331 3,--5-51K 6 2-51=! +(1%EER(1Q1#(1

#1F3 2C6F7' '14 ! +7 > 10,/ ,->1,-0, ,=6 *1, 1!",+,0 ,51, 0-0 ,-101-0*; : 1-16 * +7 ><1-* <1331E,-!6-0,1 1/ 0,(1%EEE(1Q1%#(17(1)R9))(1

-1,6 ,51-, , >?1<-< +7 >51M..1-+>1: , ?1-16 !",5191-+K2 KL *10,:<,= ,-71/ 2 *1!L 1, L-0!1 1" =; 6 !1 / < <1 , ,-,0 >G1 -H 5(1 3 :!<-*?1 6+*1 ,",12 , >1 8 71M !1/ , + <!?1 , G,6 <,1-1 ,+78 51 ,2; ,-7K1/ 6-0+* 71-,-01/ 0, !8 *101/,+ ,510: <,-0*; : 1 0-G1 , :!KL G1 ",1 / : ,0?1 , = KL G1 -!L-0 > 1 M+ < >1/ ,-G,6*L ",1-, > *(1

,M ,<!?1 6 1 + 1 271 , 1 ,/ 6 + 1 /,+ 2-,51 / ; -!/ ,-1 + 1!-,0+ 1/ : ,01 !8 *1 H , +7 ,",1 1-,0,",1 0 ,/ 0 *?1,1/ 0,0,<1 "!+ ,0 1,G >1, !; = KL 51-6>1 + 1, 1!",+,0 ,;/ 0,0>G1/ , + < G1-/+ ; H 1, " ,01 1 512 +,0 ?1910,10-G1M G1-+!2 *G1-, -0 ; ,1/ 0,0, ?1K 6 2-, ?1 8 1,-,0>0-*1 1/ 6< ,<1 -,6 = 1 ,/ 6 + ,",1 0 6 1 2 +,0 2-,51 6 * +7 ,-?1 0 +K2 ,51 01 .! H , ,0 1 !+7 ! >?1 , L-0 1 01 H +,<(1 7+ 6,0 +7 ,?1 1 6,+K1 . +,-,. 1 / 0 1 0>/ 6 1 + : H *1 " 0 ,51 .! H 1 .+,-,. 1 /,1 , , L K1 :!+7 ,01 :0 *1 0-51 - -<>1 !2 ,",1 : *1 / < +7 ,1 1 K-; / !6 H ?1 0>*-K1 , L ",1 G 1 1 / 0+ ,-1 G1 0: <,6 5-0 *(11

!2 , 1/,: 1/ 0,0,51 , <>1 1," 2 0-*1 ,+7 ,1--+ 6,0 <1 1-! ! ,51, " : H ?1: ,0,51., <>10>; = *?1/ ,51 + : H ?1 ,1-1 , G,6 <,-7K1/ 6/,+ ; " 10>*-1-, 2-G1 1-,H +7 >G1!-+,0 51 1/ 2 1 1 /,*0+ *?1 M..0 ,-1 6 5-0 *1 M ,51 , <>1 1 "!+*H K1 , L-0 > 1 , ,8 *1 1 /,0 6 1 " =6 (1 F-K6 1 -+ 6! 1 0>0,61 ,1 ,<?1 2 ,1 / 0,1 91 -+,= >51 -,H +7 >51 . ,< ?1 0 +K; 2 >51 01 .! H , ,0 1 1 :0 1 , L-0 1 1 - -<>1 : ,, : >G1, L-0 >G1, ,8 5191M , ,< 2-G?1/,+ ; 2-G?1 0-0 >G?1 6 <," . 2-G1 1 (6(1 ,M ,<!1 0,:; <,= ,1 1 , G,6 <,1 -0 71 0,/ ,-1 ,1 0: <,6 5-0 1 , L 51 , 1/ 0 1 1-,H +7 ,51. +,-,. 1 1.! 6 < +7 ,",1 :; 6 + 1, L 51. +,-,. (11

,+ 1 ,",?1-, *1. +,-,. 1 1/ 0,0,51 , 1/, :>0 ; ?12 ,1 < ,101 8 1/ , + <1: , ,< ,-51, L-0 ,; ",1 :0 *?1,/ 6 + 1-,01 +--,01 1-,H +7 >G1" !//?1 0>*-16!G 1M/,G 1 G,6* 1, = 16 !"1016 !" 1. +,-,. *1

1

1/ 0,(1 2 <1M 1 8 *101, , G1-+!2 *G1<,"+ 10> = 7-*101 0-7< 1, , L ,51 1, 0+ 2 ,51., < ?1/ < *10 61 :+ 2; ,;! 0-+7 >G1/ H /,0(1 0,-,: 101-0, 51 H , +7; ,; -,51., < 10>G,6 1 1! ,0 71, L 51 , 1,1/ ,; 6 1 1 : 2 1, L-0 1 12 +,0 ?1-<> *-7101-0, <1-,6 = ; 1 -1 , +-7K1 -, -0 ,1 . +,-,.-G1 0,/ ,-,0?1 6 = 1 / 6; -0+**1-, ,51, :?10 1-,H +7 ,51. +,-,. (14-16,+; = 1 < 710 * , 1/ 6-0+ 1, 1,-,0 >G12 G1 1: , ,; < ,-*G1 :0 *1, L-0 ?1/ 2 G?10>:>0 KL G16 0 , 1 /,0 6 ?1 /-!/ ,-7?1 / 0,0,51 " + :<?1 0: <,6 5-0 1 :+ 2 >G1., <1, L-0 ,",1-,: *(1

1 -,0 < >G1 . +,-,.-,;/ 0,0>G1 --+ 6,0 *G1 ; ! +, ,10,:-1 ,+71 ,/,+," 1/ 0 ?1 :0 0 KL 5-*101 -<,-,* +7 !K1 , 2-!K1 1 !2 !K1 6-H /+ !(1 O ,1 -0*: ,1 1-1, L <1 ,/,+," 2-<1/,0, , ,<101-,0 < ; ,51. +,-,. 1 101H +,<1, L-0,: ?1 1 1-1/ < 1 " =6-,",1, L-0 1 1/ 0,0,",1",-!6-0 ?1 !",+7 ><1 < <1 , , >G1*0+*K-*1/ 0 1 1-0, ,6>12 +,0 (1 1H 0 + ; :,0 ,<1, L-0 12 +,0 10-101 ,+78 51-/ 1, 1 :; < 1 I2 +,0 1 K 6 2-,",J1 S^_`_1 abcded]bfT?1 / 0,0, 1 > 1 , , ,",1 -,-0+* 10 = >51<,< 1 6 0 6! +7 ,",1 1 -,H +7 ,",1 > *(1B-+ 1/ 0,0!K1 , K1-! 101/ 0!K1 ,2 671-!H , +7 , 1 > 1/ 0 ?1 ,1/ 0,0!K1 ,/,; +," K1 -! 1 M<,H , +7 ,;0,+ 0, ?1 -,+," 2-, 1 , ; ,8 1 2 +,0 1 1 / 0!1 91 01 : 0-<,-1 , 1 ",1M 2-,5?1 !+7 ! ,;H 0 + : H , ,51 6 2 ,-(1 1 / 0,0,51 ,; /,+," 1 1 / 6 51 /+ 1 0>G,6* 1 "!<-2-1 -/ >1 ",-!6-0 ,;/ 0,0,516 * +7 ,-191/ 0,0 *1 !+7 ! 12 ; +,0 1 1, L-0 ?1/-G,+," *1/ 0 ?1-0, ,6 12 +,0 101 6 ; -0 1 1" 51 1," 2 5(1

g 0 + : H *10>:0 + 1 1= : 1. +,-,. K1 1-<,-,* +7; , 1 , 2-, 1--!=6 ?1 1-<+ 1/, * 71-, 1 1 !-,5-0,1< 101H +,<1 1-,H +7 ,51= : 1012-,-(1g 0 ; + : H *1= 1/, ,6 + 1/ 0, 2 +7 ,101+, 1. +,-,. 1 1 , ; 2-, 1/ 0,-,: ?1-<!1I 6 K1/ 0 J(1 ,1, ,8 K1 16 5; -0!KL <!1 / 0!?1 ,., <+ ,<!1 : , ,6 +7 ,?1 . +,-,. *1 / 0 1-,G * 1-0,K1, ,-+7 !K1-<,-,* +7 ,-7(171-<,;